"It will be a large-scale military operation" - Naval Research Center analyst on the situation in Ukraine

29

The observed Russian military build-up around Ukraine, within a radius of 250 km, suggests that the Russian leadership has ordered its troops to prepare for a large-scale invasion of Ukrainian territory. This is stated in the report of Michael Kofman, a leading specialist on Russia from the US Naval Research Institute, which he made at a seminar at the Center for International Security and Cooperation at Stanford University.

It will be a large-scale military operation

- the analyst thinks.



Kofman outlined how the said operation would take place. He believes that it will involve: aviation, ships and marines, operational-tactical missile systems, cannon (including long-range) and rocket artillery. Thus, the entire territory of Ukraine may be affected.

I am very skeptical that the goal of the Russian military operation will be territorial gains. Although it cannot be ruled out that they may seriously consider the option of dividing Ukraine. This is the worst case scenario and it definitely exists.

- he specified.

In his opinion, there are several scenarios for the development of events: a limited strike and a large-scale operation. Limited strike - the use of artillery and aircraft with the threat of a large-scale ground invasion. But this tactic is uncharacteristic of the Armed Forces of the Russian Federation, therefore it is unlikely.

Large-scale operation - the destruction of the potential of the Armed Forces of Ukraine and forcing Kiev to capitulate on Moscow's terms. In such a scenario, the Russians will have to take control of the territory in order to ensure the security of the supply of their troops. The Ukrainian coast of the Black and Azov Seas, as well as all the lands on the left side of the Dnieper River, may be under the control of the RF Armed Forces. In addition, this territory is likely to have its own government, as it was already 100 years ago.

Other, much more limited options, I regard as very unlikely or deeply impractical, or because it is impossible to determine political the purpose they might serve, or because the cost of these more limited types of operations would actually be much higher

- he added.

The expert stressed that the military of different countries can look at the same things differently. Therefore, the Russians will proceed from their own calculation of the potential, balance of power, costs and risks associated with the operation.

At the same time, politicians who receive information from the military generally have their own special approach to what is happening. They think differently and make decisions based on their conclusions. So when analysts assume that politicians act solely on the basis of data provided by the military, they are almost always wrong.

Politicians may have their preferences (optimistic or pessimistic). This is what influences the final decision. Therefore, sometimes politicians come to the conclusion that the operation will not last long, and its cost will be low, even if the military has the opposite opinion, the expert concluded.
29 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. -12
    25 January 2022 13: 13
    He believes that it will involve: aviation, ships and marines, operational-tactical missile systems, cannon (including long-range) and rocket artillery. Thus, the entire territory of Ukraine can be hit.

    Large-scale operation - the destruction of the potential of the Armed Forces of Ukraine and forcing Kiev to capitulate on Moscow's terms.

    - Yes, who will allow this and allow Moscow ???????????????
    - How long can you write about it?

    Limited strike - the use of artillery and aircraft

    - Very limited pinpoint air strikes, the use of small units of armored vehicles (tanks, infantry fighting vehicles, etc.) ...
    - This is still possible...
    - And the infliction by Moscow of complex massive strikes across the entire territory of Ukraine and so on ... so on ... so on ... - all this will be instantly regarded by the West, the United States, and the entire world community - as ... as ... as use "excessive means of force", "excessive force" ... - and will be directed against Russia ...
    - And, by the way, how many times has Russia used "complex massive strikes" in Syria against ISIS in all seven years? - No one !!! - Why didn’t you burn them out with such "complex massive strikes" in the very first period of the war ??? I just didn't dare...
    - Here again, everything will come down to a semblance of a war in Syria or Yugoslavia ... - This is how Russia will confront Ukraine "almost on equal terms" - tanks on both sides, artillery and very limited use of aviation ...
    - So there will be such "military events":
    - "They took the object, held the object ... - Temporary truce; then the violation of the truce - again the resumption of skirmishes; then the" mediators "; then - again fierce hostilities; again a truce and an agreement on a ceasefire ... and so on and so forth .. - Then there will be "new Minsk agreements"; already between Moscow and Kiev ... "...
    - Yes, by the way - Belarus in this war - will not support Russia !!! - Belarus will observe "neutrality" and sympathize with Ukraine... - Like this... - And not otherwise!!!
    - So Russia will have no allies at all !!!
    1. +1
      25 January 2022 13: 48
      - Here again, everything will come down to the semblance of a war in Syria

