Strategic Culture: "Putin's Munich speech turned into reality"


The Second World War was the heyday of Washington's "soft power". From Melanesia to Europe, American soldiers brought freedom and the American Dream. The United States became the most powerful state on the planet, which was consolidated in Bretton Woods and San Francisco in the form of a new world order. Only the USSR and its satellites still resisted, writes the online publication Strategic Culture.


Until 1972, wages and productivity were linked. Everyone got richer together. Since then, they began to disperse. Productivity has been growing, but wages are not. In 1989, social inequality increased dramatically. The total wealth of the richest 1% of Americans was six times the wealth of the poor.

Now this figure is 15. The overwhelming majority of people really feel that they will never live better. The COVID-19 pandemic further undermined the reputation of the United States and the West as a whole as an effective governance system. The 2020 elections and their aftermath will also not benefit the US's reputation as a democratic society.

The post-American era began on January 6, 2021. Joe Biden's inauguration ceremony looked like the enthronement of a dictator after a coup d'état. Dissenters in the United States began to persecute, freedom of speech was abolished, and the opposition began to be labeled as an "internal terrorist". This could be called an inglorious end to US soft power. The propaganda of decency and freedom is over.

The whole world is watching with interest what is happening in the United States. The West no longer looks successful in the eyes of other civilizations. Now the West is literally consuming its capital, while China is increasing its own.

The turning point can be called the recent WEF online summit in Davos, which took place on January 27, 2021. During the event acted Russian President Vladimir Putin. In his speech, the Russian leader actually recalled that what he said in 2007 in Munich was confirmed.

Looking back, it is really easy to see that Putin's Munich speech has become reality. There is no longer the Washington Consensus or the unipolar world, and soft power is preparing to move to China.
  • Used photos: http://kremlin.ru/
70 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. Alexndr p Offline Alexndr p
    Alexndr p (Alexander) 10 February 2021 18: 56
    +5
    sure. Putin and his analysts are not articles by the wonderful analyst-journalist Seryozha on Topkor. All to the point. To serve in the KGB / FSB is not a thousand articles of water to pour. Serious men are busy with this business.

    The funniest thing is when these wonderful farm-scale analysts accuse Putin of being shortsighted / stupid

    It's even funnier when they give him advice in the comments. And even more funny is that they will not stop doing it. They will use drugs, but they will eat.
    1. goncharov.62 Offline goncharov.62
      goncharov.62 (Andrei) 10 February 2021 19: 13
      +4
      and minus on the site, grunting with pleasure and bitch legs ... (for the time being ...)
    2. Uneven Offline Uneven
      Uneven (VADIM STOLBOV) 10 February 2021 20: 49
      -12%
      In 1990, Russia's GDP was $ 0.51 trillion, $ 5.9 in the US, and $ 0.36 in China. In 2018, Russia's GDP is 1.6 trillion $, in the US - 20.54, in China - 13.6.
      We must assume that Russia achieved these results solely due to the depth of analysis of the special services and their fosterlings in certain positions?
      1. Akuzenka Offline Akuzenka
        Akuzenka (Alexander) 11 February 2021 09: 11
        +7
        You first figure out how they calculate their GDP and how not theirs. And how he is generally considered. And then give these "numbers".
        1. Uneven Offline Uneven
          Uneven (VADIM STOLBOV) 11 February 2021 10: 01
          -6
          1)
          You first figure out how they calculate their GDP and how not theirs.

          a) "they" is who?
          b) How exactly do you propose to "count"?
          c) Do you "calculate" fundamentally different figures? Share?
        2. Ben latin Offline Ben latin
          Ben latin (Valentine Latin) 4 March 2021 20: 14
          0
          ... essentially ...
      2. shinobi Offline shinobi
        shinobi (Yuri) 11 February 2021 11: 24
        +7
        And where do you live, and why are you so happy about our difficulties? The question is not who earns how and on what, but the fact that, unlike the dollar, the ruble is confirmed at least by sary. cut green paper. Take the printing press from the US, and they don't even hide it, and the US economy will dramatically shrink by an order of magnitude, or even two.
        1. Uneven Offline Uneven
          Uneven (VADIM STOLBOV) 11 February 2021 13: 00
          -7
          Take the printing press from the United States, and they don't even hide it, and the US economy will sharply shrink by an order of magnitude, or even two

          So take it away! Who's stopping you?
          1. shinobi Offline shinobi
            shinobi (Yuri) 11 February 2021 13: 01
            +3
            And in the process, if not blind
            1. Uneven Offline Uneven
              Uneven (VADIM STOLBOV) 11 February 2021 17: 22
              -6
              Only a few biblical characters could have survived to this miracle ...
              1. shinobi Offline shinobi
                shinobi (Yuri) 12 February 2021 08: 39
                +1
                Blind. Well, there is nothing to help. Medicine is powerless.
                1. Uneven Offline Uneven
                  Uneven (VADIM STOLBOV) 12 February 2021 08: 41
                  -3
                  Condolences ...
          2. Knight Offline Knight
            Knight (Vladimir) 11 February 2021 16: 33
            0
            So the God's chosen people pillar behind the cowboys, yes, God forbid, God forbid every Teresa Usraken to sit with them.
      3. Dear sofa expert. 12 February 2021 11: 14
        +3
        In 1990, Russia's GDP was $ 0.51 trillion, $ 5.9 in the US, and $ 0.36 in China. In 2018, Russia's GDP is 1.6 trillion $, in the US - 20.54, in China - 13.6.

