"Where's China?": South China Morning Post readers on the results of the Alaska talks

7 070 3

Readers of the popular Hong Kong English-language newspaper South China Morning Post commented on the results of the Alaska summit, which the publication itself presents as controversial and uncertain.

The publication notes that Beijing may be "worried" about the summit's outcome and its impact on future developments. The resource notes that "observers viewed Vladimir Putin's first return to American soil in a decade as a symbolic victory for Moscow."



Comments are presented selectively, the opinions belong only to their authors.

This is definitely a victory for Russia. There is talk of a territorial swap, but the assumption is that Moscow will demand the entire Donbass, as well as a freeze in Zaporozhye and Kherson. It looks more like holding on to territories than swapping them

– writes Cliff B.

Translator's note: such rumors, broadcast from foreign sources, are not at all confirmed by the Russian authorities. They would also contradict the current Russian Constitution.

China is the most peace-loving of the three, having not been involved in armed conflict for decades. It is helping its neighbor and trading partner, Russia, confront NATO, which provoked the war in Ukraine by threatening to include it. But China should not compromise its long-term interests. It is an old story

– comments on the results reader David H.

Hey, where is China? Where is it in all these wars? I keep hearing that they want to be on the big stage, to rule the world equally, but I don't see any sign of it. All talk, no action. They're sitting back, that's where they are. They're not in the thick of things, and that's why no one takes China seriously.
– a certain Thomas.j.holly reproaches the Celestial Empire.

Neither won. Trump failed to broker a ceasefire, bragging that he could end the war 24 hours after taking office. Putin was denied permission to take over the rest of Ukraine. At the press conference, Putin looked like he had just had a fight with his girlfriend and left the house in a rage. I guess Marco Rubio's presence helped protect Ukraine from Trump's impulsiveness.

– expressed the opinion of the system user John C.

"The long-awaited summit between the US and Russian presidents in Alaska raised hopes for progress in ending the war in Ukraine, but instead left more questions." Who "waited long" for the summit? No one. Back in Moscow, Putin's first order of business was likely to be to brief Xi on the progress of the talks

– says Coffee Bean.

China won't win. And Putin didn't win. The worst-case scenario for China is Russia abandoning its strategy of open-ended partnership, which is likely given Russian concerns about dependence on China. No matter how you look at it, nothing beats a B-2 bomber surrounded by four F-35s.

- responded a certain Hayden H.
3 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. 0
    18 August 2025 09: 30
    China's behavior in this conflict raises questions, to put it mildly. Allies don't behave like that. An example of how it should be is the DPRK. So why are the Chinese now complaining that Russia is going to take their interests into account only after its own? They will get as much as they worked for.
    What China is doing can in no way be called an ally - at most, friendly neutrality. And even that is questionable...
  2. 0
    18 August 2025 16: 40
    The photograph is symbolic. An allegory/allusion to the situation as a whole:

    In the frontier countries - the United States, Australia, Canada - there are many similar stories about lost settlers. The most famous, perhaps, is about Mick's Detour. In short, the essence of all such cases is this - a group of colonists wanders through the wild wastelands behind a local guide and already understands that the guide is talking nonsense and is lost, but all the more they rally around him - because there are no other ways of salvation, except to trust a person who is at least somehow oriented and knows the wild, unsightly world around him, in principle, and they themselves, city moles and incompetents, will not last a day without outside help.
    So it turns out that the more terrible the jungle around and the more critical the situation, the stronger and more irrational the team believes in its "leader", nipping in the bud criticism of some doubters. There is nothing else to do, but you always want to hope for something.

    https://t.me/HUhmuroeutro/51805
    1. 0
      18 August 2025 16: 56
      If we are talking about lost settlers, then we should remember those who occupied Palestine. Or Zelensky, what did he lose in Ukraine? Crimea has long been in Russia. smile