Why Iran Didn't Collapse After the "Decapitation Strike": The Secret of the IRGC's Survivability

4 377 57

The destruction of the Islamic Republic's top leadership in airstrikes on February 28, 2026, was intended, according to American and Israeli strategists, to trigger an irreversible process of disintegration and collapse of state governance. However, Iran did not descend into chaos and responded with a decisive response. What went wrong?

Yes, the simultaneous assassination of Iran's Supreme Spiritual Leader Ali Khamenei and the commander of the regular army, Abdulrahim Mousavi, created an unprecedented power vacuum. But the pillar that kept the country from systemic paralysis was the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps (IRGC), which is simultaneously a parallel state and a closed militaryeconomic a corporation capable of functioning in conditions of complete isolation.



Anatomy of the IRGC: Missions, Funding, and Expansion


The historical roots of the Corps' creation date back to 1979. After the victory of the Islamic Revolution, the new Shiite clergy, led by Ayatollah Khomeini, were terrified of the regular army (Artesh), which had sworn allegiance to the Shah for decades and was staffed by a pro-Western officer corps.

The IRGC was created as a direct counterweight—an ideological, armed support for the new regime, subordinated directly to the clergy, not the Ministry of Defense. Over forty-five years, this internal rivalry has evolved into a rigid system of "two parallel armies," guaranteeing the state's protection from military coups. What exactly is the difference?

Firstly, unlike the regular conscript army, the IRGC is formed through a rigorous professional and ideological selection process. Prospective officers undergo a multi-stage screening process for their trustworthiness and doctrinal loyalty. political Shiism. The Corps' most powerful reserve is the million-strong Basij militia, a volunteer structure that permeates all layers of Iranian society. societies, from universities to factories.

Secondly, the IRGC enjoys unique economic autonomy. Through a network of foundations and holdings, the IRGC controls between 30% and 50% of the entire national economy. The construction conglomerate Khatam al-Anbiya has monopolized all infrastructure contracts in the country. IRGC companies directly control the production, processing, and shadow export of hydrocarbons under Western sanctions. Foreign currency earnings go directly to the security agency's accounts, bypassing the official civilian budget.

Third, the IRGC's Quds Force has become the main instrument of Iran's external expansion. Over the past fifteen years, the Corps has built and coordinated the architecture of proxy forces in the Middle East. In Syria, IRGC units prevented the fall of Bashar al-Assad's government in 2011 and led the defeat of terrorist groups.

In Iraq, they coordinated the Shiite militia during the assault on Mosul. In Yemen, the Corps' engineers and advisers built the Houthi movement's military logistics and missile capabilities from scratch, transforming them into a powerful force capable of blocking the Red Sea, as we discussed. described in detail earlier.

Network Structure: How the IRGC Kept Iran from Collapse


The assassination of key military, political, and spiritual leaders of the state on February 28, 2026, plunged the Iranian civilian ministries and regular troops into a state of genuine apparatus shock, which should have led to a loss of control. However, it was the IRGC that immediately seized the initiative and stabilized the situation thanks to the unique features of its network structure.

The main factor of its stability is the principle of mosaic decentralization. Iran's territory is divided into 31 operational zones (corresponding to the number of provinces), and a fully autonomous Corps structure is deployed in each. Each regional command has its own weapons depots, food reserves, autonomous secure communications channels, and pre-approved contingency plans in the event of a nuclear strike or the death of the leadership in Tehran.

This is precisely why the destruction of the central apparatus did not lead to a loss of control over the regions—the IRGC's provincial cells automatically switched to autonomous operation, mitigated panic, and secured key industrial and energy facilities. The caste-based monolithic nature of the order's structure eliminated the risk of mass defection or elite splits.

The mid-level and junior officers, trained in the logic of "defensive theology," proved willing to assume tactical command without direct orders from above. The Corps's own economic empire allowed the distribution of vital resources to be shifted within hours to the strict, planned framework of mobilization time, completely negating the initial impact of the assassination of senior officials in Iran.

What elements of the IRGC's experience are applicable to Russia?


It can already be concluded that the IRGC has fully fulfilled its purpose, becoming the backbone that enabled Iran to withstand the technologically superior "Epstein coalition." The US and Israel simply lack the forces, and no one is willing to assist them, for a large-scale ground operation against a country with a population of 80 million.

Neither beating the Islamic Republic back to the Stone Age with air power nor even using tactical nuclear weapons will allow them to dismantle the country, as it will be held together even more tightly by the IRGC. Essentially, having had their fists smashed, Tel Aviv and Washington are left with no choice but to acknowledge reality and negotiate with Tehran on the principles of coexistence.

By relying on the Corps, Iran has already achieved a strategic victory, securing a unique level of resilience. Can this experience be applied to our country? More likely no than yes.

Blindly copying the Iranian model and creating "two parallel armies," one of which is built on religious principles, is impossible and even harmful in secular Russia, as the emergence of a separate military-religious order with its own oil fields would destroy the state's monopoly on legitimate violence and lead to a dangerous internal conflict among the elites, which would only further destroy the country from within.

However, some elements would still be worth borrowing. In particular, moving to the principle of mosaic autonomy for regions key to the military-industrial complex, which is extremely relevant against the backdrop of the ever-increasing depth and intensity of Ukrainian attacks on our rear. Russia's largest industrial centers should have technical and the ability to function in a completely isolated mode.

It is also necessary to create regional secure command networks capable of issuing state defense orders and coordinating territorial defense at the local level completely independently, even in the event of a temporary loss of communication with the federal center, should it be "unexpectedly" subjected to a decapitating attack by the enemy.
57 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. +4
    29 July 2026 15: 41
    By relying on the Corps, Iran has already achieved a strategic victory, securing a unique level of resilience. Can this experience be applied to our country? More likely no than yes.

