The European Union has declared the amendments to the Russian Constitution illegal


On Thursday, September 17, the European Parliament adopted a resolution on the situation in Belarus and around the poisoning of Russian opposition leader Alexei Navalny. At the same time, the document also said about the illegality of the constitutional reform in Russia - especially the adoption of amendments to "zero" the presidential term and the priority of Russian legislation over international.


The Russian Federation, as a member of the Council of Europe and the OSCE, must fulfill its obligations to respect human rights and fundamental freedoms and ensure the rule of law in accordance with the European Convention on Human Rights and the International Convention on Civil and Political Freedoms

- noted in the resolution.

In July of this year, the Venice Commission of the EU considered the reform of the Basic Law of the Russian Federation and came to the conclusion that Russia had violated the provisions of the European Convention on Human Rights. Experts criticized the Kremlin's attitude to the ECHR and recommended that Moscow revise the rules on Russia's right not to comply with decisions of international instances that are in conflict with Russian legislation. The resolution of the European Parliament states that the Russian Federation is obliged to comply with the provisions of the ECHR, since it joined the Council of Europe and ratified the Convention on Human Rights - its 46th article says that Russia must comply with court decisions.

The US Senate also did not stand aside from the discussion of internal Russian reforms.

On the last day of voting on the constitutional referendum, there was no doubt about its outcome - this fake procedure, disguised as a plebiscite, destroyed the remnants of Putin's legitimacy and democracy in the Russian Federation

- outraged the head of the Senate Foreign Relations Committee, member of the Republican Party from Idaho, Jim Risch.
  • Photos used: https://wilderness-society.org/
56 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must to register.
I have an account? Sign in
  1. King3214 Offline King3214
    King3214 (Sergius) 18 September 2020 11: 27
    +9
    After such statements, it is necessary to break off relations with these Jews.
    1. rotkiv04 Offline rotkiv04
      rotkiv04 (Victor) 18 September 2020 12: 20
      -4
      What are you talking about? Mikheev was right when he said that non-traditional wagging backwards in foreign policy is the know-how of the Russian Federation
      1. alexneg13 Offline alexneg13
        alexneg13 (Alexander) 19 September 2020 14: 48
        +1
        Know-how is influencing you backwards to the west. The Yeltsinoids and Vlasovites are always happy to lick the ass of the USA and try to do as much harm to Russia as possible. Cheap!
  2. rotkiv04 Offline rotkiv04
    rotkiv04 (Victor) 18 September 2020 11: 29
    +4
    We are waiting for concerns from the heroic Ministry of Foreign Affairs, and maybe deep concerns
    1. Rashid116 Offline Rashid116
      Rashid116 (Rashid) 19 September 2020 13: 20
      -4
      And Zakharova will also dance "Kalinka" for them ... in short, save yourself, Europeans)))
  3. Bulanov Online Bulanov
    Bulanov (Vladimir) 18 September 2020 11: 53
    +6
    on the priority of Russian legislation over international.

    And educate, who can: - In the United States, international law has priority over American?
    If not, why are these proposals being made? Russia takes an example from US legislation.
    1. molotkov60mkpu Offline molotkov60mkpu
      molotkov60mkpu (Yuri) 18 September 2020 13: 20
      +1
      USA-supra-international education
      1. alexneg13 Offline alexneg13
        alexneg13 (Alexander) 19 September 2020 14: 49
        +3
        USA - an arrogant formation of criminal rabble from all over the world.
    2. Oleg Rambover Offline Oleg Rambover
      Oleg Rambover (Oleg Rambover) 18 September 2020 14: 32
      -4
      The United States did not undertake an obligation to comply with the decision of international organizations, the Russian Federation, upon joining the Council of Europe, undertook to comply with the decisions of the ECHR
      1. Bulanov Online Bulanov
        Bulanov (Vladimir) 18 September 2020 14: 59
        +5
        And NATO undertook a commitment not to expand to the East! Now what?
        1. Oleg Rambover Offline Oleg Rambover
          Oleg Rambover (Oleg Rambover) 18 September 2020 15: 18
          +2
          This question is dark and has not been legally formalized. In contrast to the entry of the Russian Federation into the Council of Europe.
          1. 123 Offline 123
            123 (123) 18 September 2020 15: 27
            +3
            This question is dark and has not been legally formalized. In contrast to the entry of the Russian Federation into the Council of Europe.

