“Illegal state of the USSR”: why are Russia trying to “recapture memory”?


The flagrant demarche of the judge of the Constitutional Court, Konstantin Aranovsky, who allowed himself to express his dissenting opinion on one of the rulings of the Constitutional Court with rude attacks on the Soviet Union and declare that modern Russia should have nothing to do with this “illegally created country”, makes you think right away about a few very important things. First of all, about who and why it is so necessary today to turn us all into "Ivanov, who do not remember kinship," again injecting into the blood of the Russian people the poison of anti-Soviet condo?


It’s also the time to think about how long, in fact, the anti-state “fifth column” will feel completely safe and comfortable in our country. And, most importantly, until its representatives continue their stay in the most public positions, turning them into stands and horns for their own Russophobic rhetoric?

"Guardian of Russia?" No, her mortal enemy


It is entirely possible that it might seem to someone that Mr. Aranovsky, who pours out his bile and hatred on the USSR, which he calls “repressive-terrorist” and “illegal party-state power formation” only an anti-Soviet and anti-communist, but at the same time - an ardent patriot of today's Russia, today's Russia. This is by no means the case. What, if you think about it, does this figure, in my personal opinion, call upon his statements and actions to not only discredit, but completely discredit the high rank of judge? To ensure that our country does not consider and do not think of itself as "the successor of totalitarian power," that state that it "does not inherit, but only replaces with itself in its territory." In his conviction, the "guilt of the state of socialism" for its "unforgivable atrocities" is "immense and unbearable in the literal sense of the word." Moreover, he declares the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics not the state at all, but, as was said above, a kind of “power formation” created “completely illegally” ... According to Aranovsky, having renounced it, our country will not “bear the blame for Soviet repressions ", and (attention!)" to replace the Soviet state. " Well, well said a lot. An outstanding example of pseudo-legal casuistry. Why is it "pseudo"? Yes, because any true lawyer knows for sure: without duties there are no rights, without responsibility there is no inheritance. The Russian Federation does not and does not want to have anything in common with the USSR? Aranovsky, by the way, in all seriousness proposes to consolidate such a position legislatively and almost constitutionally, according to the experience of “civilized Germany and the Czech Republic”. Well, great - let's see what this could lead to.

If, God forbid, take for the program of action the appeals of a judge of the Constitutional Court who played an “accuser of totalitarianism”, then it should be considered that in 1945 the USSR “illegally formed” took and defeated Germany, which had absolutely legal and constitutional power. After all, the NSDAP and Adolf Hitler came to power not after an armed uprising, like the communists so hated by Aranovsky, but by the most legitimate means - as a result of the free and democratic expression of the will of the German people. Therefore, what? Please give Kaliningrad to Germany. With an apology and sharing, preferably. What's next for us? The legitimate authority of imperial Japan, rudely violated by the "red hordes"? Ay-yai-yay ... How bad it turns out! We take a saucer with a blue border and humbly bring Tokyo the Kuril Islands and what else did she manage to ... fool the Japanese in 1905-1907 the "legitimate authority" of the Russian Empire so adored by the judge judge. Well, we are their successors, it seems, according to Aranovsky it turns out? It is unlikely that it will be possible to return Finland and Poland “under the scepter” (especially with such “sovereign husbands” as our “hero”), but to pay reparations and indemnities to all kinds of petty trash screaming along our borders about “Soviet occupation” "Will have to be in full. In a queue to line up, with the same Warsaw at the head. And this is, literally offhand, the first thing that comes to mind. The fact that after listening to Aranovsky, it is necessary first of all to demolish the tomb of the Unknown Soldier and to erect monuments to the Vlasovites, I will not say anything - the language does not turn to develop this topic. Chur me, chur! And how to celebrate Victory Day now - after all, everything was illegal ?!

With whose voice is the “song”?


As is usually the case with our domestic liberal public (and Mr. Aranovsky to her after some sort of “coming out”, even write to the prophets!) So that she does not try to broadcast with pathos or without it, it will only be a repetition of “adult uncles” with Of the West. And there now sounds such a chorale on this particular topic - at least take out the saints. Here you are, The Economist:

Russia is trying to cling to a fake memory, since the present destroyed the USSR!