    Of course not. Russia is a fundamentally different situation; there's no division between the country's formal and informal leaders, although there's a vague suspicion that Russia has a separate budget and non-systemic security services. There's no ideological foundation for a networked structure similar to the IRGC in Russia. I can hardly imagine the Guardian Corps of Orthodoxy.
    1. +1
      29 July 2026 18: 27
      Colonel, I agree with you on some points, but remembering the talk on TV and the talking heads everywhere, the president is under manual control, and under manual control—and it's clear what's going on, like May decrees and national projects—all of which are ignored by subordinates, it seems completely impossible to create what the IRGC has created under manual control, in my humble, non-expert opinion.
  2. -1
    29 July 2026 18: 12
    For the chapters: "Anatomy of the IRGC: Tasks, Financing and Expansion" and "Network Structure: How the IRGC Kept Iran from Collapse" +.
    And the chapter: "Which elements of the IRGC's experience are applicable in Russia" doesn't reflect reality. Not in relation to Russia; I don't understand that.

    Neither driving the Islamic Republic back into the Stone Age with air power, nor even using tactical nuclear weapons will allow them to collapse the country, since it will be held together even more strongly from within by the IRGC.

    During the 40 days of the war, the Israeli Air Force carried out 10,800 strikes on more than 4000 military facilities, dropped more than 18,000 bombs in more than 1000 attack waves.
    Continuation of such attacks, but now on economic structure The IRGC would have led to its complete collapse and the collapse of this system of governance. But Trump decided that was enough and that business could be done. He and his advisers were mistaken, and today it seems he has realized it.
    1. 0
      29 July 2026 18: 25
      Quote: vitgusin
      But Trump decided that this was enough and that business could be done; he and his advisers were wrong, and today it seems he has realized this.

      Or maybe Trump realized that Iran won't have enough weapons to drive it back to the Stone Age, and that the number of coffins in the US will be in the three or four digits, and he's done with it. Especially since Bibi has gone into hiding and isn't showing up. He should have continued driving Iran back to the Stone Age if he had something of his own besides American weapons, and he won. No!
      1. -3
        29 July 2026 18: 36
        Quote: Valera75
        and the number of coffins in the US will be in three or four digits

        One more time just for you:
        The Israeli Air Force carried out 10,800 strikes on more than 4000 military targets, dropping more than 18,000 bombs in more than 1000 attack waves. There are no wounded and no losses.

        Quote: Valera75
        Moreover, Bibi has gone into a hole and is not showing any signs of being there.

        28/07/26 Netanyahu says his meeting with Trump on Iran was a triumph.
        1. +3
          29 July 2026 18: 54
          Quote: vitgusin
          28/07/26 Netanyahu says his meeting with Trump on Iran was a triumph.

          How old is your six-fingered one, if my memory serves me right, but I could even be wrong, since the nineties, they said that Iran would soon create a nuclear bomb, and it’s 26, so I’m supposed to believe this guy?
          Well, you're a real storyteller, by God.
          Sorry, but you get a minus.
          Oops! Maybe Bibi got something from Epstein that this supposed peacemaker will start attacking Iran with demonic force, and Bibi will sit back and wait for some results?
          Remember I wrote to you about the third force, which was cleverly repaired?
          laughing
          Iran simply must stand up to pedophiles, child murderers, and Zionists! And I wish them luck!
          1. -2
            29 July 2026 20: 06
            Quote: Valera75
            Well, you're a real storyteller, by God.

            You understand the difference between facts and the empty propaganda nonsense you are trying to spread.

            Quote: Valera75
            Iran is going to create a nuclear bomb in a few days, and it's 26, so I'm supposed to believe this guy?

            International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) reported that Iran has accumulated approximately 400 kg (more precisely, about 440,9 kg) of uranium enriched to 60%. This amount puts Iran close to the level needed to create a nuclear weapon.

            Please do not write me fakes that you dig out of the media dumps or from elsewhere.
            1. 0
              1 August 2026 17: 12
              Quote: vitgusin
              You understand the difference between facts and the empty propaganda nonsense you are trying to spread.

              Sorry, your six-fingered one has been saying this for almost 40 years.
              Are you pushing your IAEA on me as a last resort? You're a real fairytale Jew. I know I can't handle you. I wrote a long time ago that I dealt with several Jews, and they stood right in my face and told me the absolute truth, and that theirs was the only truth, but it turned out they were farts. Ever since the distant early nineties, I've been wary of you guys, and reading your fairy tales and your Zionist Bibi only makes me more convinced that I was always right. laughing Your brother knows how to try to instill the truth and try to present it in such a way that you are ready to believe it, but alas wink
              1. -1
                1 August 2026 18: 55
                Quote: Valera75
                always knows how your brother trying to instill the truth and trying to present it in such a way that you're ready to believe it, but alas

                Of all the rubbish you've written, this is the only one that corresponds to reality.
                April 18, 2021
                Earlier, Head of Atomic Energy Organization of Iran Ali Akbar Salehi said that Iran has begun enriching uranium at 60 percent at the Natanz nuclear facility.
                He added that Iran's IR6 enrichment level was 55.3%.
                June 7, 2025, 08:57
                Iran has formally defended its enrichment of uranium to 60% purity in a public statement, insisting the activity is not prohibited under the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty (NPT).

                If you have any difficulties with translation, ask your Jewish friends, they will translate for you. hi
                1. 0
                  1 August 2026 19: 09
                  Quote: vitgusin
                  If you have any difficulties with translation, ask your Jewish friends, they will translate for you.

