The Spectator told who “set up” President Putin in Ukraine

45

The twenty-first century, without a doubt, has brought changes to all spheres and areas of life, including a large policies. Tyrants have ceased to be tyrants, that is, who they really are. They began to appear democrats and avoid pariah status, using not violence, as before, but cunning to achieve their goals. This new breed of strong men began showing up at meetings in formal suits instead of military uniforms to chat with the world's democratic elite on an equal footing. Now they are hiring sociologists and political consultants, giving speeches to citizens and sending their children to universities in the West.

Until recently, this formula worked, but one of the most intelligent and powerful politicians of our time, Russian President Vladimir Putin, made an unfortunate mistake and went beyond the doctrine of the behavior of any modern ruler. British political scientist David Patrikarakos writes about this in an article for The Spectator, putting forward his version of what happened.

As the expert notes, formidable world leaders gradually learned the lessons of the last century and moved away from the image of a tyrant, trying to look more democratic, although they were not. If in the past a strong personality was associated with the dictates of fear, now the rulers are more focused on the formation of public opinion than on the violent repressions of the past.



In this aspect, Russian President Vladimir Putin made a mistake. However, it is not his fault in this mistake, he was literally "set up" by enemies from the environment, which just wants to get rid of the real leader of his country. Therefore, now the Kremlin has repeated the fate of the Syrian leader Bashar al-Assad and has fallen into an ambiguous international situation.

For example, in Ukraine now one can see the "return" of the 20th century. Moscow's actions are connected neither with persuasion, nor with cunning, nor with juggling. They are honest and old-fashioned, full of hard power backed by a desire for pure victory without behind-the-scenes games and secret pacts.

Putin, after 20 years of a reign backed by true top support, has succumbed to an alienation from reality caused by the sycophants around him

says the British expert.

The iron rule of any government is not to listen and not always trust the environment, which can work for the enemy, have their own goals, or simply be narrow-minded, which is doubly dangerous, Patrikarakos summed up.
  • kremlin.ru
Our news channels

Subscribe and stay up to date with the latest news and the most important events of the day.

45 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. -9
    11 July 2022 08: 50
    What he sowed, he shook it.
    1. +3
      11 July 2022 11: 43
      Didn't annoy. Let's fix it.
      1. -1
        12 July 2022 19: 22
        "Aluminum Cucumbers".
        In general, the author is right - it is clear to any teapot that this is a mistake. An old-fashioned blitzkrieg clearly requires more than 150
    2. +3
      11 July 2022 19: 43
      We can check everything, but what did he do, couch worker.
  2. +18
    11 July 2022 08: 58
    to chat with the world's democratic elite on an equal footing.

    And the "world democratic elite" is, excuse me, who is it? Those who drove Iraq and Libya into the stone age? Do you call this the NATO elite, which unleashed dozens of new wars on the planet after WW2, "world democratic"? This is Barack Obama, who, after receiving the Nobel Peace Prize, tore Gaddafi to pieces in front of the whole world, and Hillary Clinton, looking at this with pleasure, exclaimed - "Wow"!? And how do they then differ from the "non-democratic elite"?
  3. +7
    11 July 2022 09: 19
    Such a publication, which has the goal of personally influencing V. Putin, indicates that he is pursuing the right policy in the interests of his country!
    1. 0
      11 July 2022 10: 20
      This is a breakthrough and sanctions will only benefit us!
  4. +12
    11 July 2022 09: 23
    Where's the base? The fact that Ukraine has become an enemy and the most dangerous for Russia is a fact and the destruction of the Nazis and the drug addict regime is simply necessary in the shortest possible time. And also the return of its historical territories, Russia is simply obliged to do this.
  5. -1
    11 July 2022 10: 21
    No time for swing
    1. +3
      11 July 2022 11: 44
      Vasya - do you have another person behind the keyboard?
  6. +5
    11 July 2022 10: 24
    This new breed of strong men began showing up at meetings in formal suits instead of military uniforms to chat with the world's democratic elite on an equal footing.