            You yourself are dark. What kind of legal arrangement do you need?
            1. Oleg Rambover Offline Oleg Rambover
              Oleg Rambover (Oleg Rambover) 18 September 2020 15: 41
              +1
              O Lord, you are forgiven for not knowing such trifles, an honest merchant's word is enough for you. But usually the treaty is written on paper, the representatives of both sides sign it, then the parliaments of both sides ratify it (NATO also has some kind of advisory body) and only then does it come into force.
              1. 123 Offline 123
                123 (123) 18 September 2020 16: 53
                +2
                O Lord, you are forgiven for not knowing such trifles, an honest merchant's word is enough for you.

                It is possible without titles, for a simple yes don't bother.

                But usually the treaty is written on paper, the representatives of both sides sign it, then the parliaments of both sides ratify it (NATO also has some kind of advisory body) and only then does it come into force.

                Maybe an enlightened and sophisticated interlocutor will condescend to explain what kind of treaty we are talking about, with which country it was signed and which parliaments have ratified it? And also, with what fright did you drag NATO here? Why not Unesco?
                1. Oleg Rambover Offline Oleg Rambover
                  Oleg Rambover (Oleg Rambover) 18 September 2020 22: 49
                  +1
                  Oh, His Serene Highness, you are inattentive, dear Bulanov, in our discussion with him about the priority of international law, he made an argument that NATO has undertaken not to expand to the East, but has violated this word, and like the Russian Federation may also violate its obligations. I objected to this that no binding (and even non-binding) treaties, agreements, etc. should not be expanded. was not concluded. In contrast to the entry of the Russian Federation into the Council of Europe. And then you appeared.
                  1. 123 Offline 123
                    123 (123) 18 September 2020 23: 14
                    -2
                    Oh, His Serene Highness, you are inattentive, dear Bulanov, in our discussion with him about the priority of international law, he made an argument that NATO has undertaken not to expand to the East, but has violated this word, and like the Russian Federation may also violate its obligations. I objected to this that no binding (and even non-binding) treaties, agreements, etc. should not be expanded. was not concluded. In contrast to the entry of the Russian Federation into the Council of Europe. And then you appeared.

                    As I said, you can do it at home, without titles. Thank you for clarifying, though not completely hi With which country has Russia signed an agreement? Why are you there for the Council of Europe worried?
                  2. Ivan Ivanov_20 Offline Ivan Ivanov_20
                    Ivan Ivanov_20 (Ivan Ivanov) 21 September 2020 20: 59
                    0
                    The problem is ... As we entered, we will leave. :)))
                    Self-interest is in this office ...
          2. Vladimir Tuzakov (Vladimir Tuzakov) 18 September 2020 16: 44
            +1
            International treaties are created on the basis of the Constitution of the state, and the Constitution of the state is primary, the rest is secondary ... Some international treaties contain clauses that are higher than the Constitution of the state, so these clauses need to be withdrawn even unilaterally ... A simple legal formality will not be foundations of objections to amendments to the Constitution of the Russian Federation ...
      2. 123 Offline 123
        123 (123) 18 September 2020 15: 26
        +7
        Instead, the United States undertook to destroy chemical weapons.
        And he also signed many agreements like the INF Treaty. This is a normal practice, they signed it, they changed their minds. What is the essence of the claims?
        And it is high time to leave the ECHR, there is nothing to do in this pigsty.
      3. akarfoxhound Offline akarfoxhound
        akarfoxhound 19 September 2020 14: 30
        +3
        As they took it, they will give it back, an example - the Americans ..., where and what is not profitable, breaks contracts and relations without looking back, on pretexts sucked out of the finger. And nothing...
        And then tolerasts will survive.
        1. Oleg Rambover Offline Oleg Rambover
          Oleg Rambover (Oleg Rambover) 19 September 2020 17: 32
          -1
          I completely agree, I don’t like to execute the decisions of the ECHR, leave the Council of Europe and all the cases, otherwise all sorts of tolerants want to eat a fish and stay in the Council of Europe.
      4. alexneg13 Offline alexneg13
        alexneg13 (Alexander) 19 September 2020 14: 50
        0
        No ... Russia does not obey the decisions of the ECHR.
        1. Oleg Rambover Offline Oleg Rambover
          Oleg Rambover (Oleg Rambover) 19 September 2020 17: 18
          -2
          Why do you think so?