                  You're a slimy guy, but I didn't expect anything else.

                  If you have any difficulties with translation, ask your Jewish friends

                  I never met them, but I encountered them by chance, and I'm glad it happened, because maybe I got my ears pricked reading your nonsense; I might even have believed such nonsense. There's a Guy Ritchie movie where Pitt, dressed as a Jew, says something like that. I could be wrong. The gist is, "Words are up for 300 years about your faith, whatever suits you, and then go ahead and build a Catholic church." The idea is that you can babble something for a long time, and then sell this nonsense to the people by building a Catholic church. But I think the author didn't mean to offend Jews, so he didn't write a synagogue. So, whatever, Vasya, I will never believe your fairy tales.

                  April 18, 2021
                  Earlier, Head of Atomic Energy Organization of Iran Ali Akbar Salehi said that Iran has begun enriching uranium at 60 percent at the Natanz nuclear facility.
                  He added that Iran's IR6 enrichment level was 55.3%.
                  June 7, 2025, 08:57
                  Iran has formally defended its enrichment of uranium to 60% purity in a public statement, insisting the activity is not prohibited under the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty (NPT).

                  And yes, baby! I was still talking about the nineties, and you told me about 25 years.
      2. -2
        29 July 2026 19: 04
        Quote: Valera75
        Maybe Trump realized that the weapons aren't enough to drive Iran back to the Stone Age.

        There's not much needed there - attacks on oil production and the remains of the steel industry and Iran is left without any money at all.

        Quote: Valera75
        Why would Iran have continued to drive them back to the Stone Age if they had something of their own besides American and won? No!

        So the prices at gas stations in the States are going up.
        And Russia will become even less accommodating in continuing the NWO, as liquid prices go up and restrictions on trade in Russian hydrocarbons go down.
        1. 0
          29 July 2026 19: 20
          Quote: Krasnodar
          And Russia will become even less accommodating in continuing the NWO, as liquid prices go up and restrictions on trade in Russian hydrocarbons go down.

          These prices have never jumped, and in theory they should have jumped above 200 Baku rubles, but somehow they haven't. It turns out that it's not an indicator at all.
          1. +1
            29 July 2026 23: 01
            Quote: Valera75
            These prices have never jumped.

            laughing The first time they jumped was after the start of the Second World War, then in 2025 after the Israeli attack on Iran, then in February after the start of the joint operation, etc.
            The dynamics of price growth are publicly available on the Internet, and, moreover, prices at American gas stations have risen because of this. Yes
    2. +1
      29 July 2026 22: 20
      Do you even have any idea what these numbers are?
      Compare them to the number of Russian strikes on Ukraine, or even to the number of Ukrainian strikes on Russia, and these numbers will seem like peanuts.
      And then, ammunition tends to run out, and relying on Israeli and US manned aircraft in modern warfare no longer works.
      Without a ground operation, Israel and the US have nothing to gain there.
      1. -1
        29 July 2026 23: 05
        Quote: Sergey Mitinsky
        Ammunition tends to run out, and relying on Israeli and US manned aircraft in modern warfare no longer works.

        laughing Manned aircraft ammunition is more accurate and cheaper than missiles, more powerful than UAVs, and the aircraft's overall payload exceeds the power of the most sophisticated Iranian conventional missile.
        The production of air-to-air munitions is much faster than that of IRBMs.

        Quote: Sergey Mitinsky
        Without a ground operation, Israel and the US have nothing to gain there.

        If they want to overthrow the IRGC, I agree.
        If they want to plunge Iran into hopeless poverty after destroying the remains of the steel mill and cutting off oil and gas production, aerial work will take from three days to a week.
      2. 0
        29 July 2026 23: 07
        Quote: Sergey Mitinsky
        Compare them to the number of Russian strikes on Ukraine, or even to the number of Ukrainian strikes on Russia, and these numbers will seem like peanuts.

        Strictly opposite
        1. 0
          29 July 2026 23: 16
          You just don't know how much things cost. You'd be better off learning more about this.
          Well, and accordingly, improve your math by counting the number of hits
          But you can submit your thoughts on how easily Iran could be defeated to the Israeli Knesset, or even bypassing it to the General Staff or Mossad. Perhaps they don't realize how elegantly this can be done and they'll be interested in your calculations.
          1. +2
            29 July 2026 23: 21
            Quote: Sergey Mitinsky
            You just don't know how much things cost. It would be better for you to study up on this matter.

            MRBM, uh, one piece.
            Costs Iran between $1,5 million and $4 million
            The average price of an aerial munition is $150000.
            Israel and the United States, both together and separately, are richer than Iran.

            Quote: Sergey Mitinsky
            Maybe they don't represent it there

            Trump doesn't need a sharp rise in oil prices - that's what it all boils down to
            And only at this
            1. -1
              29 July 2026 23: 28
              Then send your thoughts to Trump. And most importantly, persuade him well that it will hurt him at first, but then it will be good.
              And tell him how cheap ammunition for airplanes is.
              Just remember to tell him about the cost of the flights from aircraft carriers with full fuel tanks and the services of air tankers.
              1. 0
                29 July 2026 23: 38
                Quote: Sergey Mitinsky
                The main thing is to persuade him well, saying that at first it will hurt him, but then it will be good.

                laughing Now Bibi is doing this, I think unsuccessfully... although, who knows

                Quote: Sergey Mitinsky
                Tell him how cheap ammunition for airplanes is.

