Will the Russian aircraft industry survive the "optimization" of Serdyukov?

The coronavirus pandemic has dealt a powerful blow to the global aviation industry, affecting both the leading aircraft manufacturers and the air transportation sector. In such a situation, Russia has a chance to regain its positions in the civil aviation industry, and certain steps are being taken in this direction. However, the new reform of the aircraft industry according to A. Serdyukov's recipes threatens to cancel all this.

The figure of the ex-Minister of Defense, who now heads the UAC and the Rostec aviation cluster, evokes a rather ambiguous attitude towards himself. There is no doubt about the need to reform the industry and get rid of the debt burden of hundreds of billions of rubles. The only question is what methods are used to do this, and what is their real purpose.

The military reforms of Anatoly Serdyukov are assessed in different ways. It is impossible to say unequivocally that everything was done incorrectly: it brought some benefit to the RF Ministry of Defense through “optimization”. But at the same time, damage was caused to the training system, which, as you know, decide everything. During the period when he was at the head of the ministry, more than a hundred educational institutions were withdrawn from the capital, and this had many negative consequences.

For example, the Zhukovsky Air Force Engineering Academy, located in Moscow near the Airport metro station, was merged with the Gagarin Air Force Academy, which was located in Monino near Moscow. After that, the military aviators were ordered to move from Monino to Voronezh. Initially, 40 doctors of sciences and 3 hundred candidates worked at the Zhukovsky Academy. Most of them refused to move from the capital to the Moscow region, finding another job. The Gagarin Academy employed 20 doctors and 3 hundred candidates of sciences. They also refused to leave for an even more distant province. As a result, the prestigious educational institution was drained of blood in terms of professional staff.

A similar fate befell the Military Academy of Radiation, Chemical and Biological Protection named after V. Marshal of the Soviet Union Tymoshenko. At first, a branch was opened in Kaluga, and then it was all transferred from Moscow to the province. Doctors and candidates of sciences also refused to leave the capital, which means that the level of teaching objectively dropped. The coronavirus pandemic has clearly demonstrated how important military biological defense specialists are to the country.

The explanation of why all this was done is banal. Under Serdyukov, the Ministry of Defense released expensive capital land for educational institutions, which was then put up for sale for commercial development. That is, there was no talk at all about any "optimization" for the sake of improving the quality of military education, the question was only in money. And now something similar is happening in the civil aircraft industry, which is supervised by the ex-minister.

Leading helicopter manufacturers, Mil and Kamova Design Bureau, merge, the staff is reduced, and "excess production space" is freed up for subsequent sale. The process of merging Sukhoi and MiG companies has begun. And a few days ago we toldthat, perhaps, we are talking about the merger of "Tupolev" and "Ilyushin". "Excess" production areas will be liquidated, and the land under them will be sold. "Superfluous" specialists will also be cut, and the rest will go to free bread themselves, since the united design bureaus will move from Moscow to the National Center for Aircraft Manufacturing, which is in Zhukovsky near Moscow.

It turns out that for the sake of expensive capital land, in fact, the cadre is being destroyed, which should work to restore the domestic aircraft industry. There is no doubt that our "brains" will eventually flow into some other corporations, most likely foreign ones. Note that merging different design bureaus eliminates our traditional advantage in the form of internal competition between projects. Here is such a "optimization" according to Serdyukov's recipes.
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. Bulanov Offline Bulanov
    Bulanov (Vladimir) 18 August 2020 13: 17
    The author of the phrase - "Cadres decide everything!" I would never put a non-specialist at the head of a technical organization. Imagine instead of Korolev, Kurchatov, or Tupolev, people with humanitarian education. And then there would be neither the First Cosmonaut in the USSR, nor the atomic bomb, and the planes would be bought by farmers, and Abrams tanks, if they were sold in the USSR ...
    1. Kostyar Offline Kostyar
      Kostyar 18 August 2020 14: 01
      And the USSR would no longer exist !!!
  2. Sergey Latyshev Offline Sergey Latyshev
    Sergey Latyshev (Serge) 18 August 2020 14: 00
    Tse cunning plan of Putin to deceive the West.

    Oligarch Serdyukov will show himself to everyone.
    After all, at first, the number of built helicopters dropped dramatically, but now we are confidently catching up with the level of 2011-2015 ...
  3. steelmaker Offline steelmaker
    steelmaker 18 August 2020 14: 01
    It is impossible to say unequivocally that everything was done incorrectly: it brought some benefit to the RF Ministry of Defense through “optimization”.

    For example!? Everyone talks about the benefits, but the facts are only negative. Serdyukov is Chubais, who is given real power. And that worries me the most!
  4. Vladimir_ Voronov (Vladimir) 18 August 2020 15: 53
    The analysis is done correctly, the conclusion is incorrect.
    Metropolitan professors are spoiled, they have already achieved everything in their lives and are resting on their laurels. Therefore, they refuse to leave, because Moscow is their goal, not new achievements.
    Kurchatov, Fedorov, Kovalchuk are people of science, they didn’t want to be engaged in “household chores”, they are not caretakers. Everyone must do their job.
    Serdyukov is an anti-crisis manager who has already shown himself once, and if he was entrusted with such work again, then he showed himself well. They didn't jail him.
    Scoundrels are not kept in Putin's close circle. He is a statesman, not a huckster.
    1. Alf Offline Alf
      Alf (Vasiliy) 18 August 2020 19: 05
      Quote: Vladimir_Voronov
      Scoundrels are not kept in Putin's close circle.

      The circle consists of them ...

      Quote: Vladimir_Voronov
      They didn't jail him.

      We don't hand over ours.

      Quote: Vladimir_Voronov
      Serdyukov is an anti-crisis manager who has already shown himself once, and if he was entrusted with such work again, then he showed himself well.

      So "not bad" that after the removal of the furniture-marshal in the army there was a week-long booze.

      Quote: Vladimir_Voronov
      He is a statesman, not a huckster.

      Who is he? Is it really Himself? The results of his "statehood" are visible to the naked eye - the retirement age, negative economic growth, etc.
  5. Potapov Offline Potapov
    Potapov (Valery) 18 August 2020 21: 42
    Every time I am surprised at the wisdom of the nation ... You are surprised, dude ...
  6. Nikolay Malyugin (Nikolai Malyugin) 19 August 2020 06: 33
    We have everything to not only restore, but also to go ahead. There is no one. A sober attitude to the market system. A good marketer will not spare money to generate income in the future. We are ready to level the mountains to the ground in order to get instant profit. Business people do not have confidence in the idea of ​​lone designers. And the current Central Banks value young people little. Say, it's calmer.
  7. Yuri Bryanskiy Offline Yuri Bryanskiy
    Yuri Bryanskiy (Yuri Bryansky) 19 August 2020 06: 54
    Unfortunately, the country is ruled by stoolists.
  8. bear040 Offline bear040
    bear040 19 August 2020 21: 48
    Serdyukov is a thief. And the thief should be in jail. And given the amount stolen, on death row. However, he will still be there after he has filled everything up and got through at his current post. The fox is not assigned to guard the chicken coop. Putin will be destroyed by the same thing as Brezhnev - nepotism!