        Where do you even get your numbers ??? Do you invent it yourself?

        China:
        1990 - GDP 1,12 trillion.
        2018 - GDP 25,36 trillion.
        growth - 2162%

        U.S.:
        1990 - GDP 5,96 trillion.
        2018 - GDP 20,49 trillion.
        growth - 244%

        Russia:
        1990 - GDP 1,19 trillion.
        2018 - 4,05 trillion.
        growth - 241%

        https://ru.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Список_стран_по_темпам_роста_ВВП

        As you can see, the growth of Russian GDP for the specified period of time is quite comparable with the American one. Although I do not understand at all, why was it compared? If, then at least by PPP. And this, in the context of this article, would be useless.

        And by the way .. about the article .. if you carefully read the article itself, you should have noticed that only 7% of the general condition is in 99% of the US population, and 93% (!) Is concentrated in the hands of only 1% of the population.

        Is this a reason for you to admire something here, and even set the United States as an example?

        What kind of “cry from the heart” is pushing you to this? The call of the ancient "ukrov"?)

        PS If you lived in the USA, then you, with your feeble mind, would definitely not find yourself in this 1%.
        1. Uneven Offline Uneven
          Uneven (VADIM STOLBOV) 12 February 2021 12: 51
          -3
          Although I do not understand at all, why was it compared?

          Based on these figures, we can conclude that Russia, while maintaining the current rates of development of its economy, has hopelessly lagged behind the leading countries of the world.

          Links sent in a personal.
          1. Dear sofa expert. 12 February 2021 13: 23
            +3
            Based on these figures, we can conclude that Russia, while maintaining the current rates of development of its economy, has hopelessly lagged behind the leading countries of the world.

            Links sent in a personal.

            You sent this link to me in a "personal":

            Interactive Links: Russia / Gross Domestic Product
            US / Gross Domestic Product
            China / Gross Domestic Product

            Utopia of "real" GDP and PPP http://www.internettrading.net/vvp-gdp-pps-ppp-vcollege/

            It was not by chance that I asked you a question: where do you get your numbers from?

            Now it becomes clear ...
            "VCollege
            The first school of exchange trading and investing in Russia ”!

            Are you kidding everyone here?

            SCHOOL OF TRADING AND INVESTING!))

            Some advertising theses of this "school", inviting such idiots as you, what are they worth !:

            “... If you are subconsciously drawn to trading, know that you are a special person. The idea of ​​trading is visited by only a small part of the world's population, its most adventurous and independent .. "

            "... We are perfectly aware that 5-10% of all Russian speakers, taking into account the peculiarities of the mentality of compatriots and the conjuncture of the already difficult Russian market, is the most optimistic limit of our target audience today ..."

            http://www.internettrading.net/vvp-gdp-pps-ppp-vcollege

            Do you have any education at all, besides this "SCHOOL"?
            1. Uneven Offline Uneven
              Uneven (VADIM STOLBOV) 12 February 2021 13: 49
              -4
              1) You could not consistently insert 3 links into the search bar? (!)
              2) What does some kind of "advertising" have to do with it? (!)
              Did you manage to master the proposed text?
              1. Dear sofa expert. 12 February 2021 13: 54
                +3
                1) You could not consistently insert 3 links into the search bar? (!)

                Chatter is not essential.

                2) What does some kind of "advertising" have to do with it? (!)
                Did you manage to master the proposed text?

                Yes, imagine, I opened your link and "mastered the text", which is what I wish for you, since you yourself have not yet fully read this nonsense.

                I went to this "vCollege", walked through all its nooks ... you gave me a link for this?

                I do not understand the course of your "thought".)
                1. Uneven Offline Uneven
                  Uneven (VADIM STOLBOV) 12 February 2021 14: 03
                  -3
                  I do not understand the course of your "thought"

                  How fine you need to chew ...

                  1) Have you figured out GDP for three countries?
                  Have you managed to insert three links in succession into the search bar? Did you press ENTER?
                  Are there interactive graphs of GDP for each of the three countries?
                  Did you move the mouse according to the schedule?
                  Have you chosen interesting years for you?
                  Have you compared?
                  2) Did you manage to open the link with foreign letters?
                  Found an article about GDP?
                  Have you read it?
                  Any thoughts after reading?
                  1. Dear sofa expert. 12 February 2021 14: 11
                    +1
                    1) Have you figured out GDP for three countries?
                    Have you managed to insert three links in succession into the search bar? Did you press ENTER?
                    Are there interactive graphs of GDP for each of the three countries?
                    Did you move the mouse according to the schedule?
                    Have you chosen interesting years for you?
                    Have you compared?

                    There is no objective information, sorry. There information is only for such "special people" as you.

                    2) Did you manage to open the link with foreign letters?
                    Found an article about GDP?
                    Have you read it?
                    Any thoughts after reading?