                Don't worry about that - what Americans have always been good at is counting money. Yes
                Jews - even more so wink

                Quote: Sergey Mitinsky
                Just remember to tell him about the cost of the flights from aircraft carriers with full fuel tanks and the services of air tankers.

                An F-16 flight from a regular airfield costs $45000.
                An F-18 flight from an aircraft carrier costs approximately $60000.
                An F-35 flight from Israel to Iran, with refueling (taking into account the cost of an air tanker flight), costs around $170000.
                In this case,
                Iran's economy is approximately $400 billion.
                Israel's economy is well over $600 billion.
                And this is despite the fact that 10 million people live in Israel, and 90 million in Iran.
                I won't even mention the US economy. lol
            2. -1
              29 July 2026 23: 31
              And one more thing, I forgot!
              Tell Trump and the Israeli General Staff that it costs nothing and is also cheap to build interceptor missiles against Iranian aggressor missiles.
              1. 0
                30 July 2026 03: 39
                It's still expensive and slow, I agree. Yes
                The problem is that Iran has no effective air defense at all. hi
                1. -1
                  30 July 2026 06: 44
                  Something about Iranian air defense and the power of both Israeli and American bombings

                  You claim that "manned aircraft ammunition is more accurate and cheaper than missiles, more powerful than UAVs, and the total payload of an aircraft exceeds the power of the most sophisticated Iranian conventional missile."

                  The production of aircraft ammunition is much faster than IRBMs."

                  Now let's get to the bottom of it.

                  Even if the aircraft's overall payload exceeds the power of the most sophisticated Iranian conventional missile, what do you think the combat load of the aircraft that attacked Iran was, given that the aircraft from aircraft carriers and Israeli airfields flew there with full fuel tanks on the wings and under the belly, and even that wasn't enough for them, and they returned after refueling in mid-air? Were these strikes even more powerful than the Iranian missile strikes?

                  And I'll tell you, the combat load of such aircraft did not exceed 500 kg for aircraft that flew from aircraft carriers. Two KABs

                  Now, about Iran's air defense, which, as you claim, "is not effective at all."

                  Above you state that "During the 40 days of the war, the Israeli Air Force carried out 10,800 strikes on more than 4000 military targets, dropping more than 18,000 bombs in more than 1000 waves of attacks."

                  Well, let's say, how many of these blows hit the target, did you count?

                  Iran has several positions from which they have bombed Israel with ballistic missiles and continue to bomb the United States. None of them have been suppressed by your air force.

                  This is about the work of Iranian air defense and the effectiveness of manned aircraft, and about the heads of Israeli aircraft that were forced to launch their bombs, which, with booster engines, cost not $150,000, but at least twice as much.
                  1. 0
                    30 July 2026 07: 22
                    Quote: Sergey Mitinsky
                    Considering that aircraft from aircraft carriers and Israeli airfields flew there with full fuel tanks on the wings and under the belly, and even that wasn't enough for them, and they returned after refueling in the air? Were these strikes more powerful than those of Iranian missiles?

                    Israelis were refueled by air tankers

                    Quote: Sergey Mitinsky
                    And I'll tell you, the combat load of such aircraft did not exceed 500 kg for aircraft that flew from aircraft carriers. Two KABs

                    The average Iranian warhead that landed in Israel had exactly 500 kg of explosives.
                    The Israelis used Air Lora missiles—two per F-16, a Kinzhal variant, and other aerodynamics. In addition to KABs and cruise missiles. And all of this is more accurate than Iranian ballistics, yes.

                    Quote: Sergey Mitinsky
                    Well, let's say, how many of these blows hit the target, did you count?

                    Aerial munitions are precision weapons. Most likely, 90%

                    Quote: Sergey Mitinsky
                    Iran has several positions from which they have bombed Israel with ballistic missiles and continue to bomb the United States. None of them have been suppressed by your air force.

                    lol which one did you iron?
                    A) They shot mainly at squares; in two companies they killed one soldier on leave and 60 civilians.
                    At the same time, many missile launchers were destroyed on the ground.
                    And there are no positional areas there - Iran is larger than Ukraine, they shoot from wherever they can

                    Quote: Sergey Mitinsky
                    This also concerns the work of the Iranian air defense system.

                    It is zero, since absolutely everything and everyone whose location is known is destroyed on the territory of Iran.

                    Quote: Sergey Mitinsky
                    And to the question of who walked over the heads of the Israeli planes that were forced to fire their bombs, the cost of which with the booster engines

                    All modern aviation operates at a rapid pace; only American B-2s operate overhead, and even then, after all air defense in the area has been destroyed.

                    Quote: Sergey Mitinsky
                    Not $150,000, but at least twice as much.

                    I think a little less than $150000 on average laughing
                    Aeroballistics are expensive, JBUs are cheap
                2. -2
                  30 July 2026 06: 46
                  And further to the question of what is cheaper, ammunition for manned aircraft or missiles, it is explained by the simplest logic, which assumes that what is cheaper is what requires the least set of logistics

                  For example, what is the logistics of aviation ammunition?

                  Airplanes that cost a fortune, crews that cost even more, bases, very vulnerable airfields and their cover, maintenance, servicing, which cost even more, and so on and so forth.

                  What are the rocket's logistics?

                  A launcher, an operator and a button, and with a UAV the logistics are even cheaper

                  So your arguments about the cheapness of ammunition for manned aircraft are not convincing. hi
                  1. 0
                    30 July 2026 07: 33
                    Quote: Sergey Mitinsky
                    Airplanes that cost a lot of money

                    As the Israelis have demonstrated, there is no need to lose them.

                    Quote: Sergey Mitinsky
                    bases, very vulnerable airfields and their cover, maintenance, servicing, which cost even more, etc.

