Kedmi: There is not a single country that has survived at least one of the disasters that happened in Russia


Over the past century, Russia has gone through several difficult periods. There is not a single other country on the planet that has experienced at least one of the three gigantic catastrophes that have happened to Russia during this time. Political scientist, former head of the Israeli special service “Nativ” Yakov Kedmi told about this during the program “Straightforward Conversation” on the YouTube channel “Blogger BN LIVE”.


The expert noted that during the specified time period, Russia experienced defeat in the First World War, the collapse of the monarchy and the ensuing civil war, no less horrible in terms of its human sacrifices, World War II and the collapse of the USSR, with the degradation that began after this.

The 90s brought Russia, the state and everything that the USSR was, damage equivalent to the damage in the Great Patriotic War. If the Russian Federation is still on its feet today, it means that Russia has enough strength to revive

- he explained.

Kedmi said that he is optimistic about the future of the Russian Federation. Incredible shocks could not break the will of Russia and its people, and now there is a process of recovery after a period of decline.

He believes that the main problem in Russia is state administration. In his opinion, if the Russian Federation gets rid of those “diseases” that led to the fall of the Russian Empire and the USSR and can “crystallize” a new generation capable of ensuring further development and proper use of its enormous potential, the Russian Federation will become one of the most successful countries in the world.

27 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. A.Lex Offline A.Lex
    A.Lex (Secret information) 10 June 2021 13: 54
    +2
    Kedmi is too kind to us and too optimistic ... To step on the same rake so many times, to look into the abyss so many times ... Moreover, Western worship is not only our problem in the XNUMXth century - it has been with us for CENTURIES ! Until we stop looking into the dupa west, we will have no reason ... The freshest example of inferiority and degradation is the Russian Ukrainian lands ... this is what awaits us, if we don't change our minds. And then a SIGNIFICANT part of our "elite" still cherishes hopes about "entry". Not realizing that we are FOOD for them !!!
  2. Jacques sekavar Offline Jacques sekavar
    Jacques sekavar (Jacques Sekavar) 10 June 2021 14: 16
    +4
    War is a derivative of private property, a method of redistributing productive forces (territories, people, material values) when economic, diplomatic, ideological, religious and other methods do not achieve the goal of the ruling class.
    The First World War was a product of clashes of interests of the ruling classes of different states and a redistribution of spheres of influence.
    The Great October Socialist Revolution is a consequence of the exacerbation of the class contradictions caused by the war and the victory of the new social system under the leadership of V.I. Lenin.
    The Second World War was unleashed by the ruling class of Italy, Japan and Germany with the aim of conquering foreign territories and resources and therefore was just for all other states involved.
    The post-war Cold War was marked by the confrontation between two different social systems and was of a class nature.
    The collapse of the USSR is a consequence of the departure from the theory of Marxism and understanding of the essence of socialism, which led to a gradual decay, formal socialization of the productive forces, the formation of a caste of "untouchables" isolated from the party and the people from the leadership of the party and the state, which ultimately led to Yeltsyn's betrayal, a coup d'etat , the collapse of the USSR, the civil war and the restoration of capitalism.
    The business started by V.I. Lenin did not end with the collapse of the USSR. The banner of socialism, which fell from the hands of the USSR, was taken up by the People's Republic of China, and Deng Xiaoping's reforms returned the Chinese Communist Party to the Leninist understanding of Socialism and the Socialist State.
    1. Cyril Offline Cyril
      Cyril (Kirill) 10 June 2021 16: 09
      -2
      War is a derivative of private property, a method of redistributing productive forces (territories, people, material values) when economic, diplomatic, ideological, religious and other methods do not achieve the goal of the ruling class.

      The war between socialist China and Vietnam then how did it turn out? And between China and the USSR?
      1. Jacques sekavar Offline Jacques sekavar
        Jacques sekavar (Jacques Sekavar) 10 June 2021 18: 07
        +4
        The intra-class struggle within the framework of one ideology is overgrown with problems and leads to conflicts within the framework of one social system, state, political party, because everyone cannot think, understand, decide in the same way, due to different ideas, interests, conditions of material life, which can have both positive and negative role.
        In the USSR, the class of private owners of the means of production was liquidated, which fundamentally contradicted Lenin's understanding of socialism as a transitional stage with elements of two different social systems, then Deng Xiaoping's reforms were based on Lenin's understanding of socialism and were aimed at creating a class of private owners in China, their full support the state under the control of the communist party.
        1. Jacques sekavar Offline Jacques sekavar
          Jacques sekavar (Jacques Sekavar) 10 June 2021 18: 19
          +3
          You know the reason - personal relations, territorial disagreements.
        2. Cyril Offline Cyril
          Cyril (Kirill) 11 June 2021 13: 43
          -3
          War is a derivative of private property,

          Your words? Yours.