                    See above.
                    1. Uneven Offline Uneven
                      Uneven (VADIM STOLBOV) 12 February 2021 14: 36
                      -2
                      Please, give at least a couple of examples of "bias" from the materials on my links.
                      1. Dear sofa expert. 12 February 2021 15: 50
                        +3
                        Please, give at least a couple of examples of "bias" from the materials on my links.

                        A couple of examples? Are you kidding me?
                        There, the entire article - from beginning to end, as A. Raikin said - "an indiscriminate gagging of epoch-making significance."

                        Yes, here's a shot .. arguments about PPP ..:

                        if in New York a cup of coffee costs 5 dollars, and in Moscow 200 rubles, then the "natural exchange rate" should not be 70 rubles per dollar, but 40.

                        The fact that the price difference is not least due to the costs of transporting coffee, customs duties, taxes and other "conventions" of a living economy, although PPP theorists are aware, is not taken into account in practice.

                        Why lead anyone reading this nonsense by the nose?

                        Everything can be explained much more simply:

                        PPP: Dollar (within the US) against the ruble, in dollar terms (within Russia)

                        So, we have the initial data: Official dollar exchange rate = 83 rubles.
                        1000 $ = 83000 rubles.

                        You - live in Chicago (USA)
                        Family - 3 people.
                        You have $ 1000 in your hands.

                        I am in the city of Omsk (Russia)
                        Family - 3 people
                        I have in my hands 83000 rubles (equivalent - 1000 US dollars)

                        Please live in Chicago with your family of 3 people for one month for $ 1000. I'll take a look.

                        Well, and I, respectively, in Omsk - for 83000 rubles. And you, too, look if you are still alive by that time.

                        So.

                        In order for you to be able to stupidly live with your family in Chicago for just one month, you will need at least $ 6000, because $ 1000 at purchasing power parity (PPP) within the United States is a meager amount.

                        And in Russia, 83000 rubles, an amount that is quite sufficient to live a month. And let's say - not starving.)

                        This means that in purchasing power parity (PPP), 83000 rubles (in Russia) is roughly equal to $ 6000 in purchasing power parity (PPP) in the United States.

                        Here's a real PPP estimate.

                        Think about what I have written, and stop already littering the brain of yourself and others with all sorts of rubbish.
                      2. Uneven Offline Uneven
                        Uneven (VADIM STOLBOV) 12 February 2021 17: 33
                        0
                        The striking difference in GDP data with and without PPP can be demonstrated by a close and well-understood example.

                        Here's what the dynamics of Russian GDP look like, taking into account purchasing power parity:

                        2013 - $ 3,59 trillion;

                        2014 - $ 3,612 trillion;

                        2015 - 3,471 trillion US dollars.

                        Answer your own question: can these figures be used to form at least some kind of meaningful idea of ​​what is happening with the Russian Federation and its economy? Do you see any dynamics here? Traces of at least some crisis? Production drops? Mass impoverishment of the population?

                        Here is the same dynamics, but without PPP deformation:

                        2013 - $ 2,113 trillion;

                        2014 - $ 1,857 trillion;

                        2015 - 1,236 trillion US dollars.

                        I think everything is very clear ...
                      3. Dear sofa expert. 12 February 2021 17: 48
                        +3
                        The striking difference between GDP data, taking into account PPP and without it, can be

                        Again, you are writing some kind of "cardboard fool" here, designed, apparently, for "special people", like yourself.)

                        Can you tell me who is interested in this development dynamics from 2013 to 2015, when we live in 2021?)

                        Show the dynamics from 2015 to 2019 better. (We'll omit 2020 - it's not easy for everyone today).
                      4. Uneven Offline Uneven
                        Uneven (VADIM STOLBOV) 12 February 2021 18: 21
                        0
                        This is just an example. I gave you the figures for a wider range of years for three countries above. And for 2021, the data will be in 2022.
                      5. Dear sofa expert. 12 February 2021 18: 27
                        +2
                        This is just an example. I gave you the figures for a wider range of years for three countries above. And for 2021, the data will be in 2022.

                        Examples should correspond to today's reality.

                        If you want to....

                        make at least some more or less meaningful idea of ​​what is happening with the Russian Federation and its economy

                        and while talking about the Russian Federation and its economy, IN PRESENT TIME (what is happening, and not “what was happening”), then the numbers must correspond to PRESENT TIME.

                        You seem to be confused in yourself.)
                        Go already .. collect your thoughts and come with a fresh mind.

                        Or - to a simpler website (yours, Ukrainian, or where are you from there?)
                      6. Uneven Offline Uneven
                        Uneven (VADIM STOLBOV) 12 February 2021 19: 00
                        0
                        Examples should correspond to today's reality.

                        1) I admit that I am wrong if you give figures for the Russian economy for 2021. (not plan)
                        2) Do you think that something has changed for the better in Russia over the past couple of years? Justify.
                      7. Dear sofa expert. 12 February 2021 19: 19
                        +3
                        1) I admit that I am wrong if you give figures for the Russian economy for 2021. (not plan)

                        In 2022 I will definitely bring it.

                        2) Do you think that something has changed for the better in Russia over the past couple of years? Justify.

                        Do you think it will help?)