                    But the efficiency is higher

                    Quote: Sergey Mitinsky
                    missiles, what logistics?

                    A launcher, an operator and a button, and with a UAV the logistics are even cheaper

                    So the efficiency is much lower.

                    Quote: Sergey Mitinsky
                    So your arguments about the cheapness of ammunition for manned aircraft are not convincing.

                    If you make a product in a garage and hire three valuable specialists, it's cheaper than building a factory and launching a production line.
                    But, ultimately, the cost of the product manufactured at the factory will be significantly lower, and you will produce more of these products and recoup the costs of the factory, wages and maintenance, while earning several times more than a person working from a garage with three foreign workers
                    It's the same thing - you invest in air bases, pilot training, communications, an air defense destruction program, and you work freely in enemy skies, performing absolutely all tasks.
                    Ballistics - it has its drawbacks, I don’t know about the Yankees, but the Israelis used it against Iran to extinguish headquarters and large radars, at the beginning of both campaigns
                    But
                    The workhorse is the Air Force.
                    And UAVs capable of replacing manned aircraft in terms of payload, maneuverability, etc., will appear in 10 years, not earlier.
                    1. -1
                      30 July 2026 07: 44
                      I forgot that for every argument you have a dozen counterarguments, like that theoretic boxer who explains in simple terms how he can easily beat a practical boxer.

                      But the fact remains that Israel and the US are screwed, Iran is standing and will continue to stand, and that is the only thing I agree with this nervous author who flooded my email with his angry messages.
                      In the meantime, be healthy and wish you creative success in writing your counterarguments. hi
                      1. +1
                        30 July 2026 07: 57
                        Quote: Sergey Mitinsky
                        I forgot that for every argument you have a dozen counterarguments, like that theoretical boxer who explains in simple terms how he can easily beat a practical boxer.
                      2. +1
                        30 July 2026 08: 06
                        Quote: Sergey Mitinsky
                        Like that theoretical boxer who explains in simple terms how he can easily beat a practical boxer

                        laughing The big question here is who is the theorist and who is the practitioner ;))
                        70% of Israeli men have only served three years of compulsory military service, and this is a country that is constantly at war, and technologically has long been a Western country.
                        Russia - about 70% of men did not serve in the army at all, from 1945 until the Central Military District, conducted combined arms combat operations against regular armies twice - in 1956 in Hungary and in 2008 in Georgia
                        Technologically, 80% of the Russian population does not know English, the language of modern science.
                        That's why the question actually arises... laughing

                        Quote: Sergey Mitinsky
                        Until then, stay healthy and wish you creative success in writing your counterarguments.

                        These are not my counterarguments - the Israelis have experience of full-scale modern wars in 1948, 1956, 1967, 1973 and 1982, plus air operations against Syria and Iran hi
                        Even though resources are limited, they know how to count money - otherwise they wouldn't have become rich.
                        Hello ;)
                      3. -2
                        30 July 2026 08: 18
                        Oh yeah !
                        The Israel Defense Forces are powerful!
                        They still haven't defeated the bandits in Gaza and are at a respectful distance from the LBS in Lebanon, traditionally relying on armored vehicles that are successfully clicked by Hezbollah drones.
                        Yes, this "professional" army is, at best, a gathering of rangers who have served for 3 years, beating punching bags together with Israeli ladies, and compared to the Russian army, it's a flock of sheep.
                        By the way, Israeli generals understand this and have already planned a reform of the IDF, hoping for a multiple increase in its numbers and truly professional training.
                        The Chief of the General Staff of Israel in the Knesset said the following words on this matter, the meaning of which was that if the Israeli army does not increase its numbers, it will quickly disperse: hi
                      4. 0
                        30 July 2026 08: 31
                        Quote: Sergey Mitinsky
                        The bandits in Gaza have still not been defeated.

                        lol 65% of Gaza is occupied, 95% of the population lives in 35% of the strip's territory, the Israelis carry out liquidations of bandits there at least once a week, and Hamas is afraid to react - they are waiting for peacekeepers from Muslim countries so they can breathe easier. laughing

                        Quote: Sergey Mitinsky
                        is located at a respectful distance from the LBS in Lebanon

                        What? )))))
                        The IDF has occupied southern Lebanon, Hezbollah doesn't raise its head there, even the local army receives warning shots from small arms if it goes a few meters beyond its designated area. Yes

                        Quote: Sergey Mitinsky
                        Yes, this professional army is, at best, a gathering of rangers who have served for 3 years, beating punching bags with Israeli ladies, and compared to the Russian army, it’s a flock of sheep.

                        laughing
                        Yes, they don't know how to march, their drill is rubbish, and by the way - what's wrong with the rangers? lol
                        Can't they pull up their socks?

                        Quote: Sergey Mitinsky
                        To put it bluntly, Israeli generals understand this and have already planned a reform of the IDF, hoping for a multiple increase in its numbers and truly professional training.

                        laughing There are no questions about the preparation there ))))))

                        Quote: Sergey Mitinsky
                        The Chief of the General Staff of Israel in the Knesset said the following words on this matter, the meaning of which was that if the Israeli army does not increase its numbers, it will quickly disperse:

                        He's talking about reservists, some of whom serve 200 days a year - small businesses go bankrupt, employers gradually worsen their working conditions (openly firing them is illegal), etc. But this has nothing to do with the quality of training. laughing
                      5. -2
                        30 July 2026 09: 39
                        You probably think that the Russian army in Ukraine is engaged in military training?
                        The Russian army is fighting, by the way, and its experience and training cover all the previous experience of the Israeli army tenfold.
                        If the modern Israeli army had arrived from its resort to the Ukrainian LBS, there wouldn't have been a single belt left. hi
                      6. +1
                        30 July 2026 11: 10
                        Quote: Sergey Mitinsky
                        You probably think that the Russian army in Ukraine is engaged in military training?

