Why Russia never loved the Cossacks

30
In the minds of the modern Russian, Cossacks seem to be brave defenders of the Russian land, a little reckless, with their own specific way and long traditions. But for some reason, the relationship between the Cossacks and the rest of the population of our vast Motherland has long been not the best way.





This was most acute during the Civil War. The Bolsheviks perceived the Cossacks as their opponents and made every effort to destroy them as a class. So that policy gossip had deep historical roots.

Cossacks and Russians

Since ancient times, the Cossacks opposed the rest of the Russian people. Even in the class hierarchy of the Russian Empire, the Cossacks were higher than the Russian peasantry and representatives of other nationalities, the so-called "foreigners."

There is a version that there are even ethnic differences between Cossacks and Russians. According to this assumption, the first Cossacks were representatives of nomadic Turkic peoples on the outskirts of Russia - Torques, Berendeys, black hoods and others. Gradually, they mixed with the Slavic population, converted to Orthodoxy, creating a kind of subethnos.

Even today, in some Cossack regions, for example, in the Kuban, one can sometimes hear something like "they have it there, in Russia." In Sholokhov's "Quiet Don" old man Melekhov said:

Smelly Russia will not rule here.


Hitler took advantage of these contradictions in his time, equating the Cossacks with the Aryans and calling them descendants of the Ostrogoths. Many of them succumbed to Nazi propaganda and went to serve in the Cossack units of the Wehrmacht.

The Russian peasantry and the working class reciprocated the Cossacks. Moreover, in the Russian Empire they performed not only military functions, but also punitive ones. Cossacks participated in the suppression of peasant unrest in villages and strikes in cities. They were especially active in suppressing the 1905 revolution.

It is also noteworthy that when Denikin agreed on joint actions with the Terek Cossacks during the Civil War, they set him an interesting condition, demanding that every city they captured should be given for three days for looting. Somehow it does not fit very well with the fact that the Cossacks are Russian people.

Cossacks and “foreigners”

If the Cossacks were not too ceremonious with their Russian compatriots, then the development of land and the expansion of the Russian state were sometimes accompanied by real atrocities against the indigenous population. Often lands were taken away by force, villages were completely cut out, along with women and children. The Cossacks and the slave trade did not disdain.

The memory of the development of Siberia and the Caucasus by Cossacks still remains in the depths of memory of those who were then called "foreigners." For example, recently, the unexpectedly stiff resistance of the Buryat population was caused by the project of installing a monument to the founding Cossacks in Ulan-Ude. In Russia and the post-Soviet republics, examples of the dismantling of monuments dedicated to the Cossacks are also known.

Cossacks and power

Cossacks have long enjoyed privileges from Russian tsars and Russian emperors. In return, they became loyal and ardent supporters of the monarchy and defenders of the country. Cossacks proved themselves in all wars, defended Russia from invaders. Many of them laid their heads on the battlefields of their country.

In contrast to the predominant peasant population of the country, which was serfs, the Cossacks were free people who owned their own land and cultivated it on their own or through wage labor. For this, they were grateful to the authorities and were ready to protect it from any threats - both foreign and domestic. Even the imperial family entrusted the Cossacks with ensuring their safety.

After the deposition of the monarchy, the Cossacks became not only unnecessary, but also dangerous for the new government. It was an armed, trained and uncontrolled force. The Cossacks felt relieved of service. In a number of Cossack regions, separatist sentiments even arose and intensified.

Then the Bolsheviks took the path of physically eliminating the rich stanchiks and equating them with the non-Cossack population of the Cossack regions. We can say that then the Cossacks ceased to exist.

In the post-Soviet era, movements for the revival of traditions intensified. The Cossacks began to revive. Of course, it will never play the role that it played in the Russian Empire in modern Russia. It is more about the cultural and historical component. Cossack songs, costumes, ceremonies make the lives of these people brighter and more interesting, make you feel proud of your ancestors.