          https://www.kommersant.ru/doc/4451183
    3. 123 Offline 123
      123 (123) 18 September 2020 15: 23
      +4
      The right approach. It's time for the United States to change legislation. And it is time for Russia to withdraw the recognition of the states, the separatists must return to the bosom of the small British royal family, Alaska, respectively, to their home harbor.
    4. King3214 Offline King3214
      King3214 (Sergius) 18 September 2020 16: 48
      +5
      Russia is a sovereign country. Russia does not need to take an example from anyone. As Russia decides, so be it. And the opinion of others does not interest Russia.
  4. zz811 Offline zz811
    zz811 (Vlad Pervovich) 18 September 2020 11: 59
    0
    maybe it was easier to immediately apply to interpol for the detention of GDP?)
    1. Cudgel Offline Cudgel
      Cudgel (Dubina) 18 September 2020 17: 49
      -6
      It is good to...
      1. akarfoxhound Offline akarfoxhound
        akarfoxhound 19 September 2020 14: 31
        +4
        Cudgel is richer ??? laughing
  5. BMP-2 Offline BMP-2
    BMP-2 (Vladimir V.) 18 September 2020 14: 14
    +2
    I propose to return to the Stalinist Constitution, as the only legal one on the territory of Russia and a number of neighboring states! :))
  6. _AMUHb_ Offline _AMUHb_
    _AMUHb_ (_AMUHb_) 18 September 2020 15: 21
    -1
    it seems to me these bad people want to offend us ...
  7. Siberian southerner (Sergey A) 18 September 2020 18: 22
    +2
    Wow! They ate shit there? What is the European Union in general?
  8. Siberian southerner (Sergey A) 18 September 2020 18: 28
    +1
    Even the people smells like a great nix. It's just arrogance to call it, to put it mildly ... They just went crazy with their exclusivity.
  9. Siberian southerner (Sergey A) 18 September 2020 18: 30
    +1
    A bunch of Eurogeans got together and decided! Well, finally! We are waiting for the statement of the Russian Foreign Ministry
    1. alexneg13 Offline alexneg13
      alexneg13 (Alexander) 19 September 2020 14: 54
      0
      Why statements from the Foreign Ministry? Who is the Eurogeans? After their shameful sanctions against the Russian Federation, they are no longer for Russia.
    2. Ivan Ivanov_20 Offline Ivan Ivanov_20
      Ivan Ivanov_20 (Ivan Ivanov) 21 September 2020 21: 03
      0
      We are waiting for the statement of the Russian Foreign Ministry - what for? What, now it is customary to move on all fours with each dog?
  10. Mikhailov Offline Mikhailov
    Mikhailov (Mikhail Ivanov) 18 September 2020 19: 19
    +2
    How they want to keep us on a leash ...
    1. Ivan Ivanov_20 Offline Ivan Ivanov_20
      Ivan Ivanov_20 (Ivan Ivanov) 21 September 2020 21: 04
      0
      You want it, you want it, you want it .. :)))
  11. Cudgel Offline Cudgel
    Cudgel (Dubina) 18 September 2020 19: 19
    -8
    You can break off relations with Europe and even with the whole World and sit quietly in your cesspool and not trade with anyone. And it is also possible not to sell oil and gas to Europe, but they will quickly find alternative suppliers, but our "hotheads" did not think of where to get the currency from.
    Europe will stand still for a hundred years without us, and in a year we will bend another if we don’t sell to Europe and remain without spare parts.
    According to the ECHR, when the cop will plant drugs on you, and the judge podmahnet the verdict, because we have 0.3% acquittals, then you will not only run to the ECHR, but ride along!
    And the priority of the International Treaty has been introduced into the practice of any state, so that there is no such thing that the Basmanny Court or the Uryupinsk Court decides on international treaties. You try to conclude an international agreement for the supply of goods and indicate in it that the agreement is valid on the basis of the laws of the Russian Federation and disputes are resolved in the Arbitration Court of the city of Zadrishchensk.
    But a patriot does not understand this, they think that the center of the universe is Russia, which is a beacon for the rest of the world. And all countries should jump around what the State Duma can do in the RF Constitution.