                        I have friends in the North-Eastern Military District.

                        Quote: Sergey Mitinsky
                        The Russian army is fighting, by the way, and its experience and training cover all the previous experience of the Israeli army tenfold.

                        Let's put it this way: in 2022, we failed to replicate Israel's 1982 experience in Lebanon against Syrian air defenses, which were destroyed in a single day by a combination of UAVs, AWACS aircraft, tactical missile systems, and fighter-bombers. Moreover, the batteries, commanded by Soviet vacationers, were covered by over 100 Syrian fighters. hi

                        Quote: Sergey Mitinsky
                        If the modern Israeli army had arrived from its resort to the Ukrainian LBS, there wouldn't have been a single belt left.

                        I think they would have taken out Ukraine's air defenses, and then all the heavy equipment of the Ukrainian Armed Forces from the air, in about a week (and not just from the air – the IDF has more Haimars missiles in the MLRS-270 configuration and its own more sophisticated systems than the Ukrainian Armed Forces). However, Israel doesn't have veto power in the UN Security Council, so they would have quickly forced it to end the operation. Russia, as a country (and as a state), is much stronger in this regard.
                      7. -2
                        30 July 2026 12: 49
                        It's even funny to hear such statements! ))))

                        So, as I understand it, your "friend on his own" is claiming that the Russian army is actually doing drill training there!?))) laughing

                        You have finally convinced me that the city of Krasnodar is a thing of the distant past for you and now you are getting information about yourself while sitting in Israel.

                        The Israeli army has never fought an enemy even remotely comparable to Ukraine in strength, much less with the support of practically the entire NATO alliance. Are you comparing Ukraine to Hezbollah and Syria?! Iran is comparable at the start of the Second World War, but Israel wouldn't even show its face to confront its ground forces!

                        I think that in the fourth year of the war between Israel and Ukraine, there would be nothing left of Israel, given its size and how saturated Ukraine is with drones today. hi
                      8. +2
                        30 July 2026 13: 08
                        Quote: Sergey Mitinsky
                        I think that in the fourth year of the war between Israel and Ukraine, there would be nothing left of Israel.

                        At the beginning of 2022, the Ukrainian Air Force (UAF) consisted of approximately 45,000 personnel and had approximately 124 combat and combat-trainer aircraft,
                        As of early 2022, the Israel Air Force was one of the most technologically advanced and combat-ready in the world, with approximately 34,000 personnel (plus 55,000 reservists) and approximately 680 aircraft and helicopters.
                        1967 g

                        Eighty Israeli aircraft participated in the first strike, and 120 in the second. For 80 minutes, Israeli aircraft bombed Egyptian airfields relentlessly. Then, after a ten-minute lull, another 80 minutes of bombing followed. During these two hours and 50 minutes, the Israelis succeeded in destroying the Egyptian air force's offensive potential and eliminating it as a combat-ready force. In total, nineteen Egyptian airfields were bombed on the first day of the war.
                        During these 170 minutes, over 300 of the 340 Egyptian combat aircraft were destroyed (according to other sources, around 270 or 286), including all 30 Tu-16 long-range bombers. Nine airfields were disabled.
                        One of the first-hand witnesses of the war, then-attaché of the Soviet Embassy in Egypt, S. Tarasenko, recalls these events: "An hour later, we practically knew what was happening. A group of Soviet specialists working at Egypt's largest air base, Cairo West, arrived at the embassy. Their appearance—ripped, dirty clothes, haggard faces—spoke for themselves. When asked what had happened, the senior officer curtly replied, 'Egypt no longer has an Air Force, and Cairo West no longer exists.' Our guys were lucky; they were just approaching the base when the first wave of Israeli Mirages rolled in. The men managed to jump out of the bus and lie down in the ditches adjacent to the road...

                        Just the facts.
                      9. 0
                        30 July 2026 13: 28
                        This post of yours is particularly successful in combining data on the Ukrainian Air Force in 2022 with the pompous story of the defeat of the Egyptian Air Force back in 1967.
                        It's no longer time to, as you put it, "step over heads" and dominate the skies as you please. If that were the case, Iran would have long ago surrendered to the mercy of the victor. However, it's Israel and the US that have run out of steam, not Iran.

                        You will also remember the war of King David and the air support of his God against the Philistines.
                      10. +2
                        30 July 2026 15: 00
                        Quote: Sergey Mitinsky
                        It's not time to walk, as you say, "over people's heads" and rule the skies as you please.

                        2025g

                        The Israeli Air Force has crippled Iranian air defenses, allowing Israel to easily hit an increasing number of targets.
                        Such control over Iranian airspace is not just a tactical advantage, but a strategic turning point.
                        And now they can fly over the country's capital, Tehran, without resistance.

                        Please, just the facts.
                      11. +2
                        30 July 2026 17: 19
                        Quote: Sergey Mitinsky
                        This post of yours is particularly successful in combining data on the Ukrainian Air Force in 2022 with the pompous story of the defeat of the Egyptian Air Force back in 1967.

                        In 1982, the Syrian air force was destroyed during the destruction of Syrian air defenses Yes

                        Quote: Sergey Mitinsky
                        However, it was Israel and the US that ran out of steam, not Iran.

                        Is Israel exhausted? lol
                        Well, in the US, people are interested in gas prices, but they are not interested in Trump's spending on beating up Iran's third-world ass. Yes
                        But this is relevant for Israel laughing

                        Quote: Sergey Mitinsky
                        You will also remember the war of King David and the air support of his God against the Philistines.