    This is the breed. And the breed is valued in animals-horses, dogs, cows.
    For 30 years this breed has been forming anti-Russia out of Ukraine. Formed in a vile way, through the unfinished fascist henchmen-Bandera. And when it achieved its goal, when anti-Russia began to get hit in the spine for its actions, the BREED is trying to win back the reverse by the beginning of February 2022.
    And the great happiness of Russia is that Putin does not belong to this breed.
  7. +12
    11 July 2022 10: 29
    What kind of incoherent stream of consciousness of the British Greek have I just read?
    1. +2
      12 July 2022 08: 05
      El13 is absolutely right, the author decided to take a steam bath on Putin, it didn’t work out much, chatter or glasses.
  8. +4
    11 July 2022 11: 12
    As always. Western experts are full of guano. Each in their own reality. Sad.
  9. +3
    11 July 2022 11: 55
    Rave. One way or another, Russia would have to destroy fascism, no matter who rules here. But this is incomprehensible to the British. Fascism for them is one of the options for real Western democracy ...
  10. +3
    11 July 2022 13: 03
    With a hunchback, we knelt down, with an alcoholic-borka, we fell below the plinth, and now we can proudly raise our heads and not be ashamed that we are RUSSIAN.
    1. +4
      12 July 2022 19: 26
      Yes, but it was necessary to do this in 2014. There were no fortified areas of dill yet, they almost fled from Mariupol themselves (they believed that Russian troops were advancing). All I needed was some informal help.
      We are still being blamed for this.
  11. -9
    11 July 2022 13: 08
    They framed him with the pension reform, with medicine, they couldn’t come up with a vaccine for him so that he could appear in public and didn’t have to use a 5-meter table. They framed that the Kremlin reality is different from reality in Russia, life in Russia is worse than in Europe. Glad you weren't greeted warmly.
    1. +2
      11 July 2022 13: 15
      It is interesting to look at those yavropes where you visited ...
      1. -4
        11 July 2022 22: 20
        being a tourist and living is a big difference.
  12. 0
    11 July 2022 14: 52
    They want him to be like that, and if he doesn't, then it's not fair. What remains for Pertrikarkas - they hang themselves? He is also not made with a thread in any way and will be, what will be, but will pull to death.
  13. 0
    11 July 2022 16: 54
    Quote: goncharov.62
    Fix

    No matter how late these landings were!
  14. -4
    11 July 2022 16: 56
    Quote: Roust
    we can proudly raise our heads

    Lying below the plinth, raise your head, and even proudly?
  15. 0
    11 July 2022 17: 43
    A typical Briton is trying to cause confusion in the government of our country. There are so many traitors there, but I know they are there, and they are ready to overthrow the president and seize power. Lovers of undercover intrigues are in their repertoire.
    1. -4
      11 July 2022 23: 25
      And this little man in snowmobiles should have been sent to Magadan for a long time to bunk. You don't have to be British to do this...
  16. RFR
    +3
    11 July 2022 20: 35
    The loot drives ... That's the whole answer ... And we don't need songs about gullibility ...
  17. +1
    11 July 2022 21: 16
    Paradox! Almost all leading experts considered the Russian elite to be rotten and comprador, capable of selling the country for the sake of their personal interests. But we see the opposite. And it's not about Putin, but about the fundamental laws of human development. The development model implanted by the USA and the West contradicts the goals of human civilization, which were determined by Nature. Russia, headed by Putin, is only an instrument of Nature, which solves the problem of suppressing and removing the decaying parts of human civilization. The mechanisms of influence of Nature are the impact on the mass subconscious of people, which makes them take actions contrary to their selfish interests.
    1. +1
      11 July 2022 22: 23
      Usmanov, Miller, Sechin or Slutsky with a machine gun in defense of Russia, you can imagine this
    2. 0
      12 July 2022 08: 09
      Replace the word Nature with the word God and get a more precise wording.
  18. 0
    11 July 2022 22: 48
    one word subjects!?
  19. 0
    11 July 2022 23: 32
    ... he was literally "set up" by enemies from the environment, which just wants to get rid of the real leader of his country

