The expert explained why the Americans will not be able to unravel the secrets of the Russian S-400


Turkey continues testing Russian S-400 systems, and in this regard, the question of access to these systems for American specialists arises. Earlier, the US military department officially offered Ankara to outbid Russian air defense systems, but the Turks, according to the contracts concluded with Moscow, cannot do this through official channels.


However, even if these agreements are violated, the Americans will not be able to unravel the secrets of the Russian S-400. About it "Tsargrad" said military expert Viktor Baranets.

According to Barantz, there is an international rule prohibiting the transfer of access to this type of weapons to third countries. But even if this agreement is perfidiously violated, our American "partners" will still be unable to learn anything about the Russian air defense system.

The fact is that the designers "sewed" into the S-400 the impossibility of using it against Russian aircraft. The second reason is Russia's export of this missile system with only reduced combat capabilities. And the main factor of inaccessibility is the loss of functionality of the circuits and system boards when trying to open them. That is, as soon as American specialists try to study the electronic filling of the S-400, it will immediately fail.
18 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must to register.
I have an account? Sign in
  1. Natan bruk Offline Natan bruk
    Natan bruk (Natan Bruk) 19 October 2020 16: 37
    -2
    Does this Baranets have any idea about the design of these systems, or is it his guess?
  2. Mrozov Yuri Offline Mrozov Yuri
    Mrozov Yuri (Yuri Mrozov) 19 October 2020 17: 08
    -1
    Baranets has never been a military man. All my life I wiped my pants in GlavPure. His grades are of no value. Secondly, about the "sewn" something there. In 2008, rodents with their Buk M1s knocked out 8 of our aircraft. So nothing is "sewn in" there.
    1. Oleg Osadchiy Offline Oleg Osadchiy
      Oleg Osadchiy (Oleg Osadchiy) 19 October 2020 21: 09
      +8
      You are even further from this topic than Baranets. "Buk" M1 did not sell ukram, they inherited it from the USSR and all the technical documentation too. In order to shoot at Russian planes, it was enough to replace the "belonging determination units" with "friend or foe". In the avionics of these complexes, export firmware was not introduced, which protect against changes that allow the use of complexes against the aircraft of the manufacturer's country.
      1. Morgan Offline Morgan
        Morgan (Miron) 19 October 2020 23: 58
        -3
        export firmwares that protect

        - you are either a dreamer or too naive person. It is foolish to think that fools are sitting on the sides. And the second, main question, why do they need it? Moreover, there is a limited number of them, they have their own systems and are no worse with full support.
        1. 123 Offline 123
          123 (123) 20 October 2020 14: 14
          0
          Moreover, their number is limited, they have their own systems and no worse fully secured.

          Really? belay And what? smile
          1. The comment was deleted.
          2. Morgan Offline Morgan
            Morgan (Miron) 21 October 2020 21: 23
            -1
            3PK MIM-14 "Nike-Hercules", SAM "Nike-Hercules", SAM "Improved Hawk", SAM "Rapira", SAM "Zypkyn" From the latest news, Turkey turned to the United States with a request to provide it with Patriot anti-aircraft missile systems and believe they will receive them.
            1. 123 Offline 123
              123 (123) 21 October 2020 22: 34
              +2
              3PK MIM-14 Nike-Hercules

              Introduced into service in the United States in 1958. The last complex was removed from service in 1974.

              "Improved Hawk"

              90s of the last century

              SAM "Rapira"

              Development of the 60s of the last century, range 6,5 km.

              SAM "Zypkyn"

              These are Stingers paired with a heavy machine gun.

              HİSAR

              This is the best they have. Range 25 km.
              https://invoen.ru/vvs/mobilnie-zrk-hisar-pvo-turzii-kitaj-ozenka/

              little, or continue?

              This is really not enough. The Turks have no air defense. If not difficult, you can continue yes But I'm afraid this is the end of the list. Unless ... rotten tomatoes laughing

              From the latest news, Turkey turned to the United States with a request to provide it with Patriot anti-aircraft missile systems and believe they will receive them.

              This latest news from a dozen years. Erdogan has been begging for air defense for many years, but the United States and Europe have sold him absolutely nothing. For them, the Turks are second-class allies. Why should I believe that things will be different now? What changed?
    2. shinobi Offline shinobi
      shinobi (Yuri) 20 October 2020 08: 07
      -2
      It is sewn in, but not as Baranets thinks. There are a lot of questions about 2008, but our planes were shot down from Soviet beeches, where these tabs simply do not exist.
  3. GRF Offline GRF
    GRF 19 October 2020 17: 31
    -1
    The fact is that the designers "sewn" into the S-400 the impossibility of using it against Russian aircraft.

    An interesting thought, it means there is a chance to retrofit American aircraft with a similar anti-c400 device.
    In the Korean War, after a radar from an American fighter fell into the hands of the Russians, the world's first radar detector was created, which saved the lives of many pilots, so this is only a secret to the whole world ...

    - Here, Senechka, for the fact that you offend Varenka and Vovochka, I bought them presents, and you a rod ...
    - And great, mamotska, so I will use this slogan!
    1. Oleg Osadchiy Offline Oleg Osadchiy
      Oleg Osadchiy (Oleg Osadchiy) 19 October 2020 21: 15
      +2
      Lord, what are you talking about, did you even go to school? What does the radiation detector and the "friend or foe" identification system have to do with it, all the more so 70 years later.
      1. GRF Offline GRF
        GRF 20 October 2020 15: 17
        -1
        no, I drank beer, but it's good that you were there, who has something to carry ...
        your "thought" does not refute mine, does not supplement, is empty and rude, so go on learning.
  4. Sergey Sfiedu Offline Sergey Sfiedu
    Sergey Sfiedu (Sergey Sfyedu) 19 October 2020 17: 37
    +1
    Well, if "Constantinople" said, then how are we mortals, can we doubt?
    1. Oleg Osadchiy Offline Oleg Osadchiy
      Oleg Osadchiy (Oleg Osadchiy) 19 October 2020 21: 19
      +3
      People like you are immortal in your ignorance and cannot doubt only your opinions about everything in the world.
  5. Morgan Offline Morgan
    Morgan (Miron) 19 October 2020 23: 47
    -3
    The author has read a lot of science fiction.
  6. Barmaley_2 Offline Barmaley_2
    Barmaley_2 (Barmaley) 20 October 2020 02: 12
    -3
    it's so funny to read. Well, you are stupid! Buy from the Turks so that it breaks right there. Only you are capable of such stupidity.
  7. Dmitry S. Offline Dmitry S.
    Dmitry S. (Dmitry Sanin) 20 October 2020 06: 06
    +2
    Some strange experts constantly crawl out from everywhere - where is their nest?
    Does the sleep of reason give birth to experts?
  8. Sergey Latyshev Offline Sergey Latyshev
    Sergey Latyshev (Serge) 20 October 2020 08: 56
    -1
    As Lavrov said, ".... ....".
    They can, they cannot, science does not know this. And what the characteristics, reaction and tests will remove is how to give it to drink.
    So for anyone in the span. Unless there are other reasons, they say, to help extinguish the Maidan ...

    Now the ruble
  9. Michael I Offline Michael I
    Michael I (Michael I) 21 October 2020 08: 31
    -1
    Who is interested in the filling of these systems? All value is in the detection system and the irradiation and tracking channels. It is these parameters that the Americans can remove from the Turkish S-400 in order to learn how to bypass them. It was the same with the S-300. Nobody took them apart, just the Israelis trained in Cyprus, bypassing them. Judging by Syria, they learned