      Something like this might happen. Russian Aerospace Forces in the air. The LDNR corps and volunteers from civilians and from the Armed Forces of Ukraine who joined them are on the ground. All as bequeathed by the West. Russian soldiers will not enter the land of Ukraine. And then everything can go, as in France after the fall of the regime of Marshal Pétain.
    2. +1
      25 January 2022 15: 34
      Fortune telling on the coffee grounds of American pseudo-analysts,
      such as Kofman. )
    3. -1
      26 January 2022 19: 30
      It's funny :-))) What does "allow" mean?! Who will ask? The only question is what to do with it then? Well, it's true! Of course, today there is no problem to "separate the lambs from the goats", the Ukrainians themselves will inform on all the neighbors ... And there are many truly Russian people there, and what a problem it is now to collect all the activities on the network and draw the right conclusions. Question - what then, for example, to do with you? Recycle? It seems not humane ... 21st century after all! Yes, and we are not arrogant Saxons, reasonable and kind people. And considering that a lot of young people will be with their heads polluted by "Ukrainianism", which will have to be taken out - you have to think!
      Of course, settlements are reasonable, for example, in the Far North, where they can build huts for themselves, and control can be ensured ... but you can start with barracks, townhouses, so to speak :-):-):-)

      But it's not now! For sure! After all, even Moses led the Jews for 50 years in the desert, so that the promised land would not disappoint! It, after the desert, is good everywhere! While ahead, you need to learn how to live economically, environmentally friendly, get used to gas on holidays, live without cars and other excesses, learn to love and respect horse-drawn vehicles! There are many more events ahead! Do not rush the Russian army! Time will still go ... But later :-)))
    4. -1
      26 January 2022 20: 13
      - Yes, who will allow this and allow Moscow ???????????????

      8.08.08. was a shock to many.
      The Crimean events are a revelation, with poorly concealed bewilderment.
      Support for the Donbass with the realization that they are hacked on occasion for the very thing ..
      The events in Kazakhstan with the rapid transfer of who is needed and where it is needed did not particularly surprise anyone.

      However, there are especially "gifted" individuals who still ask such questions ..
    5. +1
      26 January 2022 21: 29
      Calm down, calmer .. "Analyteg" wrote nonsense, and here you scattered exclamation marks with fear.
  2. +5
    25 January 2022 13: 24
    Quote: gorenina91
    - Yes, who will allow this and allow Moscow ???????????????

    Check your mail. Putin wrote to you personally there. Asks you for permission.
    You are more gentle with him. After all, he might do something wrong out of excitement.
    1. -6
      25 January 2022 13: 42
      Check your mail.

      - So I personally state the "will" of our guarantor !!!
      - He sets the task - clearly and clearly: "Keep calm, but be prepared for anything ... - complications are possible ... - Do not listen to all kinds of fools - they are also sometimes useful in spreading disinformation against our enemy ... - let they grind whatever they want - this is all at the level of elementary school students and will not hurt anyone ... - Let our enemy think that we have a lot of "such" (and there are really - really a lot of "such" - even on the site) ... - and this will break his vigilance ... "
      - This is only a fragment - I will not publish more secret things ...
      - So - thanks to you - at least some sense ... - you can be proud ...
      - Hahah ...
  3. +1
    25 January 2022 13: 30
    Quote: gorenina91
    Yes, by the way - Belarus in this war - will not support Russia !!! - Belarus will observe "neutrality" and sympathize with Ukraine... - Like this... - And not otherwise!!!

    Yes Yes. Lukashenka told me so. "Sorry, I can't support Russia. I have obligations to Gorenina."
  4. -5
    25 January 2022 14: 22
    Quote: Expert_Analyst_Forecaster
    Check your mail. Putin wrote to you personally there. Asks you for permission.
    You are more gentle with him. After all, he might do something wrong out of excitement.

    Your sessions of "virtual rectal polishing" for Ultimatutin are already going through the roof in the ultimate degree of sycophancy.
    Do they even pay you decently?
    1. 0
      25 January 2022 14: 33
      Kesha with a claim to originality. Crawls on the Internet and soils the pages.
      1. -2
        25 January 2022 14: 34
        And in fact something to answer in any way?
        At least I see the situation as it is, and do not worship the "idol".
        1. 0
          25 January 2022 15: 38
          And what to answer then? You're drunk?

          At least I see the situation as it is, and do not worship the "idol"

          Where in your comment is there any consideration of the situation?

          Your sessions of "virtual rectal polishing" for Ultimatutin are already going through the roof in the ultimate degree of sycophancy.
          Do they even pay you decently?
  5. -6
    25 January 2022 14: 24
    Quote: gorenina91
    - Yes, who will allow this and allow Moscow ???????????????
    - How long can you write about it?

    The point here is that the West may allow this, fearing Ultimatutin's vigorous loaf.
    But then there will be sanctions.
    To make it clear to everyone, "for what exactly these sanctions."
    1. +1
      25 January 2022 14: 43
      Kesha, like you, there is only one available joy - sanctions for neighbors.
      It's good that soon people like you will be a thing of the past. More like going to hell.
      And there, people like you will not have an Internet. And there, people like you, between cries of pain, will tell each other how bad it is for us from the sanctions.
    2. -1
      26 January 2022 20: 36
      But then there will be sanctions.

      Terrible.
      The most terrible.
      There is nowhere worse.
      Ecumenical.
      Megagalactic.

