Ex-Deputy Minister of Defense of the Russian Federation offered to stop lying


The Russian Defense Ministry is too dry about what is happening on the fronts of the special operation and is silent about many events, thereby undermining people's confidence in the authorities. Andrey Kartapolov, former Deputy Minister of Defense of Russia, spoke about this on the air of the Soloviev Live TV program.


The first thing to do is stop lying

- noted Kartapolov.

In illustrating his thesis, the ex-deputy minister recalled the Sovinformburo reports for 1941, in which the announcer spoke openly about the withdrawal of the Red Army, the stubborn repulsion of attacks by the outnumbered enemy, the abandonment of settlements and losses. At the same time, the heroism of the Soviet people and real achievements on the path to Victory were reported.

People who heard Levitan and read news in the Soviet newspapers, they understood the gravity of the situation and knew that the enemy was on the territory of their native country. At the same time, Kartapolov recalled that at present the enemy is also attacking Russian cities and villages, but the citizens of the Russian Federation learn about this from military correspondents, bloggers and other people.

We have destroyed almost all the border villages of the Belgorod region, the city-fortress of Valuyki is under constant fire. But we learn about it from anyone, but not from officials. Reports of the Ministry of Defense practically do not change their content

Andrey Kartapolov stressed with regret.

Thus, the former deputy minister believes, the authorities do not consider it necessary to tell the people even part of the truth. Such an attitude can lead to a loss of credibility.

37 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. Vladimir80 Offline Vladimir80
    Vladimir80 5 October 2022 17: 06
    +11
    at least one told the truth, only who will listen to him "above"? What is Kartapolov's position now?
    1. Corsair Offline Corsair
      Corsair 5 October 2022 17: 35
      +4
      People who heard Levitan and read the news in Soviet newspapers understood the gravity of the situation and knew that the enemy was on the territory of their native country.

      Levitan was a HUMAN in spite of his very slender complexion.
      In vain, the demoniac declared him his personal enemy?
      Neither Zelensky nor Biden will say such a thing about Konashenko No. On the contrary, they will also issue a "Certificate of Protection" - "For a special contribution" ...
      1. trampoline instructor 5 October 2022 22: 57
        -3
        Personal enemy? Is it a title or an honorary position?
        As far as I know, Hitler considered Stalin, Roosevelt, Churchill and de Gaulle to be his personal enemies.
    2. Moscow Offline Moscow
      Moscow 5 October 2022 19: 08
      +6
      Chairman of the State Duma Defense Committee, Colonel-General Andrey Kartapolov
  2. prior Offline prior
    prior 5 October 2022 17: 08
    +1
    The first thing to do is stop lying

    The second thing to do is to ban ads.
    Advertising is a complete lie. She corrupts. It legitimizes lies on a national scale.
    Everyone sees it and everyone puts up with it. We are stupidly taught to lie and believe lies.
    We live in a country of total lies.
    And how after that to trust the authorities?!
  3. Moscow Offline Moscow
    Moscow 5 October 2022 17: 13
    +16
    There is such a form of lying - this is silence. This is such a special form of contempt for his people, who will not understand the problems. Listen to what they say to you and sit in your kitchens, discuss whatever you want. The authorities cannot talk about Belgorod or Kursk in terms of the NWO, because they can’t do anything about it or don’t really want to adequately and harshly respond to Ukraine. It is necessary to pump gas, to drive grain from Ukraine to the West, and most importantly not to anger the West. Silencing the truth about the NWO is, in fact, a form of powerlessness and contempt.
  4. Alex D Offline Alex D
    Alex D 5 October 2022 17: 14
    +12
    30 years is just lying. First, they made the country a "raw material colony" of the West, and then they called it great. No need to lie - Stalin's USSR was a great country. And Russia is a semi-colony, a non-sovereign state with banditry (instead of capitalism and socialism) as a form of government. Actually, the West, from which Russia learns forever, is exactly how it lives.
    It seems to me that Russia urgently needs to abandon semi-criminal practices within the country and stop trying to please the West, because the West is only looking for profit by lying with three boxes.
    1. elenuska61 Offline elenuska61
      elenuska61 6 October 2022 09: 42
      0
      And how do you imagine it?!
  5. Vox_Populi Offline Vox_Populi
    Vox_Populi 5 October 2022 17: 23
    -1
    Thus, the former deputy minister believes, the authorities do not consider it necessary to tell the people even part of the truth.