The author of the mentioned opus deals with a topic that would seem to be completely non-political - describes a sweet private museum in Novosibirsk, in which life and atmosphere of the very beginning of the twentieth century are recreated. However, the conclusions at the same time, the daredevil, makes simply furious:

The Communists, tearing to pieces the family history of Russia with their man-made disasters, destroyed so much in the country that even the imaginary past “catches” the Russians ...


Well, what is it for? And here's what:

Vladimir Putin is rehabilitating the USSR and Stalin, because he does not see the future of Russia!

- The Guardian already writes.

Everything is much simpler, more rude, more straightforward: “the evil and ugly dictator Putin” is engaged in the formation of a “new version of Russian patriotism based on the“ heroic ”and“ bright ”aspects of the Soviet past” solely to preserve its own eternal power! Didn't you know? So gentlemen the British will thoroughly explain everything to you! However, the pages of The Guardian completely pour out the soul and our, seemingly compatriot, Mrs. Irina Shcherbakova, presented as "co-founder of the organization" Memorial ". How this lady is nostalgic for the “holy 90s”! What hosanna sings to them! You can disobey ...

And about “millions of people who demanded freedom and democracy”, and then “every day they felt more and more alive and free”, recalls, and even about Tsoi with his “We are waiting for changes” ... Right now I’ll cry! True, the light-eyed Mrs. Shcherbakova did not stutter about what followed. About the destroyed and trampled country, about just these very millions of “living and free” people who later fought in a quagmire of poverty, hopelessness and horror of “perestroika”, about drug addiction, alcoholism, crime that soared dozens of times, it is silent. Well, as you can see, personally, so plebeian problems did not affect her in any way. But she deigns to argue that “terrible Putin” dares to call the collapse of the USSR “the biggest geopolitical catastrophe” of the 1989th century, flatly refusing to accept as the greatest achievements of mankind “the liberation of Eastern Europe, which took place in XNUMX, the fall of the Berlin Wall and the end of the Cold War ". What a nightmare - Russians today perceive these “great events” as “defeat”, “shame” and even betrayal! And all because “modern Russia has no concept regarding its future”, well, except for the conviction that we must stop repentingly crawling on our knees in front of the entire “civilized world”, but we should get up and go our own way, without looking at every minute him. This is horror, not a concept! Look what you’ve decided to get up ... Well, and so on and so forth. Bild:

Putin revives the cult of Stalin in Russia!


The Atlantic:

Chernobyl is a reminder to the whole world about how good it is that the USSR collapsed.


It’s a tragedy. Ancient Greek ...

By the way, this familiar to us theatrical and life term literally translates as "the song of the goats." Well, this is so - by the way, I had to ... The goat’s chorus ..., excuse me, "denouncers of totalitarianism" does not cease, on the contrary - more and more voices are woven into it. Now - not just from Russia, but from the very tops of one of its authorities - the judiciary. Honestly, the fact that the Kremlin reacted to Mr. Aranovsky’s trick rather quickly, even surprised me somewhere. Could again "not notice." The reaction, however, is so-so - Dmitry Peskov declined to comment on this matter - they say the judge has every right to express his personal opinion. Well, at least he stated that Russia "is the legal successor of the Soviet Union, both de jure and de facto." Already bread. They didn’t keep silent - thanks for that. Although, in truth, venturing a constitutional reform of historical proportions, Vladimir Vladimirovich, right, might be worried about what “remarkable” cadres, it turns out, are in our Constitutional Court. On the other hand, it is quite possible that the whole reason for such a sharp speech by Aranovsky lies in the reform! According to the president’s proposals, as far as I remember, the number of judges in the Constitutional Court should be reduced, and decently - from 19 to 11. But are we really dealing with the most prosaic manifestation of a petty and selfish resentment against the government? Very, you know, maybe - our gentlemen are liberals, you just have to "take it for granted" - for a purse, for a post, for jamon with parmesan, they begin to roar so that any beluga will envy. Is it really ?!