                        I can recall the rapid takeout of Iranian air defenses in 2025. wink
                        In 2026, this was a vulgar beating of Iran
                      12. +1
                        30 July 2026 18: 49
                        You talk too much instead of proving your point.
                        Prove it, gentlemen!
                        Prove it and convince me, but for now it's all just words, and Israel is screwed.
                      13. 0
                        30 July 2026 20: 25
                        Quote: Sergey Mitinsky
                        Israel is screwed

                        But there is a nuance lol
                      14. +1
                        30 July 2026 14: 29
                        Quote: Sergey Mitinsky
                        So, as I understand it, your "friend on his own" claims that the Russian army is actually doing military training there!?)))

                        Not on the SVO, of course.
                        And I know what they went through in their urgent training.
                        Plus minus before the SVO, what they went through, too Yes
                        Not a combatant

                        Quote: Sergey Mitinsky
                        You have finally convinced me that the city of Krasnodar is a thing of the distant past for you and now you are getting information about yourself while sitting in Israel.

                        laughing ...not at all

                        Quote: Sergey Mitinsky
                        The Israeli army has never fought an enemy that is even close to comparable in strength to Ukraine.

                        lol
                        Iran is stronger than Ukraine was at the beginning of the Second World War.

                        Quote: Sergey Mitinsky
                        especially with such support from practically the entire NATO.

                        Israel clashed simultaneously with Egypt and Syria, with the support of the USSR laughing
                        Including advisers, pilots, air defense personnel hi
                        I won't even mention such trifles as Iraqi and Moroccan motorized infantry and tank brigades, as well as Cuban tank crews and North Korean pilots. laughing

                        Quote: Sergey Mitinsky
                        Are you comparing Ukraine with Hezbollah and Syria?!

                        No laughing I'm comparing Syria in the 1970s and 1980s - the Ukrainian Armed Forces weren't even close there.

                        Quote: Sergey Mitinsky
                        Iran is comparable at the beginning of the SVO

                        Ukraine still does not have its missile capabilities.

                        Quote: Sergey Mitinsky
                        but Israel won't even show its nose to face his ground army!

                        laughing So there are no common borders - with the air defenses destroyed, the Iranian army and the IRGC are targets for all types of air forces Yes

                        Quote: Sergey Mitinsky
                        I think that in the fourth year of the war between Israel and Ukraine, there would be nothing left of Israel, given its size and how saturated Ukraine is with drones today.

                        I think that after a week of war with such a poor hole as Ukraine, no matter who supports it, in the event of a clash with Israel, the Ukrainian Armed Forces would go into the state of Hezbollah - i.e. without artillery, aviation, air defense and tanks. Yes
                        Another thing is that the Jews only have to threaten sanctions, and they will quickly stop everything – unlike Russia. Because yes – they have the size and resources
                      15. -1
                        30 July 2026 14: 40
                        Sorry, but this is typical Jewish show-off and bragging.
                        I encounter this all the time.
                        What is particularly noteworthy is your “expert” assessment, which is more reminiscent of a madman’s reasoning that Ukraine and Syria in the 1970s and 1980s “didn’t see the Ukrainian Armed Forces running anywhere near there.”
                        This is, excuse me, sheer nonsense to give such assessments.
                        With that, be well and you haven't convinced me that you live in Krasnodar. hi
                      16. +1
                        30 July 2026 15: 18
                        Quote: Sergey Mitinsky
                        Sorry, but this is typical Jewish show-off and bragging.

                        Even before the Maidan, Ukraine consistently ranked among the three poorest countries in Europe. It, Kosovo, and Moldova
                        Without adequate air forces, etc.
                        Israel, since the mid-1970s, has been writing on SEAD and the like.

                        Quote: Sergey Mitinsky
                        I encounter this all the time

                        Do you live in Israel? Or in Zhukovka? Maybe in Barvikha? laughing

                        Quote: Sergey Mitinsky
                        What is particularly noteworthy is your “expert” assessment, which is more reminiscent of a madman’s reasoning that Ukraine and Syria in the 1970s and 1980s “didn’t see the Ukrainian Armed Forces running anywhere near there.”

                        Naturally, the Syrian army of the mid-1970s and early 1980s had a larger fleet of modern aircraft at the time than Ukraine in 2022, more combat experience in full-scale, combined arms warfare, a very dense air defense system built on the model of Soviet forces in the GDR, a large number of modern tanks, infantry fighting vehicles, etc. Everything that the Ukrainian Armed Forces did not have.

                        Quote: Sergey Mitinsky
                        Be healthy and you haven't convinced me that you live in Krasnodar.

                        I didn't try and you didn't get sick hi
                      17. 0
                        30 July 2026 15: 39
                        Quote: Krasnodar
                        The Syrian army of the mid-1970s and early 1980s had....Everything that the Ukrainian Armed Forces did not have.

                        However, from the very beginning, the Ukrainian Armed Forces had US satellite communications, US satellite reconnaissance, and real-time targeting from US stationary and flying radars.
                        This allows for the launch of surface-to-air missiles without turning on one's radars, and therefore without exposing them to enemy attacks.
                        Well, yes, the bayraktars also played a role in the first stage.
                        And already in the summer of 2022, high-precision homing (Hymars), night vision devices, thermal imagers, and everything else came into play, leading to difficult decisions in the fall. And it also provided a very bleak forecast for the future of the LBS and losses for Russia.
                        However, all the vaunted NATO wunderwaffes have managed to cope and counteract them, and with approximate parity in military spending (70-100 billion dollars on each side), it is the Russian Armed Forces that are advancing.
                      18. +2
                        30 July 2026 17: 33
                        Quote from Nelton.
                        However, from the very beginning, the Ukrainian Armed Forces had US satellite communications, US satellite reconnaissance, and real-time targeting from US stationary and flying radars.