                        1992 1703 11 482 н/д н/д 5,2 % н/д
                        1993 ▼ 1591,9 ▼ 10 ▼ -724% ▲ 8,7% ▲ 874,6% n / a
                        1994 ▼ 1419,3 ▼ 9 ▼ −563% ▼ 12,7% ▲ 307,6% n / a
                        1995 ▼ 1389,5 ▼ 9 ▼ −370% ▼ 4,1% ▲ 197,5% n / a
                        1996 ▼ 1363,8 ▼ 9 ▼ −210% ▼ 3,6% ▲ 47,7% n / a
                        1997 ▲ 1406,3 ▲ 9 ▲ 517% ▼ 1,4% ▲ 14,8% n / a
                        1998 ▼ 1345,6 ▼ 9 ▼ -130% ▲ 5,3% ▲ 27,7% n / a
                        1999 ▲ 1452,9 ▲ 9 ▲ 889% ▲ 6,4% ▼ 85,7% 13,0%
                        2000 ▲ 1635,3 ▲ 11 170 ▲ 10,0% ▼ 20,8% ▼ 10,6% ▼ 55,7%
                        2001 ▲ 1757,7 ▲ 12 ▲ 054% ▲ 5,1% ▼ 21,5% ▼ 9,0%
                        2002 ▲ 1869,3 ▲ 12 875 ▲ 4,7% ▼ 15,8% ▼ 8,0% ▼ 37,5%
                        2003 ▲ 2046,7 ▲ 14 ▲ 156% ▼ 7,3% ▲ 13,7% ▼ 8,2%
                        2004 ▲ 2253,9 ▲ 15 647 ▲ 7,2% ▼ 10,9% ▼ 7,7% ▼ 20,8%
                        2005 ▲ 2474,8 ▲ 17 ▲ 232% ▲ 6,4% ▼ 12,7% ▼ 7,2%
                        2006 ▲ 2758,8 ▲ 19 249 ▲ 8,2% ▼ 9,7% ▼ 7,1% ▼ 14,8%
                        2007 ▲ 3073,9 ▲ 21 473 ▲ 8,5% ▼ 9,0% ▼ 6,0% ▼ 8,0%
                        2008 ▲ 3298,7 ▲ 23 ▲ 054% ▲ 5,2% ▲ 14,1% ▼ 6,2%
                        2009 ▼ 3063,8 ▼ 21 ▼ -411% ▼ 7,8% ▲ 11,7% ▲ 8,2%
                        2010 ▲ 3240,9 ▲ 22 ▲ 639% ▼ 4,5% ▼ 6,9% ▲ 7,4%
                        2011 ▲ 3475,4 ▲ 24 ▲ 259% ▲ 5,0% ▼ 8,4% ▲ 6,5%
                        2012 ▲ 3670,4 ▲ 25 ▲ 592% ▼ 3,7% ▼ 5,1% ▲ 5,5%
                        2013 ▲ 3796,8 ▲ 26 ▲ 440% ▲ 1,8% ▬6,8% ▲ 5,5%
                        2014 ▲ 3892,0 ▲ 27 ▲ 072% ▲ 0,7% ▼ 7,8% ▲ 5,2%
                        2015 ▼ 3835,8 ▼ 26 ▼ −658% ▲ 2,5% ▲ 15,5% ▲ 5,6%
                        2016 ▲ 3877 ▲ 26 930 ▲ 0,3% ▼ 7,1% ▼ 5,5% ▼ 15,7%
                        2017 ▲ 4007,8 ▲ 27 ▲ 834% ▼ 1,5% ▼ 3,7% ▲ 5,2%
                        2018 ▲ 4213,4 ▲ 29 ▲ 267% ▼ 1,7% ▲ 2,7% ▲ 5,5%
                        2019 ▲ 4357,7 ▲ 30 ▲ 284% ▲ 1,5% ▬3,7% ▲ 5,5%

                        https://ru.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Экономика_России

                        As you can see, after 2009 there was only one “rollback”. In the year you specified in 1.
                        Well, why did you want to focus on this?)
                      8. Uneven Offline Uneven
                        Uneven (VADIM STOLBOV) 12 February 2021 20: 00
                        0
                        1) I could not find the original information at the address you provided.
                        2) I compared the rates and volumes. The United States, as a producer of world money, could not have been mentioned. For comparison, the PRC is also sufficient.
                        3) Another characteristic indicator of the colonial orientation of the Russian economy is the excess of exports over imports. Find the numbers?
                      9. Dear sofa expert. 12 February 2021 20: 10
                        +2
                        1) I could not find the original information at the address you provided.

                        There below there is a word written in Russian letters: "statistics". click there and watch.

                        2) I compared the rates and volumes. The United States, as a producer of world money, could not have been mentioned. For comparison, the PRC is also sufficient.

                        But you mentioned the United States.
                        Yes, China is ahead of the rest of the world in terms of economic growth. One number of the population obliges him to do this. This was not denied. So what? There are advantages and challenges.

                        3) Another characteristic indicator of the colonial orientation of the Russian economy is the excess of exports over imports. Find the numbers?

                        what for? this is not interesting to me, this is not the topic of this discussion.
                      10. Uneven Offline Uneven
                        Uneven (VADIM STOLBOV) 12 February 2021 20: 55
                        -2
                        But you mentioned the United States.
                        Yes, China is ahead of the rest of the world in terms of economic growth. One number of the population obliges him to do this. This was not denied.