    Surprisingly: after all, about 2 weeks ago, in an interview with RBC, he answered the presenter's question that deputies of the State Duma and the Federation Council were also subject to mobilization. However, in the text of the relevant law it is clearly and clearly stated that they have a reservation from mobilization ... winked
    But R.A. Kadyrov was awarded the military rank of Colonel General! Some may be happy for him, but... winked
    1. Corsair Offline Corsair
      Corsair 5 October 2022 17: 44
      +3
      Quote from: Vox_Populi
      Surprisingly: after all, about 2 weeks ago, in an interview with RBC, he answered the presenter's question that deputies of the State Duma and the Federation Council were also subject to mobilization. However, in the text of the relevant law it is clearly and clearly stated that they have a reservation from mobilization ...

      I do not track the status of certain individuals, but N. Valuev received a summons. Is he a member of the State Duma?
      Deputy Milonov went to the front as a volunteer, Borodai too.

      What are you hysterical about?
      1. Polente the Wanderer 5 October 2022 18: 07
        -2
        Valuev is 49 years old, that he served in the army, there is no information anywhere. What kind of call is he talking about.
        1. Corsair Offline Corsair
          Corsair 5 October 2022 21: 08
          +6
          Quote: Wanderer Polente
          Valuev is 49 years old, there is no information anywhere that he served in the army.What kind of call are you talking about?.

          He is a reserve officer who graduated from the military department of the university.

          This is the call we are talking about....
      2. Polente the Wanderer 5 October 2022 18: 37
        0

        Valuev graduated from the Institute of Physical Education.
      3. Vox_Populi Offline Vox_Populi
        Vox_Populi 6 October 2022 17: 55
        0
        I do not track the status of certain individuals, but N. Valuev received a summons. Is he a member of the State Duma?
        Deputy Milonov went to the front as a volunteer, Borodai too.

        If interested, then personally read the law (or a Chukchi writer?). lol
        About volunteers: there are no obstacles for patriots (DMB)! They wrote to you about the nature of the agenda for Valuev. Why are you so worried? winked
  6. Polente the Wanderer 5 October 2022 18: 11
    +1

    https://t.me/nickvaluev/5899
    1. Corsair Offline Corsair
      Corsair 5 October 2022 21: 19
      +3
      Quote: Wanderer Polente
      What call are you talking about.
      Quote: Wanderer Polente
      https://t.me/nickvaluev/5899

      So maybe - at the beginning it was worth figuring out, finding this information before asking a question (quote above)?
    2. Colonel Kudasov Offline Colonel Kudasov
      Colonel Kudasov 6 October 2022 07: 12
      0
      It will be difficult for Valuev to find uniforms
      1. Corsair Offline Corsair
        Corsair 6 October 2022 14: 07
        +2
        Quote: Colonel Kudasov
        It will be difficult for Valuev to find uniforms

        A citizen is quite wealthy, and he can buy everything he needs.
        Our boys, having a modest income where sick, buy their own uniforms instead of "glass".
  7. Jacques sekavar Offline Jacques sekavar
    Jacques sekavar 5 October 2022 18: 23
    +4
    The current President of the Republic, Colonel-General Kadyrov, and the current State Duma member, ex-Deputy Minister of Defense of the Russian Federation, Kartapolov, say the same thing - stop lying and thereby undermine people's trust in power, which means they have reason.
    From this, one can make an assumption about serious contradictions in power structures, the intensity of which spills out and brings confusion to society and is one of the prerequisites for defeat in the war with all the ensuing consequences.
    1. Alexey Davydov Offline Alexey Davydov
      Alexey Davydov 5 October 2022 19: 25
      0
      From this, one can make an assumption about serious contradictions in power structures, the intensity of which spills out and brings confusion to society and is one of the prerequisites for defeat in the war with all the ensuing consequences.