                        Israel has this too and has its own

                        Quote from Nelton.
                        This allows for the launch of surface-to-air missiles without turning on one's radars, and therefore without exposing them to enemy attacks.

                        To shoot, you turn on the radar for a certain period of time anyway - therefore, as soon as you detect that you have been irradiated, the information is transmitted to your comrades in the sky, the radar is detected and everything that the comrades have flies at it

                        Quote from Nelton.
                        Bayraktars also played a role in the first stage.

                        Russia had outposts

                        Quote from Nelton.
                        High-precision (haimars) has been in use since the summer of 2022,

                        Relatively high point

                        Quote from Nelton.
                        night vision devices, thermal imagers and everything else that led to difficult decisions in the fall

                        The Ukrainian Armed Forces had this for a long time.
                        Maybe not on a large scale

                        Quote from Nelton.
                        However, all the vaunted NATO wunderwaffes managed to cope and counteracted,

                        From the Württemberg Army there are only some samples of the new 155mm self-propelled guns, and problems with the monitoring and communication system
                        The rest, including Haimarsy, is Western junk.

                        Quote from Nelton.
                        With approximate parity in military spending (70-100 billion dollars on each side), it is the Russian Armed Forces that are advancing.

                        Yes, indeed - for every cunning tukhes
                      19. +2
                        30 July 2026 18: 02
                        Following the debate is, on the one hand, interesting. On the other, even amusing, as Mr. Mitinsky "argues" either as a less-than-successful unofficial propagandist or as an unfortunate victim of propaganda... lol
                      20. +2
                        30 July 2026 20: 22
                        Metinsky our Slonyara laughing
                      21. +2
                        30 July 2026 18: 28
                        Quote: Sergey Mitinsky
                        This is, excuse me, sheer nonsense to give such assessments.

                        Ukraine, January 1, 2022
                        Tanks + BMP 610
                        628 trunks
                        There are 124 planes
                        1967 g
                        Egypt
                        Tanks 900
                        Trunks 1000
                        Aircraft 284
                        Syria
                        Tanks 340
                        360 barrels
                        Aircraft 106
                        Jordan
                        Tanks 290
                        450 barrels
                        30 planes
                        Yes, that's a fact. "The Ukrainian Armed Forces didn't run nearby."
                        And it took Israel 6 days to drive the USSR's money into the ground.
                      22. +2
                        30 July 2026 20: 23
                        Quote: vitgusin
                        to drive the USSR's money into the ground

                        Jordan - UK and US money
                      23. +2
                        30 July 2026 20: 53
                        Quote: Krasnodar
                        Jordan - UK and US money

                        Yes, + France.
                      24. +2
                        30 July 2026 22: 36
                        I don't know that, to be honest.
                        There were initially British investments in Jordan, then the United States took over.
                        I haven't read anything about the French.
                        Although it is logical - in contrast to Egypt, having changed the priority under De Gaul from Israel to an Arab country
                      25. +2
                        31 July 2026 07: 48
                        Quote: Krasnodar
                        I haven't read anything about the French.

                        290 tanks and self-propelled guns, up to 450 artillery units and 30 combat aircraft (mainly British and French production).

                        Okorokov Alexander "Secret Wars of the Soviet Union".
                      26. +2
                        30 July 2026 11: 36
                        Quote: Sergey Mitinsky
                        If the modern Israeli army had arrived from its resort to the Ukrainian LBS, there wouldn't have been a single belt left.

                        Thank you both for conducting the dialogue for me.
                        Let's wait. I know a taut spring can't remain in this state for long. Netanyahu and Trump met in Washington on July 28, 2026. Both said it was the best meeting of the seven they had held so far. There's very little information, but it's known that Israel will only initiate military action in two circumstances:
                        If Trump asks.
                        If the IRGC shells Israel.
                        In the first and second cases, Trump will not stop the Israeli Air Force for the 4th time during military operations.
                        By all appearances, it will be soon.

                        And when you figure it out -
                        All roads lead to Rome, -
                        Then come
                        Then let's talk.


                        V. Vysotsky.
                      27. 0
                        30 July 2026 12: 50
                        Well, we'll see ))) wink
                      28. +1
                        30 July 2026 15: 04
                        Quote: Sergey Mitinsky
                        Well, we'll see )))

                        I agree!
  3. 0
    29 July 2026 22: 28
    The author of this article is wrong as always.
    Because, by the way, the core of such a state in the state under Stalin was
    It was called the NKVD, the service of which formed entire regiments, divisions and even armies and controlled the most sensitive sectors of the economy, including such a huge project as the creation of atomic weapons, so that it is entirely possible to recreate such a structure in Russia if necessary.
    As for the IRGC, its structure is similar to the SS, which also had a significant stake in the German economy, and, like the USSR, had no religious ties. Quite the contrary: the SS, like their Führer, were atheists regarding Christianity and believed in all sorts of pagan nonsense, but that's another story.
  4. 0
    3 August 2026 17: 07
    A good analysis of Iran. I didn't know they had everything so well thought out and organized. Regarding using their experience in Russia... I'm skeptical. They have a different mentality. There won't be any mosaic of important leadership structures; the Kremlin won't agree to that for fear of diminishing its power. Besides, Russians are too lazy to prepare anything in advance, to foresee anything. This unfortunate bastard is a prime example of that.