          In 1969 and 1979, Deng Xiaoping had not yet undergone any economic reforms aimed at creating private property in China.

          So there is no trace of your "harmonious" logic (no).
          1. Jacques sekavar Offline Jacques sekavar
            Jacques sekavar (Jacques Sekavar) 11 June 2021 20: 30
            +2
            I was in a correctional camp for re-education.
            Read Deng Xiaoping's biography.
            A major party and statesman was arrested for a proposal to turn to the capitalist path of development.
            After his release, he returned to the party ranks and to leadership positions. It is time to "get on your feet" before proposing something different from the dogma of the Great Helmsman. Party decisions are not taken from the bay, especially such historical ones.
      2. Kamaltin Abdulaev (Kamaltin Abdulaev) 11 June 2021 18: 59
        -1
        When was the war between Vietnam and China? And the war between the USSR and China (Father Damansky does not count) Is it debelism or schizophrenia?
        1. Cyril Offline Cyril
          Cyril (Kirill) 11 June 2021 19: 06
          -4
          When was the war between Vietnam and China?

          February-March 1979. It went down in history as the "first socialist".

          And the war between the USSR and China (O. Damansky does not count)

          Why is that "not counting" yet? 800 deaths from the Chinese side, dozens of deaths from the USSR, hostilities that lasted intermittently from March to September 1969 - is that not enough? Well, replace the word "war" with "conflict" - does this fundamentally change something in my question?

          Is it debelism or schizophrenia?

          How do I know your diagnosis?
  3. Binder Offline Binder
    Binder (Miron) 10 June 2021 14: 37
    -6
    Jacob Kedmi in his repertoire is about everything and nothing, empty chatter, devoid of specifics. I am sincerely surprised how this person was able to position himself in the Russian media as an expert on all issues, without exception, from the history of the Ancient World to the COVID-19 pandemic. It is clear that this image was created by Russian propagandists like V. Solovyov for their own needs, but Yasha managed to branch out from his creators and occupy a personal niche in the Russian media space. How can such a gentleman be taken seriously? request And this blogger is completely below any criticism - he managed to attribute the Protestant Rockefeller family to Jews. lol
  4. Sergey Latyshev (Serge) 10 June 2021 14: 38
    -2
    And, the Agent is again pouring sweet poison ... and with the money of the Russian Federation.
  5. All three "disasters" are to blame for the Russian people themselveswho succumbed to the provocations of Yasha's fellow tribesmen, namely:
    1. The revolution of 17 was organized by the Jewish Bolshevik Party at the expense of the Kaiser;
    2. The Civil War and World War II were simply a consequence of the revolution;
    3. The counter-revolution of 91 was started by representatives of the Jewish diaspora, registered in the shadow business. They also staged a total plunder of Russia in their favor, of course.
    Total:
    The criminally gullible and easily provoked Russian people are to blame for all the troubles of Russia !!!!
  6. Alexzn Online Alexzn
    Alexzn (Alexander) 10 June 2021 16: 26
    -2
    Quote: Cyril
    War is a derivative of private property, a method of redistributing productive forces (territories, people, material values) when economic, diplomatic, ideological, religious and other methods do not achieve the goal of the ruling class.

    The war between socialist China and Vietnam then how did it turn out? And between China and the USSR?

    It should be noted that in the primitive communal system ...
  7. Alexzn Online Alexzn
    Alexzn (Alexander) 10 June 2021 16: 30
    -4
    Quote: BoBot Robot - Free Thinking Machine
    All three "disasters" are to blame for the Russian people themselveswho succumbed to the provocations of Yasha's fellow tribesmen, namely:
    1. The revolution of 17 was organized by the Jewish Bolshevik Party at the expense of the Kaiser;
    2. The Civil War and World War II were simply a consequence of the revolution;
    3. The counter-revolution of 91 was started by representatives of the Jewish diaspora, registered in the shadow business. They also staged a total plunder of Russia in their favor, of course.
    Total:
    The criminally gullible and easily provoked Russian people are to blame for all the troubles of Russia !!!!

    How beautifully you have done the great Russian people, which, as you claim, is incapable of not stealing or guarding ...
    1. Alexndr p Offline Alexndr p
      Alexndr p (Alexander) 10 June 2021 17: 17
      +2
      incapable of not stealing or guarding ...

      stealing is bad. This is for primates) The ability to do this is not worth developing. And about - to guard our own - that we can.

      we take ours, don’t worry. Look at the map. There you will see a great people who, in the competition of nations and states, conquered the largest living space and resources for themselves - breaking several empires along the way in a competitive struggle)

      Now look at your wonderful country, which could not withstand the competitive struggle of states and was erased from the face of the Earth, but not completely.

