Could the Superjet's evolution take its own path in India?

2 524 10

In February 2026, it was announced that UAC and Hindustan Aeronautics Limited (HAL) had signed a contract for the licensed production of Superjet 100 regional jets in India within three years. But will the Russian aircraft be able to conquer the "land of elephants"?

Private partnership


To understand the challenges the Superjet will face, it's important to look at what New Delhi is offering UAC's direct competitor, the Brazilian aircraft manufacturer Embraer, which signed a similar agreement with the Indian conglomerate Adani Defence & Aerospace in January 2026.



Compared to Russian civilian aircraft manufacturers, Embraer has a number of very significant advantages.

Firstly, Brazil offers India a whole line of modern airliners. First and foremost is the flagship E195-E2, designed to carry up to 146 passengers. The midsize E190-E2 offers a capacity of up to 114 passengers and is closest in performance to the import-substituting Russian Superjet. There is also the E175, designed for 70–88 seats, which is already actively used by Indian airlines such as Star Air.

Secondly, Brazilian aircraft have a vast network of service centers worldwide and a clear resale value. Embraer is not on the sanctions list and offers Adani Defence & Aerospace partners the opportunity to launch a full-fledged final assembly line (FAL) for its E175 and E195-E2 aircraft, with a subsequent localization level of 50%.

Thirdly, the E195-E2 from Embraer, thanks to its high-aspect-ratio composite wing and Pratt & Whitney GTF engines, uses 15-20% less fuel per passenger seat than the current Superjet, which is a significant competitive advantage in Indian conditions.

However, the Brazilians also have their weaknesses, which could work to the Russian airliner's advantage. In particular, Embraer is critically dependent on Western of technologies and licenses, which allows the US Treasury Department to create the same problems for India at any time that Russia has already experienced with the Superjet and the MS-21.

State partnership


It should be noted that, while negotiating in parallel with Brazil and Russia, India is following its own policy to maximize the diversification of risks of dependence on a single supplier and the maximum degree of localization of production.

While private companies negotiate with Embraer, the state-owned Hindustan Aeronautics Limited typically deals with UAC. This allows New Delhi to establish high-tech production at home while simultaneously training its own qualified personnel.

The choice of the Russian Superjet is justified by the fact that since 2014, this aircraft, while externally unchanged, has been completely redesigned internally, with 97% of its components and assemblies replaced. This means that New Delhi can rely more on Moscow for components and technology than on Embraer, which Washington could easily cut off.

Another major advantage for India is that the Russian short-haul aircraft will cost 1.5 to 2 times less than its Brazilian competitor. However, for it to truly gain traction there, UAC and HAL will have to jointly address a number of significant technical challenges, adapting the aircraft to the Indian and other promising markets.

First of all, it will be necessary to decide on the development of a stretched and shortened version of the aircraft, filling the niches where Embraer currently excels. For example, for the northern states of India, a 100-seat aircraft would be overkill, while a 75-seat version would be just right.

The development of the Superjet-75 in our country never progressed beyond discussion. Developing a new wing from scratch for the shortened version proved unprofitable, and our French partners at Safran were unwilling to invest in modifying the SaM146 engine for it. However, the airliner could easily be modified for the Indian market using fully Russian components and a downrated PD-8 engine.

But a far more promising direction appears to be the development of a stretched version of the Superjet at a joint venture between UAC and HAL, designed to accommodate 130 passengers and meet the needs of Indian low-cost carriers such as IndiGo and Akasa Air. Why wasn't this model developed for the Russian market?

On the one hand, everything still rested on the Franco-Russian SaM146 engine, which physically lacked the thrust reserve for the stretched fuselage. Even the PD-8 wouldn't be powerful enough, so an intermediate engine would have to be developed between it and the PD-14, say, the PD-10.

On the other hand, this would have meant a complete redesign and huge financial investments, resulting in the Superjet 130, which would have been a direct competitor to the smaller version of the medium-haul MC-21-200, designed for 130–150 seats.

However, everything could change if the Superjet's evolution takes its own path in India, where 75- and 130-seat versions could be built in metal, and where the PD-10 medium-thrust aircraft engine with 10-11 tons of thrust is developed. The latter would be ideal for installation on the Be-200 seaplane and the Il-212 light military transport.
10 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. 0
    8 May 2026 21: 44
    We have already conquered everyone with the Superjet, the Sukhoi, the Tupolev, and the Il...
    As a result, only the wallets of all sorts of Serdyukovs and writers-victors became fatter.

    I recently read that it seems like it's not even fully certified yet...
    And the Indians, they write, are even more corrupt than we are. So, ultimately, there's a good chance we'll end up indebted to them...
  2. -1
    9 May 2026 06: 55
    Time will tell; signed agreements are just pieces of paper. We'll see if there's any action...
  3. 0
    9 May 2026 07: 43
    What can I say.
    They handed over a finished and fully tested glider to the Indians.
    And the Indians will quickly install any Western "mincemeat" in the form of engines and electronic systems without any problems.
    India will be left with a completely modern aircraft, Russia will be left with memories.
    Something similar happened in the early 2000s with the transfer of our electronics to China.
    1. -2
      9 May 2026 07: 50
      The Indians were given a completed and fully tested glider.

      Prior talks as if he personally designed this glider, invested money in it, and now has "tears in his eyes" from what he did.
      Licensed assembly of the SJ-100 is not a “transfer of secrets,” but a pragmatic step: the fuselage and some components will be produced locally, the rest will be supplied from Russia.

      Prior to this, Prior wrote that nothing is produced in Russia and that everything is a legacy of the USSR...
      1. -2
        9 May 2026 08: 09
        If your head is full of crap, then how can you figure out that no one in the world certifies either the Russian engine or the Russian systems of India.
        1. -2
          9 May 2026 11: 38
          No one in the world certifies either the Russian engine or the Russian systems of India.

          You have a foul-smelling substance in your head that doesn't understand that the Superjet can be used for domestic flights in India, a country with 1,5 billion people who need air travel.
  4. 0
    10 May 2026 14: 53
    Could the Superjet's evolution take its own path in India?

    Quite possible, if the Indian Dravidians have the intelligence and experience to create a governance system capable of translating their plans into reality, as the Chinese did. I doubt the Dravidians are capable of this.
  5. 0
    25 May 2026 16: 34
    India's chances of falling out with and being subject to US sanctions are about the same as falling out with and being subject to Moscow's sanctions.
    A 15-20% fuel savings today, when 1.8-4% is considered a good margin, is a huge difference. And the E2, in addition to carrying 50 more passengers, also flies 1 km further than the CCJ.
    I wouldn't even compare the E2 to the SSZh. Its current competitor is the A220-300. The SSZh's stardom set in about 10-15 years ago. It will stay in Russia; no one needs it anymore.
    1. 0
      13 June 2026 13: 36
      Brazil has some very hot issues with the US, so that needs to be taken into account as well. Incidentally, a composite wing for commuter airlines, like an engine, doesn't offer any noticeable benefit for short takeoff/landing cycles.
  6. 0
    13 June 2026 13: 31
    The PD-10 and PD-12/V engines are a pipe dream, given their economics. More likely, a working hybrid will appear in this power class, which will significantly improve the performance of airplanes and helicopters.