    1. Eduard Aplombov Offline Eduard Aplombov
      Eduard Aplombov (Eduard Aplombov) 18 September 2020 21: 52
      0
      a saucepan, there is also for people like you uhomatsy, here then why sprinkle snot and saliva, recite your Sorovsky-sodomito delirium and slop in front of the public in a pile, that is, the local regulars and apparently your fellow tribesmen
      1. Cudgel Offline Cudgel
        Cudgel (Dubina) 19 September 2020 00: 33
        -6
        So, so, the marginal - the patriots came to the service. What a tall style! This is the Internet guard, the most nullified?
        So are we going to break the agreements with Europe and cut off the gas and oil valve? I propose to turn off all their valves on Monday! Do you agree with that?
        What else can you do to harm the damned Europeans? Not to buy machines and equipment from them, we have nowhere to put ours. Yes, you are not silent, write what you think it is necessary to do to dirty Europe so that they surrender. I look forward to your suggestions, comrade!
        1. shinobi Offline shinobi
          shinobi (Yuri) 19 September 2020 05: 54
          +5
          Europe is not our friend, it never was and will never be. We must proceed from this axiom. All the wars that Russia waged came from Europe, with the exception of the Tatar-Mongol invasion. But it was rather useful for the Kiev and Moscow principalities. An army from this freemen. has put together a single state in its own image and likeness. It was easier to collect tribute, less fuss. You need to listen to Europe, but no more. And all their Wishlist, at a known address. Let them continue to want.
          1. Cudgel Offline Cudgel
            Cudgel (Dubina) 19 September 2020 15: 14
            -4
            All countries have been at war with each other for centuries. So let's continue to fight on this basis. Another propaganda, the economically bankrupt government, it is necessary to divert the attention of the population from the deteriorating economic situation to external enemies, so it has been chosen, NATO is about to attack us, Europe has always offended us, so correct and strong-hearted. How many times England and France, France and Germany fought with each other, but more than with us. But no, we need to fan the "war frenzy", Europe has always fought with us! And during this time the dollar and the euro are slowly creeping upward, contributing to the further impoverishment of the population. But it (the population) counts how many times the vile Europeans attacked us.
            During the reign, the most effective of all the past and future rulers of Russia, we finally and irrevocably sat down on two pipes, gas and oil. And both of these pipes are laid to Europe, if we block them we will die in a year. And Europe will not even notice, LNG will not let it notice that the Russian Federation has stopped supplying oil and gas.
            Except for the Serbs. We have no allies in Europe, Thanks to our diplomats. How can we punish Europe with mass suicide?
            Well, the sawdust in the minds of the putriots does not allow them to understand that we are 90% dependent on Europe, and they do not depend on us in any way.
        2. Jozhik_2 Offline Jozhik_2
          Jozhik_2 (Jozhik) 19 September 2020 14: 41
          0
          Comrade, and if all of them are all at once beaten by a "novice" so that they do not further degenerate and do not rot the planet - do you think the Lord will forgive?
          1. Oleg Rambover Offline Oleg Rambover
            Oleg Rambover (Oleg Rambover) 19 September 2020 20: 42
            -1
            No, he will not forgive, to burn in a fiery hyena.
        3. Eduard Aplombov Offline Eduard Aplombov
          Eduard Aplombov (Eduard Aplombov) 19 September 2020 20: 56
          +1
          the answer for the club: I am a marginal in the service for the pan, what wit and brilliance of thought, the Soros political workers have nothing new or anything, don't they? and spar your nonsense according to last year's manuals, do not you notice for yourself?