Now the Cossacks have turned from a formidable and weakly controlled force into a vibrant decoration that brings joy to people.
30 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. The comment was deleted.
  2. The comment was deleted.
  3. -1
    24 July 2018 20: 25
    Cossack is a shame, the rabble of all rabble
    1. +2
      25 July 2018 12: 39
      kamski (Kamski), look at yourself in the mirror - there you will see what you are writing about, boor.
    2. +3
      25 July 2018 18: 15
      Cossack is a shame, the rabble of all rabble

      Hmm ... Do not compare current ones with their ancestors ... Yes, basically the same bandits and convicts conquered the same Siberia ... And the same Ermak and his comrades had behind them the decree of Tsar Ivan the Terrible to sentence them to death for their gangster tricks ... However, by conquering Siberia and presenting it to the king, Yermak won forgiveness ...
      Although all this is so far-fetched ... Like the whole story ... Not only Russian, but also worldwide ... hi
      PS And about the present - without mournful laughter and do not want to talk ...
      By the way, I'm probably one of the "traitors" - in general, I was born and lived my life up to 18 years in the most Cossack places ... However, I was smart enough not to say that I am a "Cossack" by nationality during the population census. .. And a lot of people declared that ... THERE IS NO such nationality - "Cossack" ... there is - an estate ... The same as a merchant, bourgeoisie, nobleman and so on ... hi
  4. +7
    24 July 2018 20: 36
    The "headquarters of color revolutions" in Washington have been chewing on this topic for a long time, as it was in Ukraine. It only takes time, but money and cookies will not matter. With the connivance of our liberal government-
    "Take as much sovereignty as you can swallow", the whole Caucasus, and Tatarstan with Bashkiria, and Buryatia with Yakutia, can rise. Look to the Moscow Ring Road, and beyond the Moscow Ring Road, who is getting fat, and who is begging, where the powerful "bohemia" lives, and where he lives, and compare their mansions with our stalls .... And the worst thing is that NOTHING is being done by the authorities to prevent the impending apocalypse, only spectacles, but without bread.
    1. +3
      28 July 2018 23: 23
      With the current Cossacks, this will not work! And not because they are devoted to the country, but because there is no more Cossacks ... That, true Cossacks!
      Now they are recruiting into the Cossacks as in circles, and those who enter are rarely descendants of the Cossacks. I personally saw the Armenian in the Cossacks.
      True, he visited Dzhalga in the Stavropol Territory, yes - there are true Terek Cossacks, but this is only an exception!
      I myself am a hereditary Cossack! In my family, Terek, Kuban and Don Cossacks (even married a Cossack), but I did not join the Cossacks — I can’t stand the simulacra of Cossack reality — the illusory greatness of the once great nation ...
      The Cossacks, unfortunately, became attached to the image of a 19th-century Cossack ... Stopped developing! Arriving in the frustration of the ephemeral existence ... What a pity!
      But I hope, of course, that it will be possible to preserve our Cossack family. I educate my two Cossacks as male soldiers, as patriots of the Russian land. And I instill the awareness that every Cossack is Russian, but not every Russian is a Cossack! And while our memory exists, our traditions of education, the Cossacks must be!
  5. +5
    25 July 2018 07: 02
    The author did not fully cover the topic, although in principle it is true ... In fact, these same defenders surrendered the tsar. The whole Cossack corps stood in St. Petersburg. They did not lift a finger to save the monarchy, let alone the royal family. Here is a robbery is the thing .. And the current mummers do not cause anything but disgust. And these claims to a certain exclusivity will ever come around. I have all the trash in the Cossacks enrolled ... From the army they slope, and the medals to the navel .. . It is true that Trotsky once told them about ... But Joseph Vissarionovich was liberal in his attitude, and there were hordes of traitors-Cossacks in the Patriotic War .. By the way, I can be considered a hereditary Cossack.
    1. +7
      25 July 2018 07: 55
      In fairness, it is worth saying that among the Cossacks in the Great Patriotic War there were real heroes. Take, for example, the cavalry corps of General Dovator.
      1. +1
        25 July 2018 12: 38
        ... or the same plastuns.
    2. +1
      25 July 2018 18: 24
      Quote: Aleksey Alekseev_2
      In my village, all the squalor has signed up for Cossacks ... From the army they slope and medals to the navel ..