      Who are you going to scare?
      Those who have been under "sanctions" since the times of Peter the Great?
      1. +1
        27 January 2022 01: 14
        From Peter's .... At least from Ivan the Terrible, and if you count everything, then from the princes.
  6. -7
    25 January 2022 14: 28
    Ultimatutin, who had never sparkled with either intellect or knowledge in anything, turned into a complete inadequate by his almost 70 years.
    And most importantly, he does not take into account the centuries-old experience of the history of the Russian Federation, when it was precisely from such tickling and hatred that Tsushima, the Crimean Wars, the Wars with Finland, etc., arose.
    1. -6
      25 January 2022 16: 28
      And most importantly, he does not take into account the centuries-old experience of the history of the Russian Federation, when it was precisely from such tickling and hatred that Tsushima, the Crimean Wars, the Wars with Finland, etc.

      - Yes it is...
      - It simply amazes "public opinion" (opinion of the plebs) ...
      - Here, give them Bread (or rather - popcorn) and spectacles (even - any war game where their loved ones can die) - and they simply don’t care about the rest !!!
      - Well, while the audience rejoices and ... both in anticipation and anticipation ...
      My plus to you, Mr. Bystander (Innokenty) ...
  7. 0
    25 January 2022 14: 29
    These Western analysts do not want to see the obvious:
    Ukraine is Maidan.
    Maidan is Ukraine.
    Until the Maidan starts chanting: Putin! Bring in the troops! - There will be no Russian "invasion"!
  8. -8
    25 January 2022 14: 35
    Quote: Mikhail L.
    Until the Maidan starts chanting: Putin! Bring in the troops! - There will be no Russian "invasion"!

    And it is precisely the Maidan that asks to drive troops from all over Russia to the side and on the border of Ukraine?
    1. 0
      25 January 2022 15: 32
      Without "smart" questions - it doesn't work? ;-(
    2. +1
      25 January 2022 23: 20
      And where else to conduct exercises, in Siberia or something, if the situation is destabilized by NATO in the West and South?
  9. +2
    25 January 2022 16: 42
    Quote from Bystander
    Quote: Mikhail L.
    Until the Maidan starts chanting: Putin! Bring in the troops! - There will be no Russian "invasion"!

    And it is precisely the Maidan that asks to drive troops from all over Russia to the side and on the border of Ukraine?

    Certainly! You are jumping like on a trampoline, everything is sliding towards you - either the special forces of the Britons, then the US, then the division of Buryat horse divers ...
    Stop jumping, sho you are not Muscovites, otherwise you will turn the planet! And everyone will be happy! You give us fat - we give you dumplings.
    And let the mattresses eat hamburgers. Or rice with a fork. By the way, from the rice media - if anything, there will be a new dish for world culinary - dumplings with rice!
  10. 0
    25 January 2022 17: 52
    everyone relax! There will be nothing! If Ukraine does not take it into its head to try its strength in the Donbass. But they won’t try, because after all, the Armed Forces of Ukraine are commanded not by the “Bandera lads”, but by the military! Military realists, not science fiction .. Russia alone can fight the whole world, especially if it is pressed against the wall! And everyone understands this! Therefore, the degree of response in Ukraine, in the event of a Ukrainian attack on the Donbass, depends only on the desire, determination of Russia itself .. No concept of "disproportionate strength"! They will use as much force as they want and no one will do anything to us, well, except for "sanctions .." Sev. Korea lives with sanctions..?! Lives "Especially We! And NATO missiles are a prospect that does not depend on the Donbass! .. They will be there in any case and in any case there will be an answer, but not in Ukraine ..
    1. -1
      26 January 2022 21: 04
      they won’t try, because after all, the Armed Forces of Ukraine are commanded not by the “Bandera lads”, but by the military! Military realists, not science fiction ..

      Izvarinsky boiler.
      Ilovaisky cauldron
      Debaltsevsky boiler

      Only the three most famous.
      Where were the Ukrainian military realists?

      Now the Ukrainian military is taught by those who recently scrambled in disgrace from the Kabul airport.
      Light, throwing heavy weapons.
      They did find a use for the released "instructors" .. smile

      PS All Ukrainian "military thought" could only master the "frog jump" ...
  11. 0
    26 January 2022 19: 36
    Let's wait and see what will happen, as they say, we assume and the president disposes.
  12. 0
    27 January 2022 01: 14
    No one is going to attack the ruin. Except for the case of the Ukronazi attacks on the Donbass and preparations for joining NATO. As ukram advised in NATO. Under the guise of the Olympics, defeat the Donbass and immediately apply to NATO due to the fact that there are no more territorial conflicts. NATO immediately accepts this application and NATO troops quickly occupy Little Russia. But the Germans leaked the information to us and we pulled up the troops to the border, showing that if the Ukrainians decide on this, we will crush like nits forever. Despite NATO and sanctions. And he twitched - and it’s scary not to listen to the boss, they will immediately replace him with a slop bucket and it’s scary to attack the Donbass. What if the Russians still protect the Donbass and where will they stop then? And how the Americans throw their prostitutes was seen in Afghanistan. Here is the hysteria.
  13. 0
    27 January 2022 19: 00
    kofman, provided that the outskirts twitch or climb into the Donbass