However, be that as it may, the signal is more than characteristic. And he testifies that it is time for our authorities to finally decide. Moreover, in the style of the well-known not-so-decent joke about portals and a cross. Something needs to be worn, and something (or someone) should be removed hurriedly and categorically. A state that considers Victory Day its most important holiday, shrine and eternal pride cannot tolerate entities in the highest echelons of power that do not see anything in the past of our country but “unforgivable atrocities”, blackness and shame. Not categorically combined. Here it is - either one or the other. And the Kremlin seems to have less and less time for a final choice.
Photos used: Andrew Gomzyakov / flickr.com
Ctrl Enter

Noticed oshЫbku Highlight text and press. Ctrl + Enter

24 comments
Information

Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must to register.
I have an account? Sign in

  1. steelmaker Offline
    steelmaker 18 February 2020 09: 38
    +5
    • 6
    • 1
    On the other hand, it is quite possible that the whole reason for such a sharp speech by Aranovsky lies in the reform! According to the proposals of the president, as far as I remember, the number of judges in the Constitutional Court should be reduced, and decently - from 19 to 11.

    And you might think, before that the JUDGES were CHOSEN from us? Putin himself appoints everyone !! JUDGE in RUSSIA is not an elected position, but appointed !!
    Even here on the site, the level of education of journalists and visitors is higher than that of presidential advisers. Conclusion:

    The king is good, these are the boyars are bad.
    1. A.Lex Offline
      A.Lex (Secret information) 18 February 2020 12: 07
      0
      • 2
      • 2
      I put the minus. I explain why: every nation deserves its ruler. Therefore, there was a time - we deserved our Mishka-labeled, Borka-drunk, and now Putin ... Who will come next - history will tell.
      1. A.Lex Offline
        A.Lex (Secret information) 18 February 2020 12: 10
        +1
        • 2
        • 1
        Well, now in the case:
        A judge who advocates undermining the foundations of statehood - depriving him of his rank, diploma and opportunity to occupy leading positions LIFE (for he cannot repent - is at the age when a person is no longer able to change his worldview).
  2. Observer2014 Offline
    Observer2014 18 February 2020 09: 46
    +1
    • 3
    • 2
    Well, this judge’s demarche made a rustle. It, of course, his proposals can be interpreted as you like. We when the Soviet Union collapsed-what they said as an argument. That Russia is the successor of the USSR. It takes on all the agreements of the USSR and its property abroad. True, the USSR took and paid off the debts, by the way, in full. Of course, I would like to know in more detail how much it cost. Well, in terms of the amount of debt is known. But the amount at that time of real estate. Embassies there and all that. Well, it’s clear that there were much more debts. Now the most important thing. And you can regard this as a judge’s response instead of similar articles. Where a lot of all kinds of words and calls, etc. hi I would ask this judge just one question. How much does a permanent veto member in the UN Security Council cost? All. There are only five of these places. Further, I hope, it is not necessary to explain? By what right did we get this place. Etc. etc. And this judge would deal with his professional duties. But he didn’t climb where he doesn’t understand anything at all.
    1. nov_tech.vrn Offline
      nov_tech.vrn (Michael) 18 February 2020 10: 21
      +5
      • 6
      • 1
      This judge of the Constitutional Court does not need to ask any questions, he already answered everything, under the back of his knee and let him prove his high qualification of a lawyer in the wild and live not from a high salary, but from the money earned.
    2. A.Lex Offline
      A.Lex (Secret information) 18 February 2020 12: 19
      +2
      • 3
      • 1
      Sergey, there is a suspicion that this “judge” simply bought his diploma. For a person with such an education cannot but understand WHAT the threat of renunciation of the inheritance of the Russian Federation of the USSR could be.
      This is only an uneducated person or a REAL Enemy (country, people) will make such statements ... even more so, at such a post.
  3. Afinogen Offline
    Afinogen (Afinogen) 18 February 2020 09: 48
    +4
    • 7
    • 3
    In the words of a guy with a propeller on his back, "Calm, only calm." Ours will be back soon. The USSR will recover. Not long to wait.
    1. A.Lex Offline
      A.Lex (Secret information) 18 February 2020 12: 20
      +1
      • 1
      • 0
      Athenogen, put you a plus, but my comment on you will be sad - do not enter the same river twice ...
  4. Bulanov Offline
    Bulanov (Vladimir) 18 February 2020 09: 53
    +7
    • 8
    • 1
    And what did you want when “thieves” are appointed to “warm” places? Hence, rockets fall, and aliens carry aircraft instead of their passengers. Which year can no longer bring the new An-2 maize to mind? And it all starts with nepotism and from school, when they bring up "Kolya from Urengoy", who repents before the invaders, because they dared to kill them in the USSR, to capture them and forced them to restore the economy destroyed by the invaders.
  5. valeriy7 Offline
    valeriy7 (Valery) 18 February 2020 10: 44
    +4
    • 5
    • 1
    The entire composition of the COP must be dispersed and a new one formed. And then who knows, how many more “Aranovskys” are sitting there. After all, not a single colleague of Aranovsky even squealed in protest against this provocation.
    1. A.Lex Offline
      A.Lex (Secret information) 18 February 2020 12: 21
      0
      • 0
      • 0
      Valera, but where is the guarantee that instead of the former they will not come the same, or even worse?
      1. valeriy7 Offline
        valeriy7 (Valery) 18 February 2020 17: 22
        +3
        • 3
        • 0
        None. But even without consequences all this cannot be left. The consequences should be for the whole composition, for the tacit approval of the anti-Russian position.
        1. A.Lex Offline
          A.Lex (Secret information) 21 February 2020 13: 44
          +3
          • 3
          • 0
          Valery, by the way, it turned out that before working in the Constitutional Court this freak did not work in his specialty NEVER! I wonder - on what basis did he take this place - without any judicial experience? There is someone who promoted it. You need to plant such. And these judges - to deprive of diplomas (NEVER they have not confirmed their qualifications and have not been re-certified !!!), and to initiate criminal cases of fraud!
          1. valeriy7 Offline
            valeriy7 (Valery) 23 February 2020 18: 42
            +1
            • 1
            • 0
            There is a ghostly hope that after the amendments enter into force, both the State Duma and the Constitutional Court will be “dispersed”. wassat
  6. Radikal Offline
    Radikal 18 February 2020 11: 05
    +4
    • 4
    • 0
    It is entirely possible for someone that Mr. Aranovsky, who pours out his bile and hatred on the USSR, which he calls “repressive-terrorist” and “illegal party-state power formation”, is just an anti-Soviet and anti-communist, but at the same time - an ardent patriot of today's Russia, today's Russia.