      I also came home for a visit in the 90s - and there ... That is - all the trash in black uniform, with gold or silver epaulets, on motorcycles (!!!) - (and where are the horses?), In boots, and behind the shafts - whips ... Poeppppstren, which I once knew from an early age ... Honor - above the navel ...
      Actually, what the current ones are trying to imagine as almost a new pillar of the new Russia is all a whim ... Whim, like our ideas - not our parties that are in power ...
      The current Cossacks are a movement no better than EdRa, LDPR, KPRF, whom else to name ??? ...
  6. +3
    25 July 2018 09: 58
    Here is my simplified vision of the history of the Cossacks. Since ancient times, not an obedient people who did not want to live in serfs all their lives, fled from the center to the outskirts, away from the tsar and other authorities (to the Don, to the Terek, to the Volga, to Siberia, and so on). People with problems with the criminal law also fled there. There they strayed in gangs and mittens. It was difficult to survive on the outskirts of Russia because of the chills with the local population, and life itself forced white people to organize themselves into large gangs. They could only live by robbery. Sort of land pirates. Over time, their numbers are scattered to comparable with large military units and pirate republics, such as Tortuga. They began to interfere with the foreign state policy of the Russian tsars - they robbed neighboring states, Turks, for example, when they did not have to rob. At some point, an agreement came and free Sharpalnik Cossacks sold out (went to serve) the Russian tsars for food allowances (bread caravans). From that moment, stratification began among the Cossacks themselves among the poor and rich (before that, the whole Duvan was divided equally). The rich became those who sat on the distribution of royal feed. There were riots. The most famous revolt of Stenka Razin against elders, which ended with the construction of Razin’s own Cossack republic and the subsequent betrayal and the issuance of it to the Cossack elders by his comrades. Over time, the Cossacks degenerated into punishers of the rebellious people. This ends the story of the Cossacks - the Bolsheviks destroyed the Cossacks and the people of the Cossacks did not grieve.
    1. +3
      25 July 2018 11: 55
      Quote: shpakov.alex
      and the people of the Cossacks did not grieve

      My grandmother, born in 1912, said that their village was inhabited by captains and mechanics of steamers. The ships overwintered in Veliky Ustyug, where in the spring all the men left. To work on the land (the land then gave birth) and with cattle, a man was hired who was called a "Cossack". The word meant a man without property, staggering between the yard, that is, a farm laborer. The story of dispossession in a village inhabited entirely by kulaks amused me. The men were literate, the authorities studied and used new documents. There was a peasant in the village who loved to walk and sing songs. He got the people out with his singing. Therefore, at the appointed time, a committee of the poor was created by the captains and mechanics and, in pursuance of the decisions of the Soviet government on dispossession of the "world eaters", a lover of loud singing was elected a world eater and dispossessed. The owners of the river fleet were nationalized in the same timely manner, where they continued to work. I am writing from grandma's words. There are no Stalinist repressions in the memory of my family.
      1. +1
        25 July 2018 12: 37
        Well, your society turned out to be wise and in time oriented at that moment ... which cannot be said about the rest of the country.
    2. The comment was deleted.
    3. +3
      26 July 2018 10: 55
      You have a very simplified view of history. Are you not a Jew? Thus, only Jews can simplify history. My son studied at a German gymnasium. I read his history book. There, entire chapters of history are presented in a simplified manner. The historical period from 1935 to 1945 is set out on a half page. Hitler came to power by deception and oppressed all of Europe, but the good Americans came and overthrew him, and brought democracy to Europe. And then 10 pages describe the Holocaust and the suffering of the Jewish people. And the children were taken to the nearest concentration camp for an excursion. You know how to simplify the story.
    4. +2
      28 July 2018 23: 45
      A strange vision, unfounded ... Of course, there were also fugitives, but the Cossacks came to the Caucasus with an already formed army! Settled on the Terek, founded the Terek Cossacks, in the Kuban - the Kuban, etc ...
      Remember the times of Ivan Ⅳ (Grozny), Stenka Razin already commanded the Cossack army! And in the Caucasus, Cossacks appeared much later ...
  7. +4
    25 July 2018 10: 07
    And the Cossacks began to revive for the same purpose. The authorities need chain dogs against the people. Then they thought better of it, abandoned this venture and concentrated on all kinds of national guard and other alternatives.
    1. 0
      25 July 2018 12: 36
      ... no one has been reviving anyone for a long time ...
  8. +1
    25 July 2018 10: 45
    Clowns
    The case was in one of the Siberian cities: We contracted to guard a dacha cooperative in the winter. Before the new year, they even rode horses, yes. And after "gone". We drank horses, orders, whips and "wrap up ..." In the spring, summer residents CATCHED (then the militia shrugged their shoulders - the Cossacks) these "guards", because the contents of many summer cottages, fences, decking from roofs and other valuable things were also drunk.
  9. 0
    25 July 2018 12: 35
    Can add:
    "Like many subenos, the Cossacks simply disappeared into the Russian people. Many descendants of those Cossacks, who still remember (from the words of their grandparents) some rituals and customs, try to make cultural business projects out of them."
    ... I remember my grandmother told me that the Cossacks were cruel not only to "foreigners", but also to their own children. My great-great-grandfather fed his son under the table like a dog, throwing leftovers from the table to him, treated him like a cattle (since childhood). Having matured, he left (ran away) from the parental home, where no one knows now ... horror in general. We had "Cossacks" and "men" ...
  10. +1
    26 July 2018 01: 10
    As a great-grandson and grandson of the registered Cossacks of the Zaporizhzhya Empress of the Cossack Regiment of the KUBAN military, I would like to speak on this topic. As it was in the past, let us leave it to historians, and most importantly, the people's memory, But how and who embodies the * revival * of this current Cossack movement (at the level of the village for sure) causes depression and a slight disgust and demonstrates the most important thing (operetta greasy form, the number of stars on uniform, crosses in all breasts and jubilee medals are expensive!) complete disrespect for the memory of their ancestors, clowns are burdened e,!
    1. +1
      26 July 2018 06: 06
      Mummers - one topic, tell me that mummers in the Donbass. Himself with a Cossack surname, and the famous
    2. +1
      26 July 2018 06: 08
      By the way, have you ever heard of the daughter of an officer of the entire regiment about the registered Cossacks in the RF Armed Forces? And who is the mummer?
      1. 0
        29 July 2018 01: 28
        Quote: Jerk
        And who is the mummer?

