The decision window is closing: three options for Western action in Ukraine

11

The increasing frequency of belligerent rhetoric and the West's emerging hawkish plans for Ukraine risk leading to a sharp escalation of hostilities. However, they show that they are based on a sincere recognition that Ukraine has begun to lose its advantage on the battlefield. American political scientist Connor Echols writes about this.

The incitement by France and Poland is the latest evidence that European leaders, fearful of worsening Ukraine's fighting position and angered by Russia's boldness, are beginning to play a more direct role in the standoff.



This points to a difficult conclusion. After more than two years of conflict in Ukraine, Kyiv's main goal - a return to at least 2022 borders - seems increasingly unlikely. As Ukraine's chances of success decline, the West is left with three bad options: try to double down on a losing military strategy, push Kyiv into difficult concessions at the negotiating table, or enter the war directly on Ukraine's behalf.

The decision window is closing quickly

Echols writes in his column.

However, the anger and disappointment that is visible in the West’s reaction to a Russian cruise missile flying into Poland shows a deep understanding of the fallacy of any course of action in Ukraine. The negotiation scenario is quite good and promising, but for Kyiv it is a defeat, and for the West it is a loss of face. And the allies will decide to take this step as a last resort.

So far, only one prospect with an unclear end emerges - NATO and Russia are one step closer to confrontation. Instead of bringing a solution to the conflict closer, it is getting worse due to extraneous reasons, the American scientist complains.

These gloomy forecasts make Ukraine's situation worse. They cause damage even with their mere mention, which is why draft evasion has accelerated, since none of the Ukrainians wants to die without a chance of victory or survival.

In the meantime, the United States and the EU are increasingly drawn into hostilities, while hypocritically claiming that all decisions on the conflict will be made by Ukrainian citizens. Although in fact everything was already decided for them, making them hostages and victims.
11 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. +3
    29 March 2024 09: 02
    Ukraine is already a “living” corpse.
    If she capitulates today, and this is the death of Bandera’s Ukraine, or....
    Let's say, let's say that Ukraine remained in existence as a result of some kind of truce.
    What will be tomorrow.
    The militarization of Ukraine to the level of a nuclear power and a new war with Russia. Even more cruel. The likelihood that a new war will become nuclear is more than high.
    And this means that Ukraine will be completely destroyed, again a corpse.
    Here is such a “fun” forecast.
    1. 0
      29 March 2024 09: 32
      Quote: prior
      Let's say, let's say that Ukraine remained in existence as a result of some kind of truce.
      What will be tomorrow.

      Tomorrow -
      Firstly, she will be taken off pay.
      Secondly, Ukraine will be forced to open the borders, and all the young, active ones will rush to get out, first of all - to earn money, and at the same time - so as not to fall under mobilization in the next round (which will be expected for a long time).
      Thirdly, the birth rate in Ukraine is already extremely low.
      Accordingly, 20 years later it is a sleepy agrarian state, with a small, old population, well, a few licked tourist streets of “the Europe” in Lviv - Odessa - Kyiv.
      1. 0
        29 March 2024 10: 02
        Oleg. You are as always an optimist.
        The West will never give up plans to harm and defeat Russia.
        This is not even discussed. Especially by the wrong hands, in this case Ukrainian nationalists.
        Therefore, he will not leave alone a country bordering Russia, which has an anti-Russian population ready to fight and die for the West.
        They will help with money and weapons, carry out educational work, and, if necessary, organize a provocation.
        If Nazi power remains in Ukraine, the next war in Ukraine is only a matter of time.
        Ukraine is not in danger of becoming a “sleepy agrarian state.” The genes are not the same.
        1. +1
          29 March 2024 10: 45
          Quote: prior
          anti-Russian population

          In any case, this population will decrease and age.
          those. Ukraine’s role will be reduced to the territory from which provocations are possible.
          1. -1
            29 March 2024 11: 24
            Let the population on the territory of the entire former Ukraine age as part of Russia.
            There will be orders of magnitude less provocations and terrorist attacks.
      2. +1
        29 March 2024 10: 42
        Don't be ridiculous. 2014 put everything in its place (Minsk agreements). Even if the quasi-state of Kyiv remains, huge amounts of money will pour in there too. Just to preserve the source of irritation and terror of all liberated territories, etc., etc.
      3. WFP
        +1
        29 March 2024 10: 58
        We can agree about the sleepy agrarian state, but with great reserve. On its territory there will also be closed territories in which mining complexes with military bases will be located to protect them and train militants for you know what. Still, the territory is rich in raw materials, and explored deposits of the same uranium, gold, titanium, rare earths, natural gas, coal, refractory clays, and identified occurrences of diamonds attracted the attention of overseas bourgeois decades ago.
  2. 0
    29 March 2024 11: 07
    All this and similar “forecasts” are simply a diversion with the help of “convenient articles”, IMHO..
    tk. the main feature is Western guarantees on the nuclear weapons deal, such articles are carefully not mentioned
  3. +2
    29 March 2024 11: 43
    If Ukraine is preserved in any form or another state or entity is created on the territory of Ukraine, the problem of war with Russia remains. With such a decision, the war will be transferred to the future and our children and grandchildren will die in it. Is this what you want?
    There is only one solution regarding Ukraine in favor of the people of Russia. The state of Ukraine must cease to exist. The entire territory of Ukraine should return to Russia, in the form of regions. There is no need to ask anyone for permission, everything must be done unilaterally. There is no state, Ukraine, no debts, no Ukrainian government in exile, no legal Banderaites, no Ukrainian participants in various international organizations, no hostile state on the border of the Russian Federation. Russia will strengthen its economic and military-political influence in the world, and there will be direct access to Tiraspol and Chisinau. NATO will no longer have the opportunity to use Ukraine against Russia. The northwestern part of the Black Sea will belong to Russia.
    Even if part of the state of Ukraine is left, then today and in the future, Russia will always have an enemy in the person of Ukraine. Ukraine will definitely join NATO and will definitely attack Russia. Everything that is promised and will be spelled out in the Constitution of Ukraine, in its documents, Ukraine will change, in the way that is beneficial to the United States and its satellites.
    Any half-hearted decision is the defeat and capitulation of the Russian Federation to NATO.
  4. 0
    29 March 2024 14: 00
    There are only desperate cries on German TV and in the media: Russia SHOULD NOT WIN...
    They don’t realize that in this way they are bringing nuclear war closer!
  5. 0
    April 2 2024 13: 05
    Don’t give a damn about the first two options and forget about it. Those on whom the decision-making in Russia depends must remember this. Washington has gone all-in and will stop at nothing.