          You, aggressive, called yourself smart and conscientious, only society does not recognize you for them, you are ridiculous and absurd in your aggressiveness and stupidity, you chatter the same thing, you are not able to see and look beyond your horizon.
          You are ordinary noisy provocateurs hiding behind the tinsel of words
        4. The comment was deleted.
        5. The comment was deleted.
      2. The comment was deleted.
        1. The comment was deleted.
          1. Eduard Aplombov Offline Eduard Aplombov
            Eduard Aplombov (Eduard Aplombov) 19 September 2020 20: 59
            0
            why should I or about me write, take your advice personally and the world will return to balance
    2. Rashid116 Offline Rashid116
      Rashid116 (Rashid) 19 September 2020 13: 37
      0
      By the way, the argument about drugs. Only the journalist was shot by the whole world. In our city, the anti-drug department was completely disbanded, the scandal was to the skies. These creatures set up a laboratory in front of their windows, in a simple way, but what to encrypt from themselves))). And they closed everyone who didn’t hit, throwing the very drugs, well, they hired. They also threw them to competitors and those who buy from them. Google-Naberezhnye Chelny, if you have not already combed your hair. We had all the resources, hardly polished to shine.
      1. Cudgel Offline Cudgel
        Cudgel (Dubina) 19 September 2020 14: 48
        -4
        Famously, however. And then, in the courts, at least one case fell apart or the judges, as always, pushed it, on the basis: there is no reason not to trust a police officer?
        In the capital with this, as it were, softer. The main income of the police, well, among other things, is going to the Night Club, where there are junkies and they take everyone who is under the influence, and there are, alas, a lot of them. And then the money goes out from the parents, now, I don’t know the rate, but it was 240 rubles. Therefore, such Night Clubs cherish and do not close and promote their "non-main activity", but you have to somehow feed. Why I know, a classmate had to borrow this amount, her son got caught. And then the lawyer told me how this system works. The risk is much less than tossing it up and cooking it yourself. Here, we are ahead, the Capital!
        1. Rashid116 Offline Rashid116
          Rashid116 (Rashid) 19 September 2020 15: 13
          -2
          As those were burned, they stirred up another topic, generally global, well, by our standards, of course))). In short, the narik is firing, they load him, like give someone "control" and you are free, and he is chasing instead of you. on "heartburn" and depresnyak he is ready for anything, well, he thinks indistinctly, is carried on. Submits his friends or someone left, they swaddle and go with this idiot (of course))) is not a rather big time. So on the way to court sentences begin from judges through lawyers, for a very substantial amount of money or to cut the term. Also basically a scammer, but not always. In the course, because a classmate and a friend of his son, just on this caught. The boy just finished school, left for seven or eight years old, I don’t remember exactly for a long time, it’s coming soon. ” took (for six years the boat has not even launched into the water, I have no patience to sit and wait for one fish for half a day))), it was generally leaked by a childhood friend.
          1. Cudgel Offline Cudgel
            Cudgel (Dubina) 19 September 2020 15: 51
            -4
            We have that too. If the person is in the drug dispensary or there was an administrator in this case. That is the scheme, they catch a narik and ask him to throw a bag of dope, who has already lit up on this (to a friend, of course). Narik with a bag comes to visit such and quietly puts it in the apartment, and then the police, attesting witnesses. They caught two of them, they really were junkies, but they were quiet. Both have already left. When I asked one and the other what he would do with the one who set him up, they gave up. Both are very quiet. I certainly would not have let it down.
