Why did medieval armies always capture castles rather than bypass them?

8

A castle in medieval Europe was an almost impregnable fortification. Despite the fact that there was a relatively small garrison inside, the capture of such a defensive structure was given to the advancing army at the cost of huge losses.

The castle often stood on a hill, was surrounded by ditches, and from its walls arrows, stones, cannonballs, and even hot tar flowed onto the heads of the attackers. As a result, the best option to capture this structure was a siege.



It is worth noting that this tactic took quite a long time. After all, as mentioned above, the garrison inside the castle was small, and the supplies inside lasted for a long time. In addition, before the attack, the owners of the defensive structure expelled the “common people” from there so as not to waste food supplies on them.

For example, the siege of Candia on the island of Crete lasted 21 years, from 1648 to 1669. It was the longest in history. The Ottomans then lost 240 thousand people, but took the castle.

In this case, the question arises - why did medieval armies necessarily capture castles and not bypass them? After all, this way it was possible to avoid huge losses and preserve the army for a further offensive. There are three reasons for this.

Firstly, treasures, provisions, weapons and other valuables were usually stored in castles, which were promptly brought there in the event of a war. No invading army could refuse such trophies.

Secondly, castles were usually located in such a way as to be able to control the main roads. In other words, the garrison remaining inside the structure would certainly deprive the enemy of logistics if he advanced further without destroying it.

Finally, thirdly. The captured castle acted as an excellent defensive structure for the attackers themselves, in case something went wrong.

8 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. 0
    9 February 2024 10: 14
    The Ershvbolote YouTube channel gives a more detailed description of why in certain cases the castles were either captured or surrounded and moved on. There is also a description of the dangers of leaving certain garrisons of the Armed Forces of Ukraine in the rear for the attackers. With figures for the consumption of shells, food and fuel.
    1. +1
      9 February 2024 10: 17
      Here is an analysis of the reasons for the capture of Mariupol, which was an example of a modern fortress and castle

  2. The comment was deleted.
  3. RUR
    0
    9 February 2024 11: 51
    Castle in medieval Europe

    - this is not relevant for the Turanian civilization, since there were no castles - the first, if you look from the east, feudal castles - only appear on the territory of western Belarus and Ukraine, and even then this is Polish influence... In the Baltics, the few castles were mainly not feudal, but rather played the role of fortresses
    1. 0
      14 March 2024 10: 00
      - this is not relevant for the Turanian civilization

      This is because for them the value was not gold and brocade, but rams and horses. Why would a nomad in the steppe carry around a bunch of gold with him when he will always take it in some castle.
  4. 0
    9 February 2024 12: 20
    Because everything was delicious there. Who cares about a city or a village? What should I take there? Pots? Cows? Skins? And how long will the convoy be if the city is robbed? And a castle or palace - yes, there is gold, art, religious symbols, etc.
    The rest of the reasons are bullshit - roads can be built around them. Dig the castle with a moat so that they don’t climb and that’s it.
  5. 0
    9 February 2024 12: 40
    Why did medieval armies always capture castles rather than bypass them?

    All the people from the surrounding region ran to the fortress, poor empty peasant huts remained around, where there was nothing to profit from, and robbery in wars was the main incentive for the troops. Then the whole question is how they captured, if the fortress is powerful, they took it by ATTRACTION, if there is an opportunity to take it, they tried. With powerful troops, they blocked several fortresses of the state and prepared for the main battles. This is in the Middle Ages, in the North-Eastern Military District, with today's weapons and tactics, it is not necessary to take large cities and created fortresses, it is too bloody and takes too long. The main thing is to achieve a moral turning point in the enemy troops, when victory is no longer possible, then both the troops and garrisons will stop resisting. That is, the strategy of the general state of the state becomes the main thing. The beginning of the North-Eastern Military District was similar to such a strategy, only an erroneous calculation of forces, means and tactics did not allow achieving success. (This is how the Wehrmacht defeated many different countries, by pressure, achieving a quick turnaround in military campaigns). Only the RF Armed Forces continue to act in the SVO without sufficient initiative and forces, protractedly and without pressure for victory, the enemy resists, not seeing its defeat. Conclusion: the strategy of the second stage of the SVO is not designed for a quick victory, but for other goals.
  6. 0
    10 February 2024 17: 56
    Why did medieval armies always capture castles rather than bypass them?

    The answer to this was given by the Tatars under the leadership of the Mongols - the elite were hiding in the castles, which they successfully massacred by opening the locks of the yak crabs in the restaurant.
  7. 0
    15 February 2024 20: 32
    And the Huns bypassed the fortress. Imagine a feudal lord A and B sits in the castle and as a result the lords fight and the lads' forelocks crack as now with one military and special operation and instead of returning the land and people the lads go to hell well okay Nazis and mercenaries and sincere - conscious ones God ordered them and in the graves they will bury those who are not Savchuks but Ivanovs and Danilovs and Antonovs.....