      Or vice versa - one of the prerequisites for a beneficial change in leadership, which is now leading the country into the abyss in accordance with the Anglo-Saxons' plan to foment a war between Russia and NATO. Russia needs to create an inevitable threat to the territory of the United States and Great Britain with our nuclear weapons, forcing them to retreat in all positions. However, for this, you must first free yourself from subordinating the leadership of the Russian Federation to them, which means blocking their decisions on the use of our strategic nuclear weapons
  8. The comment was deleted.
  9. Benjamin Offline Benjamin
    Benjamin 5 October 2022 21: 52
    +4
    And so in everything, the regime is built on lies
  10. Hiker Offline Hiker
    Hiker 5 October 2022 22: 08
    0
    That is, in Belgorod and not only, there was a laser beam, and not an atmospheric phenomenon? Well, if you do not lie ...))))))
  11. Alexey Davydov Offline Alexey Davydov
    Alexey Davydov 5 October 2022 22: 51
    +3
    Thus, the former deputy minister believes, the authorities do not consider it necessary to tell the people even part of the truth. Such an attitude can lead to a loss of credibility.

    If this does not concern the authorities, we, moreover, should not bother ourselves with the continuation of its longevity.
    The end of the credibility of the authorities is a logical outcome that has been so much delayed.
    They don’t change horses at the crossing - that’s right. Because it is inconvenient and risky.
    Well, what if the horses are carried straight into the pool? If this is happening because they have been controlled by the enemy for 30 years now? How then is the situation at the crossing with convenience and risk?
  12. Alexey Davydov Offline Alexey Davydov
    Alexey Davydov 6 October 2022 00: 42
    +1
    Lies are not interesting in and of themselves. Much more important is his purpose.
    In one case, it simply, childishly, delays the punishment.
    In another, it makes it difficult to neutralize the plan being carried out.
    The concept: "Russia needs a compact professional army for local conflicts and modern strategic nuclear forces to protect the sovereignty and security of the state" belonged personally to Putin, and all these years he has been actively promoting it. It was the task of dismantling the "superfluous" forces that was, practically openly, set by him to Serdyukov. Which he successfully did. Before the war in Ukraine, this result was considered by Putin himself, and by his ruling party, without any reservations, as a positive achievement. Parallel processes of "fatting" and "optimization" took place, and are still taking place, in all other areas.
    And now the "moment of truth" has come.
    Stupidity and betrayal often look the same in their visible consequences. I can't ascribe the first to Putin. So this is the second one.
    Think for yourself:
    Being "under control" Yeltsin could transfer his power (under the same control) ONLY to someone who was able to continue this "work" of his. It is likely that even then the States formed for themselves reliable guarantees for the control of the authorities in Russia. How could it be otherwise?
    What do we currently have?
    The Anglo-Saxons, under their control by governments in Ukraine and Russia, create a hotbed of war in quiet and stable Europe, in which:
    - Ukraine has already practically formed from Russia, in conflict with it, an instrument for inciting this war
    - Russia in the conflict with Europe is almost ready to fulfill its role of "match" and "fuel for ignition"
    - the governments of the countries of Europe controlled by the Anglo-Saxons are almost ready to draw their countries into this war - the cold winter probably "should" bring them to condition
    As a result of this war, according to the plan of the Anglo-Saxons, Russia is destined to die, giving them its resources, and weakening Europe, just enough so that it, without resistance, becomes a manufacturing appendage of the United States.
    The result is the complete dominance of the States over the European part of the world, its transformation into their production appendage.
    This construction of the Anglo-Saxons can only be destroyed by a threat of mutual destruction, which the USSR successfully did with the Americans in 1961, however, the control of the Anglo-Saxons over our power, thus implies their control over our strategic nuclear weapons, at least regarding threats to them, and its application.
    Thus, in order to escape from the clutches of the Anglo-Saxons, Russia must first change the government extremely competently
    1. The comment was deleted.
    2. elenuska61 Offline elenuska61
      elenuska61 6 October 2022 09: 52
      -5
      Nonsense!!! What change of power?! The country is big, it's hard to keep track of everything, of course there are problems. As for nuclear weapons, they will use them only at the very last moment !!!!
      1. Alex D Offline Alex D
        Alex D 6 October 2022 11: 17
        +4
        Quote from: elenuska61
        Nonsense!!! What change of power?! The country is big, it's hard to keep track of everything, of course there are problems. As for nuclear weapons, they will use them only at the very last moment !!!!