                        Before the USA RF as before Alpha Centauri. I repeat: they print WORLD money.
                        However, it is no closer to China either. But there is another reason - the growth rates that are unattainable for Russia and the volumes of the economy gained over these years. The Russian Federation can still be compared in a number of indicators with Turkey, but, taking into account the trends, here we will only lag behind. By many criteria, Russia is already at the level of a number of African countries.
                      11. Dear sofa expert. 12 February 2021 21: 36
                        +2
                        Before the USA RF as before Alpha Centauri. I repeat: they print WORLD money.

                        Yes, they are printing, yes, far away ..

                        Apparently, therefore, the ratio of patients with coronavirus (and mortality) from it in the United States is also 6: 1 in relation to Russia.

                        Somehow, printing money did not help much for 55 million Americans without basic health insurance.

                        Remember how the dispute started?)
                        I will remind you:

                        only 7% of the total wealth is in 99% of the US population, and 93% (!) is concentrated in the hands of only 1% of the population.

                        This is by the way about what was written in the article.

                        The Russian Federation can still be compared in a number of indicators with Turkey, but, taking into account the trends, here we will only lag behind. By many criteria, Russia is already at the level of a number of African countries.

                        Of course, you can continue to write nonsense here, like this, in the end - making people laugh is also a useful thing.

                        And I already feel sorry for you to waste time. There are much more interesting opponents here.
                        I am more interested when I learn something new for myself. You are not the case. Sorry.
                      12. Uneven Offline Uneven
                        Uneven (VADIM STOLBOV) 13 February 2021 11: 35
                        -3
                        1)
                        Apparently, therefore, the ratio of patients with coronavirus (and mortality) from it in the United States is also 6: 1 in relation to Russia.

                        Linden statistics on the banal seasonal ARI are your "arguments"?
                        Strong!

                        2)
                        Somehow, printing money did not help much for 55 million Americans without basic health insurance.

                        I once argued that capitalism is good?
                        The point is that Russian "reformers" have built Russia into the global economy as a colony and are working diligently to destroy its future ...

                        3)
                        You can of course continue to write nonsense here.

                        Are you not interested in what the current Russian Federation is like in comparison with other countries?
                        Would you like some statistics?
                      13. Dear sofa expert. 13 February 2021 11: 53
                        +1
                        Apparently, therefore, the ratio of patients with coronavirus (and mortality) from it in the United States is also 6: 1 in relation to Russia.
                        Linden statistics on the banal seasonal ARI are your "arguments"?
                        Strong!

                        Why is it fake? Because you yourself do not have enough intelligence to look at statistics on the Internet?)

                        Will this suit you ?:

                        https://news.google.com/covid19/map?hl=ru&gl=UA&ceid=UA%3Aru

                        I once argued that capitalism is good?
                        The point is that Russian "reformers" have built Russia into the global economy as a colony and are working diligently to destroy its future ...

                        Explain who these "reformers" are?

                        Well, according to Yeltsin, I agree. What's next?

                        You can of course continue to write nonsense here.

                        Are you not interested in what the current Russian Federation is like in comparison with other countries?
                        Would you like some statistics?

                        I don't need your statistics, you have some sort of ... to put it mildly, not objective.

                        Everything I need, I find myself.
                      14. Uneven Offline Uneven
                        Uneven (VADIM STOLBOV) 13 February 2021 17: 45
                        -4
                        1)
                        Why is it fake? Because you yourself do not have enough intelligence to look at statistics on the Internet?

                        If you believe all the data that Rosstat fabricates, then I can only express my deep condolences to you.
                        This is an absolutely prostituted organization that gives out exactly the data that is required by the customer. Examples of darkness ...

                        2)
                        will this suit you?

                        Absolutely not! Since all world statistics regarding this nedovirus are distorted to the point of disgrace, since it is absolutely conjunctural and adjusted to specific goals.

                        3)
                        Well, according to Yeltsin, I agree. What's next?

                        And what is fundamentally different from Yeltsin's "deeds" of his last son?

                        4)
                        I don't need your statistics, you have some sort of ... to put it mildly, not objective.

                        I have no statistics. I can only tell you where you can get acquainted with it. And then ... Believe it or not ...
                      15. Dear sofa expert. 13 February 2021 17: 53
                        +1
                        Since all world statistics regarding this nedovirus are distorted to a disgrace, tk. it is absolutely conjunctural and adjusted to specific goals.

                        Well then, there are no statistics, everything is distorted, everything is adjusted ... You think so, your right.
                        Then what do you even want that?

                        I have no statistics. I can only tell you where you can get acquainted with it.

                        Not necessary. All statistics that you can suggest are distorted and adjusted.

                        So I don’t want to.
                      16. Uneven Offline Uneven
                        Uneven (VADIM STOLBOV) 14 February 2021 10: 07
                        -2
                        Not necessary. All statistics that you can suggest are distorted and adjusted.

                        So I don’t want to.

                        Tip: Use the words "everything", "always", "everywhere" less often ... because in this case it will not be difficult to put you in an uncomfortable position ...