      The big uncles decided that you still need to give your education a chance, but you yourself understand - the story is a cycle. I think a certain degree of luck in your education is that you do not border on Russia. Otherwise, they would break you too)
    2. isofat Offline isofat
      isofat (isofat) 10 June 2021 17: 48
      +4
      Alexzn, but I see that it is you who shield the representatives of your people, and are trying to frame the stranger. However, your brethren always do this, I'm not surprised. yes
    3. alas, yes! not able to
  8. zzdimk Offline zzdimk
    zzdimk 10 June 2021 17: 08
    0
    If the education system had not been touched ... Recently: Ranevskaya was despotic and spread rot Catherine (Ostrovsky + Chekhov). Composition of the exam.
    1. Alexndr p Offline Alexndr p
      Alexndr p (Alexander) 10 June 2021 17: 26
      +2
      If the education system had not been touched ...

      would the citizens of Russia (USSR) still charge water through the TV and buy up MMM shares?
      If it had not been touched - Lenya Golubkov would still be telling us about the prospects - and tens of millions of "educated" people would have walked around, but thrown - without critical thinking and logic

      I'm not a freeloader. I am a partner!

      partner country was wassat highly educated

  9. Alexzn Online Alexzn
    Alexzn (Alexander) 10 June 2021 17: 33
    -3
    Quote: Alexander P
    incapable of not stealing or guarding ...

    stealing is bad. This is for primates) The ability to do this is not worth developing. And about - to guard our own - that we can.

    we take ours, don’t worry. Look at the map. There you will see a great people who, in the competition of nations and states, conquered the largest living space and resources for themselves - breaking several empires along the way in a competitive struggle)

    Now look at your wonderful country, which could not withstand the competitive struggle of states and was erased from the face of the Earth, but not completely.

    The big uncles decided that you still need to give your education a chance, but you yourself understand - the story is a cycle. I think a certain degree of luck in your education is that you do not border on Russia. Otherwise, they would break you too)

    1. Let's all the same on YOU.
    2. Great Russian people - I wrote without any subtext.
    3. My complaints against my opponent were that WHAT FROM HIS CONCLUSIONS follows ...
    We will leave ridiculous reflections about yours and mine on your conscience.
  10. Alexzn Online Alexzn
    Alexzn (Alexander) 10 June 2021 17: 52
    -1
    Quote: isofat
    Alexzn, but I see that you are shielding the representatives of your people, and you are trying to substitute a stranger. However, your brethren always do this, I'm not surprised. yes

    Why should I shield our brethren? In your posts, we are so smart and insidious, we robbed a great people ten times, created a great USSR, destroyed a great USSR ... It's nice to read something like that about your little people, but it's not very pleasant when a great nation is lowered to the level of a simpleton-moron.
    1. Cyril Offline Cyril
      Cyril (Kirill) 11 June 2021 13: 46
      -3
      Ahah)) This is great
  11. George W. Bush - medium (George Bush - average) 10 June 2021 23: 37
    +2
    I am convinced that very little time will pass by historical standards and the United States, together with the EU, will get the full from the descendants of those whom they robbed, raped and at whose expense they got rich.
    Giving green color to the flourishing of tolerance, migration flows, missing out on technological and military superiority, etc. etc., they themselves drove themselves into a hole, from which they are unlikely to get out.
    It is possible that large wars will not be needed, they will simply become a minority and degenerate.
    The main thing is that we draw conclusions.
    1. Vladest Offline Vladest
      Vladest (Vladimir) 11 June 2021 16: 19
      -4
      Quote: George W. Bush - Medium
      whom they robbed, raped and at the expense of whom they got rich.

      You have not become obsolete for these hundred years. Now they are getting richer in LABOR.
      Or tell who and where was robbed or raped, or you are a chatterbox.
  12. Cyril Offline Cyril
    Cyril (Kirill) 11 June 2021 13: 49
    -4
    There is not a single country that has experienced at least one of the disasters that occurred in Russia.

    Jacob Kedmi would somehow read about the history of Cambodia.

    However, most likely everything, he knows her very well - just for money, after being fired from the military structures of Damascus, he tells Russian jingoistic patriots what they want to hear.
  13. Vladest Offline Vladest
    Vladest (Vladimir) 11 June 2021 16: 16
    -2
    How many years out of a hundred was Russia Russia?
  14. Bitter Offline Bitter
    Bitter (Gleb) 12 June 2021 21: 00
    0
    Russian kvass saved a lot of people.

    fellow