            But the safest for them and the money is still the Clubs, there is no need to invent multi-pass combinations and shares with the judge.
            The worst thing is that it is impossible to prove anything, the courts are at the same time. Not only on Narik affairs, but on any. The policeman is always right.
            The ECHR only remains, but it looks like it will be shut down as well.
            Do not quite understand. Have you got a friend - a poacher with a dope or a fish?
            1. Rashid116 Offline Rashid116
              Rashid116 (Rashid) 19 September 2020 16: 41
              -1
              With a foolishness, his childhood friend asked me to cut something out, like the drunk got tired of it already, so they "tantrolled" for eight years. Two years later, we go to the dam (Nizhnekamsk hydroelectric power station) and go to the dam. one, two tails, I give the rest to them))). I don’t sell it, but I burst it myself, and the next day it is no longer fresh for me.
              1. Cudgel Offline Cudgel
                Cudgel (Dubina) 19 September 2020 17: 22
                -4
                Thanks, okay.
                The main thing is not to leave health in the zone.
                In pursuit.
                What I said about a classmate who needed a son to redeem 240. So this answer came to them. She is a good girl, but her husband is ... He (the husband) himself is from a dense village, where to go like that, only to the cop, and healthy in the riot police. He served in the OMON, regularly drove the opposition, but refused to go to Chechnya, he was very afraid. He himself said that his only early retirement is interested in the relative stability of the cops. True, he was not noticed in bribes, if he took it very, very little. I came out of service at 000 or 36, now I don't remember, I was happy as an elephant, he still laughed at us. I immediately went to the Guard at Mosgaz, his wife also worked there in a small leadership position. The family was not poor, even by Moscow standards, she had 38 and he had 150 + pension. But they lived widely, she had resorts, 000 times a year, two foreign cars and a mortgage. Therefore, when the son was tied in cash, they did not have.
                I know he went to the cops, probably shaking him with a crust, so he got off at 240, and they could have put his son in prison. Yes, after this incident, I began to treat the Valiant Militia differently. Until the system itself hits them, it is difficult for them to reach them.
                We go to the Oka, near Kashira, and the Volga in the Dubna region, but there are few and frightened fish there, you can not catch anything in three days. If there is time, then near Kasimov, on the Oka, there is already a better bite, medium perch, pike perch, sometimes large, record 2.7 kg. And a pike in the ducts.
                1. The comment was deleted.
    3. Ivan Ivanov_20 Offline Ivan Ivanov_20
      Ivan Ivanov_20 (Ivan Ivanov) 21 September 2020 21: 05
      0
      You might think that Russia won a lot of courts in the EU ... :)))
  12. The comment was deleted.
  13. shinobi Offline shinobi
    shinobi (Yuri) 19 September 2020 05: 42
    +5
    Threatening withdrawal from the ECHR. When payments were suspended in 2017, the council was instantly blown away. So you never know what they are blathering there.
  14. Jozhik_2 Offline Jozhik_2
    Jozhik_2 (Jozhik) 19 September 2020 14: 32
    0
    It's a shame that Russia has never sent Europins in a non-diplomatic language.
  15. Marina Mylnikova (Marina Mylnikova) 19 September 2020 21: 37
    +2
    Sorry, I was against the amendments, especially regarding the ECHR, and much more. But the amendments are in our country, they were smuggled in from us, and what does Europe matter, what are our laws? Which there are and are. This is generally our business. If you don't like it very much, let's go and do something. But at this moment, and in subsequent seasons, it will most likely not matter to me what and how they fixed from cool to mat. Russia is inexplicable.
    But, sorry, come out of Paris with your amendments to our amendments?