                        The ostrich pose and horse blinders are by no means decorating.
                      17. Dear sofa expert. 14 February 2021 12: 39
                        +2
                        Tip: Use the words "everything", "always", "everywhere" less often ... because in this case it will not be difficult to put you in an uncomfortable position ...

                        Your advice, you can leave yourself for a start.
                        So far, reading ALL (without exception) your, not burdened with intelligence, posts, I cannot imagine that you, with your chicken (since I am an ostrich, then you are a chicken) brain, can here anyone except yourself, put in an uncomfortable position.
                      18. Uneven Offline Uneven
                        Uneven (VADIM STOLBOV) 14 February 2021 17: 08
                        -2
                        Why worry so much? If my comments get in the way of your rose-colored glasses, I give you permission not to read them. For my part, I promise not to give you any more good advice. I will try to answer questions on the topic. Are you happy?
                      19. Dear sofa expert. 14 February 2021 17: 19
                        +2
                        If my comments get in the way of your rose-colored glasses, I give you permission not to read them.

                        Do not interfere. I simply don’t read them anymore (in any case, I try not to delve into the “nonsense” of what you said).

                        And I advise others not to do this either.

                        Your opinion, I'm not interested at all.

                        It is much more important for me that MY OPINION was heard.

                        For my part, I promise not to give you any more good advice.

                        This is, so far, the only reasonable thought that I have heard from you.

                        I will try to answer questions on the topic.

                        I no longer ask you any questions. You don't have to bother yourself with answers.
                      20. Uneven Offline Uneven
                        Uneven (VADIM STOLBOV) 14 February 2021 17: 28
                        0
                        It is much more important for me that MY OPINION was heard.

                        Curious, why do you think your opinion is so valuable that you need to read it?
                        For example, I prefer the opinions of specialists. But, unfortunately, this site is banned for such information. Banned even for quotes from speeches of the leaders of Russia (!)
                        The site administration likes only the comments of amateurs - "know-it-alls".
                        The question is: Who does she work for?
                      21. Dear sofa expert. 14 February 2021 17: 37
                        +1
                        Curious, why do you think your opinion is so valuable that you need to read it?

                        Why this question? I find it valuable, so I think it deserves attention. That's my right.

                        For example, I prefer the opinions of specialists.

                        And this is your right.

                        But, unfortunately, this site is banned for such information. Banned even for quotes from speeches of the leaders of Russia (!)
                        The site administration likes only the comments of amateurs - "know-it-alls".
                        The question is: Who does she work for?

                        This question is not for me.

                        PS here everyone is banned if someone starts to give vent to emotions, forgetting to turn on their brain. So instead of being offended, sometimes it's easier, in fact, to give yourself time to collect your thoughts.
                      22. Uneven Offline Uneven
                        Uneven (VADIM STOLBOV) 14 February 2021 18: 02
                        0
                        I find it valuable, so I think it deserves attention. That's my right

                        The most seriously ill is the one who thinks he is healthy.
                        Health to you!
                      23. isofat Offline isofat
                        isofat (isofat) 14 February 2021 18: 18
                        0
                        Quote: Dear sofa expert.
                        ... here everyone gets banned if someone starts to give vent to emotions, forgetting to turn on their brain.

                        The attitude is very loyal, even too much, and this fruit already got to the site, decided to cheat. laughing

                        It seems to me that it is worth obliging the authors of publications, in addition to creating, also maintain order in the discussions, giving them the rights of a moderator. It seems that they are primarily interested in an objective assessment of their articles.
          2. isofat Offline isofat
            isofat (isofat) 14 February 2021 12: 21
            +2
            Dear Couch ExpertSome commentators are so unfriendly with their heads that I often have a question - all their comments, is this an experiment of our science?

            And you and I are ordinary, ordinary observers and unwitting participants in tests of the still imperfect Artificial Intelligence.

            PS This sample is an obvious marriage, which does not have a subject for testing at all.
        2. isofat Offline isofat
          isofat (isofat) 13 February 2021 17: 58
          +1
          Uneven, what you call our Rosstat - an absolutely prostituted organization, says only that you have nothing more to say, and you lost the argument.

          PS Uneven, share your feelings, what do you feel when "prostituted" bends you down? laughing
        3. Uneven Offline Uneven
          Uneven (VADIM STOLBOV) 14 February 2021 10: 00
          -3
          1)
          Uneven, what you call our Rosstat - an absolutely prostituted organization, only says that you have nothing more to say, and you lost the argument

          Firstly, I did not argue with anyone on this topic and I am not even going to.
          Secondly, all my statements are not unfounded and (unlike some "experts") I can prove them with facts.
        4. Dear sofa expert. 14 February 2021 12: 52
          +1
          Uneven, what you call our Rosstat - an absolutely prostituted organization, only says that you have nothing more to say, and you lost the argument.

          The funniest thing, isofat, is that the link I gave it:

          https://news.google.com/covid19/map?hl=ru&gl=UA&ceid=UA%3Aru
          ... It was not Rosstat that "fabricated" (as he claims).)

          I'm just on the Web site, switched it to Russian, so that it would be clearer for him. For obvious reasons, I could not switch to MOV, so his chicken brain poorly accepted these statistics.)
        5. isofat Offline isofat
          isofat (isofat) 14 February 2021 13: 11
          +1
          Dear Couch Expert, this specimen, with a missing subject for intelligence testing, engages in artless insults to our country and its institutions.