        Big inaccuracy. If the State Council is created, monopolies like Gosugol, etc. it will be much easier to control. The country does not need 350 banks, 5 will suffice. Kazakhstan has already taken up its head!
        If the government does not change pharmacy from state banditry to digestible, then it needs to be changed!
        And by the way, a lot would change if at least the severance tax was from the proceeds and let's say 90 percent!
  13. Moscow Offline Moscow
    Moscow 6 October 2022 02: 21
    +10
    Kadyrov, Prigozhin, Kartapolov people of the system. Politicians. Knowing perfectly well that PR just isn't worth it. Moreover, making political accusations in public is nonsense for members of the United Russia. This means that we are being prepared for some changes since it was necessary to inform the public about the problems of the NWO through the media. We wait.
    1. trampoline instructor 6 October 2022 08: 37
      +4
      They undermine the authority of the commander in the eyes of his subordinates. This time.
      This story with Kadyrov and Prigozhin shows that there is no unity in the top Russian leadership in matters of strategy and tactics for the entire NWO. This is two.
  14. Alex D Offline Alex D
    Alex D 6 October 2022 11: 14
    +2
    The enemy is already in Moscow, they have been purging our country for 30 years, and we are helping them in this. I suggest that everyone who works for raw material producers - exporters, in banks and foreign retailers - quit or demand a salary many times higher. For example, coal miners may demand an increase at times! See coal prices and how much cunning businessmen are paying us.
    SVO is only a distraction from the real problems.
    I wonder how they still go to war for this power. But they are going to fight for the security of the country, on the other hand, this security has already been violated, 30 years ago.
    1. guest Offline guest
      guest 6 October 2022 14: 56
      0
      Quote from Alex D
      I wonder how they still go to war for this power.

      And during the Second World War, do you think everyone was a Stalinist? Many hated Stalin, but all the same, under the cries of "for the motherland, for Stalin," they went forward.
      1. Alexey Davydov Offline Alexey Davydov
        Alexey Davydov 6 October 2022 16: 21
        +2
        Don't overdo it. Stalin was the embodiment of concern for the motherland, and really raised Russia. Therefore, for people there was no difference. In difficult times for the Motherland, he himself wore overcoats and lived simply. Another thing is Putin, with his failures in all areas, but with ten million declared annual income. This, of course, is not the highest figure in power, but he, by the personal example of the President, only supports the general kickback-corruption system that is ruining the country
        1. The comment was deleted.
          1. The comment was deleted.
            1. The comment was deleted.
        2. guest Offline guest
          guest 25 November 2022 02: 35
          0
          And I don’t compare Putin with Stalin, the comparison will not be in Putin’s favor.
  15. Alex D Offline Alex D
    Alex D 6 October 2022 11: 28
    +5
    Quote: Benjamin
    And so in everything, the regime is built on lies

    It is especially pleasing when people talk about "our oil", "our gas", "our gold". I won't be surprised if the country doesn't even see 10% of the revenue, and they call the raw materials "ours". In fact, the country of Russia is a raw material colony of the West. Import - fictitious, overpriced. Export shown only 500 billion dollars. That's what the West is fighting for! No country feeds them like that, and our people for them and our traitors are bio-garbage that they burn in the furnaces of war and viruses like LGBT and covid.
  16. South North Offline South North
    South North 6 October 2022 12: 56
    -1
    the president must take responsibility
    the position of special operation for the Patriotic War should be reclassified
    so that there is responsibility for the mess in the country that has been going on for 30 years
    for lack of will wrecking sabotage
    next to the president is an odious man of the sands as he climbs with his comments people on their hind legs cannot stand him and he is nearby
    can we cross the mess
    become responsible people
    let's start fighting and not play some rotten games
    1. Alexey Davydov Offline Alexey Davydov
      Alexey Davydov 6 October 2022 14: 42
      +1
      It's stupid to bet everything on the loser when the country has its last chance
  17. South North Offline South North
    South North 6 October 2022 18: 46
    0
    and we will say that the peace party in Russia is headed by
    oligarch Abromovich
    that the failures of the army, we must thank this grouping in the power of these enemies, where they die, here they are traitors
  18. svit55 Offline svit55
    svit55 6 October 2022 20: 59
    0
    Against the background of the fact that the generals turned out to be completely worthless or stupid, Kartapolov's statement is timely. One gets the impression that Putin is being informed of the situation according to Kanashenkov's reports)))) and he believes that the people are worried, and the president is silent.