What are the capabilities of the Sosna air defense system in confrontation with Ukrainian attack drones?

16

Without a reliable air defense system, it is impossible to talk not only about a successful offensive with decisive goals, but even about effective defense. A new type of threat emanating from slow-moving and small-sized, but no less deadly drones, requires a reconsideration of existing air defense systems, air defense missile systems and air defense systems.

Dangerous "trifle"


The fact that understanding of the severity of this problem has finally reached the very top can be evidenced by the statement of President Putin, made during a recent extended meeting of the board of the Russian Ministry of Defense:



Air defense operations also require improvement. Of course, our well-known systems - Pantsir, Buki, S-300, S-400 - work flawlessly, they are the best in the world without any exaggeration. But what we didn’t pay attention to before, we thought that it was some kind of trifle, some kind of plywood and so on, some small drones that fly - no, it turned out that this also causes damage, and this should not be missed under any circumstances.

Indeed, the entire existing air defense system was built against completely different types of threats - missiles, ballistic and cruise missiles, airplanes and helicopters, etc. And then it suddenly turned out that primitive low-speed UAVs filled with explosives were capable of flying over the entire Moscow, covered by, in fact, the best known missile defense system, and hitting the Kremlin. Chinese-made civilian quadcopters costing several thousand dollars effectively destroy tanks and other serious military equipment. machinery worth millions of dollars. Cheap FPV drones carry out deadly hunts on individual military personnel, and, alas, often successfully.

The problem is systemic in nature, and it can only be solved comprehensively, building a layered air defense system. There are already some progress in this direction: we recently told about the appearance of a deeply modernized version of the Pantsir-SM air defense system, designed, among other things, to combat drones using specially created small-sized anti-aircraft missiles.

The only catch is that you can’t stock up on any “Shell” for the entire LBS, not to mention covering with them peaceful cities and all critical infrastructure facilities that require protection from long-range strike drones. We need something quite effective, at the same time relatively inexpensive and widespread, but what?

"Pine"


In addition to the Derivatsiya-PVO anti-aircraft artillery complex, built on the basis of the BMP-3, the promising short-range air defense system Sosna may well lay claim to the role of a lifesaver.

The complex was developed as a successor to the Strela-10M3 air defense system, and its main purpose is to protect military units from air attacks in any type of combat, including during a march. Its task is to intercept air targets that have overcome the defenses of long- and medium-range complexes. The maximum range of the air defense system is 10 km, the height to which it can reach is 5 km. Sosna is capable of shooting down missiles flying at a speed of 250 m/s, helicopters accelerating up to 100 m/s, and airplanes at up to 300 m/s.

Twin-engine guided missiles 9M340 Sosna-R with a warhead weighing 7,2 kg develop speeds of up to 900 m/s. Unlike the Strela, the air defense missile system's ammunition capacity has been increased to 12 pieces. The anti-aircraft complex is built on the basis of the tracked chassis of the MT-LB multi-purpose transporter, and it can fire at a speed of 25-30 km/h, right on the march. In addition to the “moto league”, the anti-aircraft module can be installed on the basis of the BMP-3, BMD-4 or BTR-82. That is, this is what is needed to cover troops during an offensive.

The Sosna crew consists of only two people - a driver and an operator. This is achieved through the use of an all-round viewing station, which is capable of operating in both automatic and semi-automatic modes. The developers decided to abandon the use of radar: monitoring the air situation is carried out using a multi-channel automatic all-weather noise-proof optical-electronic control system, where the laser is used as a rangefinder, and optics determine the angular coordinates of the target.

Thus, an interesting working option emerges for providing anti-drone, and not only air defense. "Sosna" successfully passed tests and a decision was made to put it into service. It can be optionally equipped with small-sized, highly maneuverable 19Ya6 interceptor missiles, developed specifically for the Pantsir-SM air defense missile system. Together with the Derivatsiya-PVO anti-aircraft artillery complex, this air defense system will be able to provide cover from air attacks.