          To prevent him from being kicked out of the site, he masks these insults as comments. All.
  • Dear sofa expert. 12 February 2021 15: 19
    +3
    Did you manage to master the proposed text?

    Once again, I was not lazy, and carefully read what was written. In general terms: empty, without any scientific justification, besides, in economic terms, quite illiterate populist chatter, stuffed with contradictions in almost every point, some unconvincing "semi-examples" designed to deliberately chatter the topic.
    Everywhere, some convulsive, at the level of sensation, attempts to "open the eyes", a kind of new look, with a "swing" on fundamental knowledge in economics.
    At the same time, there is always an ineptly hidden, mercantile, commercial interest.
    Apparently, in order to get yourself as many people like you: "schoolchildren" clients.

    Nonsense, in short.
    1. Uneven Offline Uneven
      Uneven (VADIM STOLBOV) 12 February 2021 19: 13
      -2
      That is, in fact, there is nothing to tell you? Q.E.D.
  • Vladest Offline Vladest
    Vladest (Vladimir) 10 February 2021 20: 03
    -10%
    This is in comparison with WHO

    The overwhelming majority of people really feel that they will never live better. The COVID-19 pandemic further undermined the reputation of the United States and the West as a whole as an effective governance system. The 2020 elections and their aftermath will also not benefit the US reputation as a democratic society.

    Obviously not from the Russian Federation. While the people from the Russian Federation are eager for this, the West and the United States, BUT not on the contrary. Maybe China?
    1. Rum rum Offline Rum rum
      Rum rum (Rum rum) 10 February 2021 22: 46
      +4
      Well, how do you know where the people of Russia are striving?
      So I read that the Tribals are eager for British toilets.
      What do you say?
      1. Vladest Offline Vladest
        Vladest (Vladimir) 11 February 2021 10: 16
        -4
        Quote: Rum Rum
        Well, how do you know where the people of Russia are striving?

        Statistics in the Russian Federation are not yet banned))). Broaden your horizons. The same as in the Balts.
        Just then I came across a video about one who from the Russian Federation tore and why. And why hasn't he cleaned toilets in Britain yet. And he still compare the purity in Estonia and the Russian Federation.

        1. Rum rum Offline Rum rum
          Rum rum (Rum rum) 11 February 2021 18: 10
          +2
          Figures and sources? (official) please. (Arrived-departed).
          And certainly in the Tribaltic. (then we take statistics as a percentage of the total population - for comparison).

          Or you will be balabolite.
          (Do gentlemen take their word for it?)

          If you want to sketch you a lot of videos about pigsties in the capitals of Gayrope (near the tower of old man Efel, for example), this is all subjective. And our liberota is ready to throw on the fan on an industrial scale.
          1. Vladest Offline Vladest
            Vladest (Vladimir) 11 February 2021 18: 29
            -3
            Quote: Rum Rum
            Figures and sources?

            I'm tired of writing and repeating. I will only answer your numbers. In recent years, the population of Estonia has been growing due to immigration. And then the form above is an example for you. There are many answers to salaries and prices and living standards.
            1. Rum rum Offline Rum rum
              Rum rum (Rum rum) 11 February 2021 18: 34
              +1
              I thought so.

              Balabol
            2. Rum rum Offline Rum rum
              Rum rum (Rum rum) 11 February 2021 20: 47
              +1
              Chatterbox, so you understand, here you are not a geyrope, you need to confirm your words with reliable sources.
              At home, you can take revenge with a broomstick as much as you like, but here, be kind enough to answer for your words (you said, you brought proof, your words, and leave the European style, unsubstantiated chatter, at home), or write "in my opinion."
        2. Dear sofa expert. 12 February 2021 11: 31
          +2
          Just then I came across a video about one who from the Russian Federation tore and why.

          As I understood from the film, I "rushed" to my girlfriend, plus I saw my personal professional prospects in Estonia. It's a matter of a special case, it happens - and that's good, and that's normal.
          I don’t understand why “drive waves in the glass” and make some kind of “politics” out of it?

          And he still compare the purity in Estonia and the Russian Federation.

          Dear, have you been to Moscow for a long time?
          I’ll find you a bunch of streets there too, “licked like a cat's eggs”.

          You were apparently born to make sure that there would be someone on this site to make readers laugh.)
          1. Vladest Offline Vladest
            Vladest (Vladimir) 13 February 2021 01: 51
            -1
            Quote: Dear sofa expert.
            You were apparently born to make sure that there would be someone on this site to make readers laugh.)

            At least I give on the topic, and you are all about me and about me. Like an old woman on a bench at the entrance.
            Here with figures for explanations. Let it come to someone. This is not for trolls.

            1. Dear sofa expert. 13 February 2021 02: 13
              +2
              At least I give on the topic, and you are all about me and about me.

              Can you only read the last paragraph?)
              On the other hand .. but about whom, if not about you? You are the one who entertains everyone here with your "nonskladushkam".)
              Have you even read the article itself?
              There is nothing written about your Estonia.
              1. Vladest Offline Vladest
                Vladest (Vladimir) 13 February 2021 02: 16
                -1
                Quote: Dear sofa expert.
                Can you only read the last paragraph?)
                On the other hand .. but about whom, if not about you? You are here to entertain everyone with your "neskadushkam".
                Have you even read the article itself?

