In modern armies there are no commanders capable of ensuring the interaction of large formations

4

Conducting large-scale military exercises of NATO countries in the Atlantic Ocean showed that there are no commanders left in modern armies capable of managing large-scale operations. After the end of World War II, there was no need to ensure the interaction of tens and hundreds of formations as a whole.

A modern large-scale military operation breaks down into several elements. Separate brigades or groupings of troops perform disparate tasks, since the experience of managing large armies as a whole has been lost. A striking example of this was NATO exercises involving aircraft carriers from five countries. According to the plan of the organizers of the naval maneuvers, the ships of the United States, Italy, France and Great Britain were to work out full cooperation and jointly carry out combat missions. However, in fact, each of the aircraft carrier teams performed their tasks with a very low level of coordination.



As consultants, the Americans have to bring in long-retired Cold War commanders. The peers of the current American president, who managed large squadrons during the era of Ronald Reagan, remember the principles of managing large formations. In the current generation of generals and admirals, there are no commanders of this level.

Problems in organizing the interaction of large formations exist in the American army not only at sea, but also on land. A large-scale exercise at the Pentagon is considered to involve one ground brigade with support and control units. Maneuvers or combat operations involving a large army break up into several separate operations, and even modern controls are not able to ensure the coordination of joint actions.
  • Mass Communication Specialist 3rd Class Vincent J. Street/wikimedia.org
Our news channels

Subscribe and stay up to date with the latest news and the most important events of the day.

4 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. +1
    27 March 2023 12: 23
    What nonsense, just NATO showed how to maintain a database in modern realities, by digitalizing information and intelligence. Knowing in real time what the enemy is doing.
    The fact that the ingenious super-genius admiral generals failed the NMD by training the army for parades does not mean that no one knows how to use large-scale databases. Didn't the NVO show this for a whole year, how NATO LGBT generals (hihi-haha) outplayed the General Staff and the women's battalion?
    1. 0
      27 March 2023 15: 02
      It seems like ...
    2. 0
      28 March 2023 17: 39
      Quote from Hell MASTER
      What nonsense, just NATO showed how to maintain a database in modern realities, by digitalizing information and intelligence. Knowing in real time what the enemy is doing.
      The fact that the ingenious super-genius admiral generals failed the NMD by training the army for parades does not mean that no one knows how to use large-scale databases. Didn't the NVO show this for a whole year, how NATO LGBT generals (hihi-haha) outplayed the General Staff and the women's battalion?

      As a matter of fact, you are right, but in general, many people are responsible for the failure. I do not think that the generals are guilty of misjudging the mood of the Ukrainians. Further. The shortage of troops already in March raised the question of mobilization, or at least preparation for it. And we were completely unprepared for it, in any respect. The generals are not to blame for the fact that they are not ready, but the generals are not to blame for the fact that the mobilization was delayed until September.
      1. 0
        28 March 2023 20: 45
        The main problems of today's Russian Federation are that there is no commander-in-chief who requires responsibility, the system is built on corruption and sycophancy, where shoulder straps and positions are not for success, but for proximity to the circle and the top. Here the system showed its failure, at the first serious verification by deed. While the parades and biathlons were going on, no problems were visible, everyone was satisfied with the eyewash, kickbacks are regular. We went to check in practice, and there are no uniforms, not like Armat and other new weapons. But the system does not change, and the problems worsen when it explodes, only a function of time ..