In addition to MT-LB, BMP-3, BMD-4 or BTR-82, the Sosna module can be placed on towed two-axle semi-trailers, like the British Rapier-2000 short-range air defense system. This would make it possible to make the anti-aircraft complex more affordable and widespread, protecting a larger number of valuable objects from enemy UAVs.
16 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. -1
    7 January 2024 14: 55
    By the time Sosna reaches the army in small quantities, the enemy will already reach Moscow with his drones.
    1. 0
      11 January 2024 00: 20
      It's almost enough
  2. +2
    7 January 2024 14: 59
    All available air defense systems do not have protection against mini UAVs, quadcopters weighing hundreds of grams, and other “mosquitoes”. At long distances it is difficult to detect, such a one will fly up with a warhead, and there is no “Sosna” or “Derivation”. This problem is high time to be solved, perhaps with mini-mortars with grapeshots or something similar. Of course, electronic warfare comes first.
    1. 0
      7 January 2024 17: 01
      According to reviews, 2-barreled 23 mm ZUshki are used without automatics and in some cases they are shot down.
      1. +1
        7 January 2024 22: 06
        “Sometimes they shoot you down” is a very bad option. There are camouflage shots of 6-8 or more on the sides of armored vehicles. On their basis, you can create cardholders without large investments. The main thing is to create and make a grape shot for them. Connect 6-8 on a light anti-aircraft machine for transfer. In the manual version, 2-3 with a butt is more mobile. (For grenade launchers there is an earlier proposal). This will help at first, until more advanced samples are created. Given modern realities, “saving drowning people is the job of the drowning people themselves”
    2. 0
      13 January 2024 00: 05
      Derivation was created for such purposes.
  3. 0
    7 January 2024 19: 06
    For almost 2 years, the SVO has never heard of the S-350 Vityaz, I haven’t heard what is the situation with them?
    1. 0
      13 January 2024 00: 04
      Yes it works.
  4. DO
    +1
    7 January 2024 20: 05
    Yes, here and now at least Pine on a heavy trailer.
    But in the near future, to protect trenches and logistics routes from FPV drones, a compact version of the anti-drone canister air defense system is needed, which would fit on a household 4-wheeled walk-behind tractor, or on a Niva trailer.
    1. +3
      7 January 2024 21: 47
      Yes, at least they won’t install anything, if there are no regular officers, then all this will not give much effect.
      But it seems that there is no one to fight in the Russian army except soldiers.
      How can you sell such a new complex that was received in a single copy just a few days ago.
      They write that the estimated price is about 250 lyams.

  5. 0
    8 January 2024 10: 15
    "Twin-engine rockets"?From what hangover? belay The Sosna-R missile defense system is a bi-caliber missile (130 mm and 72,5 mm...) similar to the Tunguska and Pantsir air defense systems! Where did the “author” get the second engine?

    It can be optionally equipped with small-sized, highly maneuverable 19Ya6 interceptor missiles, developed specifically for the Pantsir-SM air defense missile system.

    Rockets for "Pantsir" are radio-controlled! "Sosna-R" - laser-beam guidance! In the first versions of the Sosna-R air defense system, radio control was used for a short time (!) to place the first booster stage on the line of sight ... but there is information that in the latest versions they abandoned radio control!
  6. +1
    8 January 2024 12: 07
    Place the Pine on the T55/T64 platform, which are in storage, and you will be happy.
  7. +2
    9 January 2024 02: 28
    What missiles are there against babies, and especially their swarms? Where are the dusty Shilkas, at least to survive for now, with cartridges with remote detonation? Is the caliber too small for this?
  8. 0
    10 January 2024 00: 01
    As far as I understand, air defense is needed in order to avoid being hit.
    What if:
    1. Build a moving object whose walls cannot be broken through?
    2. The shock wave can either be damped in it, or deflected...

    And in such a “super-fortress” it’s stupid to drive/swim/fly wherever we need to go. )))
    1. +1
      11 January 2024 21: 55
      And elephants, by definition, do not fly. For such a crawling “super fortress” they will quickly whip up a super projectile, a super winged bomb, and a hundred times cheaper. The eternal path: weapon-defense... Here we work comprehensively, with different components, as A. Pokryshkin defined: height, speed, maneuver, weapon. Something like that.
  9. 0
    13 January 2024 00: 03
    "Pantsiri", "Buki", S-300, S-400 - work flawlessly,

    Hmm....the statement is certainly interesting, but stupid. Fleet headquarters, ships at the docks, S-400 launchers... and there was a lot more...
  10. The comment was deleted.