    Who wants to get rid of the "real leader"? Usmanov? Brothers Rotenberg? Timchenko? Kabaeva? Or Volodin? Maybe Medvedev?
    As the Jews say, "don't make fun of my slippers"!
    Those who collect rubles for medicines for children want to get rid of him...
    1. -2
      12 July 2022 08: 06
      In an atmosphere of helpful lies and flattery, the right decisions are not "found" .... Yes .
  20. -4
    12 July 2022 16: 32
    again someone framed? no way...
    if he is so gullible and gullible and is being deceived and set up all the time, then what kind of head of state is he?! and does not he appoint "substitutes" to their posts?
    and if even during the NWO and the "war" already openly declared by the West, the "setups" of their own country and population continue, then it is generally enchanting.
    Meanwhile:

    FAS is going to give the pricing of raw materials into the hands of the oligarchs. “The draft roadmap for the development of exchange trading provides for the expansion of the number of commodity and raw materials, namely: forest products, aquatic biological resources, petrochemical products and others. Exchange trading has proven to be an effective market tool that provides a balance of supply and demand for goods on competitive terms, as well as an additional sales channel on digital platforms,” the FAS said.

    - and this is instead of limiting their (oligarchs') irrepressible "appetites" and instead of nationalizing industries vital for the country, which are in the hands of such "patriotic" Forbes lists?! Russian officials are afraid of the word "nationalization" like fire, quite rightly fearing that it could be the first step to the scaffold. Painfully a lot of bells and whistles, there are not enough prison sentences. By the way, in the same Europe, nationalization is a normal tool, an example is France and Germany and Denmark, etc. where it is a tool to protect the interests of the state and the population, and a way to solve economic problems and ensure security.
    Apparently, the FAS again substitutes, by itself? why, then, in general, the state and the head and the FAS, if everything is again "destroyed" by the "market" ?! the one that looks west with all its heads and assets?!
    By the way: In Article 6 of the Constitution of the USSR, it was stated that "the land and its subsoil are the property of the whole people." On the contrary, Article 9 of the Constitution of the Russian Federation, written under the dictation of American advisers, states that “Land and other natural resources are used and protected in the Russian Federation as the basis of the life and activities of the peoples living in the corresponding territory”, and that “land and other natural resources may be located in private, state, municipal and other forms of ownership”. Here is the answer.
    The totality of facts with the new privatization, the planned transfer of the pricing of raw materials to the hands of the oligarchs, the permission for the uncontrolled export of foreign currency, the massive (senseless!) Export of Russian raw materials abroad, including through Ukraine with payment for transit to Kyiv, and other similar initiatives indicate that Russia at the moment openly hostile forces are in control. In the same piggy bank of an ominous invoice, we will include gas supplies for the currency that accumulates in foreign accounts and is not spent on reindustrialization, but on earnest attempts to pay off the public debt, and other frankly anti-people acts.

    “The most reasonable thing in the light of the recent ultimatum of the oligarchs (and its punctual execution by the ruling bureaucracy) is to nationalize the basic sectors of the economy that provide the bulk of material costs in order to reduce the scale of prices nationwide. Primary industries and infrastructure should work for development, that is, ensure the maximum reduction in the price of their products. And their activities in the interests of society can only be directed by the owner acting in his interests, that is, not by an oligarch of some degree of savagery, but by a state transformed by a new task, ”says Mikhail Delyagin, State Duma deputy, doctor of economic sciences.

    while everything is the same as before..
    While the Russian army and the allied forces of the LPR and DPR are fighting the Nazis and Western mercenaries, someone is still setting up, and someone is setting up, and there is no end to this.
    and new weapons are supplied to the Bandera people along undestroyed roads and a piece of iron, Donbass and the liberated regions are subjected to increasingly harsh and massive shelling, the "decision centers" are notorious safe and sound, and officials and politicians are only "swaying the air":

    11.15 The United States and its allies are dangerously balancing on the verge of an open military confrontation with the Russian Federation, this would be fraught with nuclear escalation - Maria Zakharova.