                The transition to personality is a sign that you are ZERO on the topic. You have not refuted anything of mine.
                The population of Estonia is growing for evil all the trolls)))!
                1. Dear sofa expert. 13 February 2021 02: 41
                  +2
                  The transition to personality is a sign that you are ZERO on the topic. You have not refuted anything of mine.

                  I've already written enough on the topic here. If you have problems with vision, go to the optometrist.

                  There was no need to go over to the personality, since the personality I am in you is not
                  had seen. So don't flatter yourself.

                  The population of Estonia is growing for evil all the trolls)))!

                  As for the trolls, I already told you. Trolls on other people's sites (that's how you are here).
                  And I'm here, on my Russian site, I'm at home, so a priori there is no point in trolling here.

                  You, as I understand it, are already "aged" (well, once you get a pension). Therefore, it is doubly surprising that this age came to you alone, and the mind, apparently, somewhere in adolescence lingered. Could be at least a little wiser here.
                  And so, you, here, at the Maidan level, are only dishonoring your country with your activity.
                  1. Vladest Offline Vladest
                    Vladest (Vladimir) 13 February 2021 09: 30
                    -3
                    Quote: Dear sofa expert.
                    on other people's sites (that's how you get here)

                    There are no "your" sites here. Don't fantasize or "The Site Rules Clause".
                    There is one. TV channels from the Russian Federation where they are not allowed to watch. "This video is not available in your area." ... Then it's yours ..)))
    2. Knight Offline Knight
      Knight (Vladimir) 11 February 2021 16: 38
      0
      I personally do not torn, there is the same chmurafen, the same eggs, only in profile. There is torn Moscow and others like them, And our zero is divided and there will be zero, mathematics, however.
      1. Vladest Offline Vladest
        Vladest (Vladimir) 13 February 2021 01: 57
        -2
        Quote: Knight
        I personally do not torn, there is the same chmurafen

        You can tear, but there is nothing to break out ...
        There will be a little about Russian doctors fleeing to Germany. OTR is the most honest TV channel in the Russian Federation.

        1. Dear sofa expert. 13 February 2021 03: 09
          +2
          There will be a little about Russian doctors fleeing to Germany. ABOUT

          Straight and running?))

          A couple of questions immediately arise:
          1) Who invites them to work there?
          Indeed, in Germany, working as a doctor first requires a special confirmation of this qualification, certification, and a special permit from the state. bodies for the implementation of this prof. activities. All this requires quite a lot of time and (!) A very good knowledge of the German language. And this language, oh what a difficult one.

          2) Where do the German doctors run away, that there are so many vacant jobs for the Russian "running away"?)
          1. Vladest Offline Vladest
            Vladest (Vladimir) 13 February 2021 09: 42
            -3
            Quote: Dear sofa expert.
            Indeed, in Germany, working as a doctor first requires a special confirmation of this qualification,

            Why shouldn't it be okay. There in the program the same thing about doctors from Wed. Asia spoke. They go to Russia and work. They are in the Russian Federation, the Russians are from the Russian Federation.
            I recently came across a figure. About 80 Russians apply for asylum in Germany, about 000 have been refused. And Germany is not alone. It was the same in Finland. People go where it is better.
            If you watched the video there, your uncle told you how ridiculous is the money that is allocated for medicine? 100 billion a year. Conversation immediately at the beginning. And this is in the Russian Federation itself, the Russians themselves say. So they are running. It is not known how long to endure for a year or two and then live normally there or here. They even manage to learn Estonian.
            1. Dear sofa expert. 13 February 2021 10: 46
              +2
              Why shouldn't it be okay.

              And who said that this is not normal?)
              The question is in the real feasibility of this. Here you are mindlessly spreading some kind of "cartoons", writing according to the principle: I heard a ringing, but I don't know where it is. If only to blurt out something offensive to Russia.
              So I asked you a couple of specific questions.
              You could not even adequately answer any of them. All some - slogans, superficial excuses. Puff, puff here, but there really is nothing to say to you here.
              All that you can is to spray your senile bile here on the forum. Life is coming to an end, the pension (500 €) is small. It, at your "European" prices, is only enough to eat a piece of bread, drink water from the water supply, and sit, frantically writing all sorts of nonsense here.

              Essentially you didn't answer me:

              1) How can you work as a doctor in Germany without good knowledge of the German language, having previously learned (without the same language) a confirmation of qualifications, permission, from the state, to conduct medical activities in the country?

              You do not know the answer to this question.

              So why do you even write about something you don't know?

              Write further about your Estonia, there you are at least a "guru", and do not meddle in all this "European jungle". You do not know anything about Europe, sitting on your skinny ass, in your micro-state. Your pension does not even allow you to leave the city.
  • Sergey Latyshev Offline Sergey Latyshev
    Sergey Latyshev (Serge) 10 February 2021 23: 11
    +2
    Everyone was scared, the West is trembling, the dollar is falling, and so on ...

    Except for individual newspapers, no one even remembers about any speeches, and about any national projects ...