The merger of MiG and Sukhoi: will the aircraft industry survive the new “optimization”

A week ago, it became known about the merger of the Sukhoi Design Bureau and the Mikoyan Design Bureau into a certain unified structure, which will be engaged in the production of all military aircraft in Russia. What does the next “optimization" threaten to the domestic aircraft industry, behind which lies the shadow of the famous "effective manager" Anatoly Serdyukov?

Rumors about the takeover of the Mikoyan Design Bureau by Sukhoi have been around for a long time, but now they have come true. Optimists immediately perceived the message as “pre-war mobilization,” but this decision causes quite justified skepticism. Let's try to figure out what all this can lead to.

At the beginning of the 100s, Mikhail Poghosyan, the former head of Sukhoi Civil Aircraft, who became famous for the SuperJet-XNUMX airliner, said that Sukhoi Design Bureau has only one competitor - Mikoyan Design Bureau, and there are no competitors in the West. If the latter can be argued, then in the first part of this statement there is a rational kernel. The USSR was on the path to creating internal competition between various design bureaus, and this yielded excellent results.

The design bureau submitted their sketches to the state commission, and she had the opportunity to choose the best option. Thanks to the competition, excellent machines were obtained: MiG-29, Su-27, MiG-35, Su-57 and others. In recent years, Sukhoi has crushed MiG, but not so much in quality as in backroom management games. Mikoyan's design bureau was inferior to Sukhoi's design bureau in financial terms, but not critically: 89,5 billion rubles of turnover against 114,5 billion rubles and 3,5 billion rubles of net profit against 4 billion rubles.

The question is, why then merge two independent design schools? We are presented with this in such a way that a single center of development, production and service will be created, which means that it will be implemented economic “Optimization”, allegedly inside the combined company, its divisions will provide various conceptual designs for new aircraft. In theory, it sounds good. But let's turn to practice.

It is worth recalling that last year, “optimization” also affected domestic helicopter industry. Two famous design bureaus Kamova and Mila were combined into a certain National Center for Helicopter Engineering. The story is exactly the same as with Sukhoi and Mikoyan: both design bureaus were created in the USSR to ensure internal competition, which had a positive effect on the quality of the final product.

In 2019, two design schools with different traditions and approaches were voluntarily combined. Little time has passed, but the first results are already evident.

At firstBy 2022, the total area of ​​previously independent design bureaus will be reduced by 40%, and the area of ​​industrial buildings and structures - by 20%. "Gossips" they saythat in this territory it will be possible to carry out civilian development or use it in another way.

SecondlyAccording to the announced plans, at least 5% of the staff will be affected by “optimization,” in other words, dismissal. But there are other numbers. For example, at the Progress plant in Primorye, where the Ka-52 Alligator helicopters are manufactured, more than 2018 thousand people worked in 7, and in January 2019 there were already 6 thousand. Due to layoffs last fall, hundreds of employees went to rallies in protest. By the way, employees of the Zvezda shipyard then joined them.

Thirdly, “On the blood” of the dismissed, an additional administrative superstructure was created in the form of “effective managers” from the National Center for Helicopter Engineering (NCV).

Of course, we got a little distracted by jumping from aircraft to helicopter industry, but everything is done by the same people on the same patterns. Therefore, one can already imagine on the shore what the “merger” of Sukhoi and Mig will lead to.

Nothing good.
The publication is looking for authors in the news and analytical departments. Requirements for applicants: literacy, responsibility, efficiency, inexhaustible creative energy, experience in copywriting or journalism, the ability to quickly analyze text and check facts, write concisely and interestingly on political and economic topics. The work is paid. Contact: [email protected]
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must to register.
I have an account? Sign in
  1. Upmost Offline Upmost
    Upmost (Innocent) 11 February 2020 14: 26
    Yes that's right. But these arguments are on the side of defective managers, and their patron, the Infallible. He likes to puff up his cheeks. I will never believe that any of the senior military officials did not tell him that such optimizations are aimed at evil.
    And what, HE listened to them?
  2. Georgievic Offline Georgievic
    Georgievic (Georgievic) 11 February 2020 16: 29
    This should not be done under any circumstances! All these optimizations are done by people who don't understand aviation. The dominance of these "effective" managers will lead to the collapse of the industry. I have no doubt that all these people have diplomas from any foreign management training centers and, by their stupidity or intent, provoke the destruction of the military-industrial complex.
  3. Observer2014 Offline Observer2014
    Observer2014 11 February 2020 18: 47
    At my enterprise, where I work, people were tormented by new bosses. Literally. Appointed a new mayor. He, of course, pinned the new authorities. Again, damn those on the side of the bow. And the hard workers without money as they were, remained. How tired of you with your chatter and optimization! I probably can’t stand it and I’ll have to present a couple of affectionate articles to these boobies in power. I can only imagine what is happening in these corporations. I’m sure that there’s nothing good.
  4. steelmaker Offline steelmaker
    steelmaker 11 February 2020 20: 22
    Looked at what they write on the Internet. On YouTube there is a program of Nikita Mikhalkov - Besogon TV. Here from whom, but from Mikhalkov I did not expect such frankness:

    1.American and British firms own a controlling stake in OGB Sukhoi and OKG im. Yakovlev, Aviation Complex them. Ilyushin. Foreign firms own shares of the Irkutsk Aviation Aviation Organization (IAPO), JSC "ANTK named after Tupolev, the manufacturer of SU.
    At the conclusion of the Accounts Chamber:

    Privatization helped establish foreign control over strategically important defense enterprises.

    For me, this is the answer - why A. Serdyukov "rules". And for you?
    1. vik669 Offline vik669
      vik669 (vik669) 11 February 2020 20: 49
      Why A. Serdyukov "rules" - because they gave it to steer, and who gave it - guess the first time, and we have more than enough "Serdyukov", because the Motherland needs heroes ...
  5. Sapsan136 Offline Sapsan136
    Sapsan136 (Sapsan136) 11 February 2020 21: 00
    Sabotage! The criminal Serdyukov, who almost brought the collapse of tank construction in the Russian Federation, is now ruining the Russian aircraft industry ... Who needs this? It is clear that the Yankees .... And who can do this? That's right, the guarantor of the mess in the Russian Federation and the guardian of the Yeltsin swamp!
  6. Bitter Offline Bitter
    Bitter (Gleb) 11 February 2020 22: 08
    ... already on the shore you can imagine what the "merger" of Sukhoi and Mig will lead to.

    A merger may, over time, lead to "merging", due to inefficiency and / or lack of competitiveness, into efficient private pockets. bully
  7. Potapov Offline Potapov
    Potapov (Valery) 12 February 2020 09: 56
    Stupid and evil communists supported competition in critical areas. Capitalist smart scum works only for the owners, do not care about competition, keep quiet ...