    9.00 Russian State Duma deputy from the Crimean region Mikhail Sheremet on the shelling of Nova Kakhovka: “There must be a clear position of the UN. Ukraine began the targeted destruction of the civilian population of the liberated territories, shelling cities and towns with weapons specially supplied by the United States for this purpose. The United States actually sanctioned the killing of civilians. It is time for the UN to recognize Ukraine and the United States as aggressor countries in order to stop their plans to turn peaceful territories into scorched earth. The whole world must unite and impose international sanctions on those countries that supply Ukraine with lethal weapons.”

    What position? what UN?! Is it not something that is in the USA and has shown itself to be a miserable tool in the hands of American puppeteers?!

    The UN opposes the shelling of civilian infrastructure in Ukraine, said Farhan Haq, deputy spokesman for the secretary general of the world organization, answering a question about the UAF strike on Nova Kakhovka.

    and what did the residents of Novaya Kakhovka feel better about?
    By the way, this is the same Sheremet who has repeatedly threatened "strike on decision-making centers."

    15.40 State Duma Deputy Yevgeny Revenko on US wine:
    “The strike on Novaya Kakhovka in the Kherson region with numerous victims and injured is another bloody crime of the Kyiv regime. This time with the use of American HIMARS multiple rocket launchers. Responsibility for the barbaric shelling and death of civilians lies not only in Kyiv and Zelensky personally, but also in Washington, which organized the supply of these weapons to Ukrainian nationalists. It is important to understand that there is no justification for such crimes and cannot be. The guilty will be punished. Neo-Nazis will face trial. The special military operation continues."

    Words, words, words ... "guilty, neo-Nazis" .... Washington already shivered in fear of deputy Revenko and stood in a corner ... Our soldiers and officers are fighting a real enemy, and deputies and officials are shaking the air, not for that without answering and PR on the SVO and human suffering ... In the Donbass, the deputy corps in the trenches with weapons was not seen, and the volunteer battalion (at least) of the EdRa is also not observed.
    At various domestic political talk shows, the genre is now extremely popular - questions to the Universe. Where, they say, does Russia have such an economy? Who, they say, failed the import substitution program? Why is there no growth? How long will the outrages continue? And so on and so forth. But in fairness, it must be admitted that sometimes the answers also sound: THEY interfere with life!
    Moreover, not only foreign adversaries (everything is clear with them), not only five-column national traitors (it is now strictly with these), but also - who would have thought - "separate" "irresponsible" Russian officials, that is, bureaucrats. To paraphrase a well-known book quote: in the Russian Federation they were not that very bad, one could even say good, but every year it gets worse and worse.
    and with all their actions they "set up" the country, the people and even the president with impunity, ... and no one is to blame and no one is punished ... Yes, as they say, other simplicity is worse than theft.

    ps and classic:

    Ah, it's not difficult to deceive me, I myself am glad to be deceived ..
    1. -4
      12 July 2022 16: 38
      Vladimir Vladimirovich, who opposes the hydra of bureaucracy, will not let you lie:

      Putin, October 3, 2003 (Moscow meeting of the World Economic Forum): "The bureaucracy and sluggishness of officials hinder the increase in the efficiency of the state."

      Putin, April 22, 2005 (Message to the Federal Assembly): "Among the main enemies of Russian statehood is bureaucracy."

      Putin, July 6, 2007 (Inauguration ceremony of the mayor of Moscow): “We need to work, get rid of bureaucracy, which is still enough in the whole country and in Moscow. We must be guided by the concrete interest of the ordinary citizen.”

      Putin, June 9, 2011 (Government meeting): “The task of the Agency for Strategic Initiatives is to fight bureaucratic barriers in the interests of our citizens. To put it bluntly, there are many claims and complaints from citizens to the authorities.”

      Putin, December 20, 2013 (Presidential Council for Science and Education): "The bureaucracy is stifling not only science, but also many other sectors of our life, the economy."