        So explain who is mummers. Stalin, Yeltsin, Putin, which one is mummers?
  11. +1
    26 July 2018 06: 04
    "Why they never liked border guards in Russia" - you can rename it.
    They didn’t like it because the Cossacks were needed when there was trouble, and there was always trouble on the border. Where the Cossacks were
    1. +1
      26 July 2018 10: 49
      The proletariat in St. Petersburg was chopped with drafts. That's how your Cossacks were noted in the memory of the people. Murderers, executioners, punishers, bandits, under-peasants and under-soldiers.
  12. +1
    26 July 2018 10: 41
    Everything rests on historical facts. The Cossacks always supported the tsar and autocracy. It was the Cossacks who fought against tsarism of all sorts during the first and second Russian revolution. It is a known thing that the most ardent fighters against tsarism were, judging by the names and surnames of the first rulers of Soviet Russia, Jews. Jews and the Cossacks were among the worst enemies of Soviet power. Even in modern times, the first opponents of the Cossacks in any online discussion are Jews. Apparently this is a historical memory. They cannot forgive the Jews, beaten by the Cossack whips, on the backs of the liberal Social Revolutionaries of the time of the revolution.
    1. +1
      26 July 2018 13: 54
      Stupidity. The working class of tsarist Russia consisted of Jews?
    2. +2
      27 July 2018 19: 37
      Well, the first ruler of Soviet Russia was Vladimir Ilyich Lenin, and the second was Joseph Vissarionovich Dzhugashvili. For some reason, these names of the Jews do not remind me, but of the names - perhaps Joseph, like, is Jewish.
      What sways the last Russian father-tsar, as far as I remember, he was half Dane, half German with a slight admixture of Russian blood.
      And the Cossacks, not embarrassed, laughed down not so much the Jews as at the villages of Russian peasants, whom they deeply despised, and on strike workers in cities, regardless of nationality.
      But tsarism was defeated not so much by revolutionaries as by the tsar himself.
      As for the Cossacks, most of them were not credited with the enemies of Soviet power, they were the worst enemies of Soviet power. Although some of the Cossacks warmly supported the new government.
  13. +1
    27 July 2018 08: 01
    Perhaps the Cossacks are the main problem and trouble? Are the other “estates” immaculate? An article is an offer to beat yourself and ... what? Pay attention to one point: Cossacks may be in a very weakened form, but KEEPED collective self-government - the Cossack circle! The rest in this are simply deprived. And what are you bullying your nose? I am not a Cossack.
    1. +1
      2 August 2018 13: 04
      The argument is so-so. The Cossack circle is the same election of the chief, to which then all voters must seem to obey. Until the next regular or extraordinary election.
  14. -2
    28 July 2018 19: 12
    That the lackeys got a fuss.