      Putin, July 13, 2016 (Council for Strategic Development and Priority Projects): “It is necessary to build coordinated work not only between leaders, but also at the level of teams of ministries, departments, regions, get rid of bureaucracy that exhausts people, ensure rapid adoption and implementation of decisions” .

      Putin, August 5, 2017 (Meeting on the development of local self-government): “I have repeatedly said that it is categorically wrong to ignore the ideas and proposals of citizens, to engage in ‘bureaucratic football’.”

      Putin, May 7, 2018 (Inauguration): “We need breakthroughs in all spheres of life. I am deeply convinced that such a breakthrough can only be ensured by a free society that accepts everything new and everything advanced and rejects injustice, inertia, dense protection and bureaucratic dead things.

      Putin, September 17, 2019 (Meeting in the Far East): “People still face callousness and formalism, the worst and, unfortunately, very common features of our bureaucracy.”

      Putin, February 5, 2020 (Meeting with the government): “I expect, dear colleagues, from you a real breakthrough in debureaucratization in all areas. This is a guarantee of trust on the part of citizens ... "

      Putin, April 15, 2021 (Meeting of the Presidium of the State Council and the Agency for Strategic Initiatives): “It is necessary to resolutely remove senseless demands, unreasonable, endlessly bureaucratic procedures, absurd norms and rules that humiliate people.”

      Putin, June 9, 2022 (At a meeting with young entrepreneurs): “The answer to all Western sanctions on our part can and should be unconditional bureaucracy in decision-making.”

      Does the Russian population believe in success, achievement and overcoming? In general, there is no doubt, and where would they come from ?! The only thing that is still not entirely clear is where did so many, to put it mildly, inefficiently irresponsible managers come from, preventing the implementation of grandiose plans?
      1. -2
        12 July 2022 17: 15
        How from where? From "America" ​​and "EU" ... They were sent in sealed wagons. And in general: "the Englishwoman crap" - forgot something? Yes And then there is the "fifth column" - those who do not want to wipe their ass with a burdock and walk in bast shoes ... - enemies, sik.
        1. -3
          12 July 2022 18: 04
          well, for now, not only are energy resources being driven through Ukraine with payment for transit, it also turns out that Kyiv "did not cross the red lines" ?! and the shelling and death of civilians are green lines ?! how much you can goof off with the Bandera regime, and how many more civilians and our military must die so that the Nazi regime receives not 4-month promises of "strike at the centers", but harshly and to the fullest, everything that it deserves, according to the laws of wartime, but not a "threat with a white-gloved finger"?!:

          17.15 Zaporozhye region does not plan to disconnect Ukraine from the supply of electricity if Kyiv does not cross the red lines - the head of the pro-Russian administration of the region Balitsky.

          instead of tough actions and blows, advice and meetings with a predictable outcome:

          17.40 To convene an emergency meeting of the UN Security Council in connection with the shelling of Novaya Kakhovka by Ukrainian troops was proposed by the head of A Just Russia - For Truth, Sergei Mironov.

          the very council in which of the five permanent members - three members of NATO and enemies of Russia?! Those. any decision is subject to a veto. Then it’s better to write directly to Sportloto.
          right ... some transits pay for Banderstadt, thereby financing its crimes, other lines are looking for .... while people are dying.
      2. 0
        12 July 2022 21: 29
        oh, by the evening the minuses pulled themselves up) either from among the bureaucrats, or the oligarchs, or the fifth column) it's a shame for "their" nettle seed "?) nothing personal - just facts, all quotes are easily verified - search for help) and if with Nothing has changed in 2003, then of course, a minus will help)
    2. -2
      12 July 2022 19: 16
      and there, another "setup":

      18.00 The head of the Ministry of Industry and Trade of the Russian Federation Denis Manturov will simultaneously be Deputy Prime Minister, follows from the presidential decree. Probably, the increase in the status of the minister is explained by the importance of import substitution, for which the department is responsible, by the need for Russia to achieve technological sovereignty.

      the same Manturov who said at the PEMF that import substitution is not the development of one's own production and industry and the production of domestic goods, but the replacement of one foreign seller with another "?!
      By the way, he has been in this chair - the Minister of Industry and Trade of the Russian Federation since May 21, 2012, i.e. the entire failure of the "import substitution" program - including its direct "merit" and nothing and nothing and "rafik is not guilty" - another increase ....
      Again deceived and framed?
      1. -2
        12 July 2022 19: 40
        Russian President Vladimir Putin introduced a new position in the Russian government - by his decree, the head of state increased the number of deputy prime ministers from 10 to 11.

        Initially, when the Cabinet of Ministers was formed in January 2020, it had 9 vice-premiers. Six months later, the structure was changed when Alexander Novak, who previously headed the Ministry of Energy, became another deputy prime minister. Another very "effective manager", whose efforts and "achievements", as well as the growth of energy resources and, accordingly, everything else, were felt by all Russians.
        There are more and more officials, but less and less use ...
        in the meantime, apparently from enthusiasm and joy for such "import substitutes":

        The Russians bought on the stock exchange a record volume of euros and dollars in three years. Between April and June, Russians bought 400 billion rubles worth of currency on the stock exchange, which exceeds the figures of the previous three years. Rossiyskaya Gazeta

        somehow it doesn’t look like a rejection of the dollar, but in the light of the decisions of the Central Bank on the unhindered export and transfer of currency to the West, it’s generally wonderful ...
        Meanwhile:

        16.25 Dmitry Medvedev on the depreciation of the euro against the dollar:
        “The best protection against the rotting euro will be the transition to new payment methods in trade with our reliable partners, including the use of national currencies - the Russian ruble, Chinese yuan, Indian rupee, etc. In the future, it is also possible to create a new reserve currency of the BRICS countries. The modern world is clearly not enough for the dollar, the euro and the pound sterling.”

        our song is good - start over. Looking for logic from politicians and officials is like a black cat in a black room, especially if it is not there.
    3. 0
      13 July 2022 06: 16
      By the way: In Article 6 of the Constitution of the USSR, it was stated that "the land and its subsoil are the property of the whole people."

      In short, this is a lie.

      Article 6. The Communist Party of the Soviet Union is the guiding and guiding force of Soviet society, the core of its political system, state and public organizations. The CPSU exists for the people and serves the people.
  21. 0
    12 July 2022 17: 35
    Can anyone translate this abracadabra into Russian?
    1. 0
      13 July 2022 05: 33
      General meaning: Everything did not go according to our plan and not at all as we wanted. We are at a loss, do not understand what is happening and do not know what to do next, so that it does not get even worse.
  22. -1
    13 July 2022 05: 30
    And you didn’t have to believe the West. This is actually not even about Putin, he is trying to clean up the mess from his predecessors. And everyone interferes with him. Our Westerners must be driven out of the country, we are civilized barbarians. Although I would still apply the experience of Joseph Stalin. .
  23. 0
    15 July 2022 11: 36
    if he is so gullible and gullible and is being deceived and set up all the time, then what kind of head of state is he?!

    - but a terrible question... It is already clear that the planned blitzkrieg failed miserably. Who advised him? Who told him that our troops in Hohland would be greeted with flowers? First name, last name, patronymic - and personnel decisions! Where is it? Again, like half a year ago, on the first channel, stubborn Russophobes Michael Bom, Yanina Sokolovskaya and Sytin. Again spokes in the wheels, again golem propaganda and irresponsibility ....
  24. 0
    16 July 2022 01: 46
    Breshesh dog aglitskaya! Putin is never wrong! And those who wanted to frame him, those have long been gone. You are mistaken empty talk and that Putin single-handedly makes decisions. The president has a whole staff of analysts who are considering hundreds of options for decisions and, most importantly, their consequences. Putin only confirms with his signature the most optimal option, meaning not a momentary decision, but what will follow these decisions in years to come, and how this will affect the entire country as a whole and its population!