    And actually - why not? winked After all, someone identified him in such a high authority, probably taking into account his "current", so to speak, patriotism! Therefore, do not simplify the situation. Such characters who do not consider themselves patriots of the USSR, but exclusively the current liberal Russian Federation, are enough on our site, so there is no need to be surprised. sad
    1. Arkharov Offline
      Arkharov (Grigory Arkharov) 18 February 2020 14: 42
      -7
      • 0
      • 7
      After all, someone identified him in such a high authority, probably taking into account his "current" patriotism, so to speak!

      - But what is the main quality of any judge? Perhaps professionalism, impartiality, if possible, apoliticalism and strict adherence to laws? And also the ability to have your own opinion?
      1. A.Lex Offline
        A.Lex (Secret information) 21 February 2020 13: 46
        0
        • 1
        • 1
        Grisha, tell me - what was his "professionalism", where did he work before the COP?
      2. A.Lex Offline
        A.Lex (Secret information) 24 February 2020 12: 00
        0
        • 1
        • 1
        Well, I knew it! There is nothing to answer!
  7. Radikal Offline
    Radikal 18 February 2020 11: 15
    +2
    • 3
    • 1
    A state that considers Victory Day its most important holiday, shrine and eternal pride cannot tolerate entities in the highest echelons of power that do not see anything in the past of our country but “unforgivable atrocities”, blackness and shame. Not categorically combined. Here it is - either one or the other. And the Kremlin seems to have less and less time for a final choice.

    Here it would be just right to agree with the author, but what about the "galoshes" besides which supposedly nothing else was produced in the USSR ", and the Mausoleum draped every year on Victory Day? winked
  8. Valentine Offline
    Valentine (Valentin) 18 February 2020 11: 54
    +2
    • 4
    • 2
    It’s bad, is it good, but after 1917 our country unconditionally divided into “whites” and “reds”, and this continues to this day, and both sides have been living their own lives for more than 100 years, honoring and preserving their traditions, customs, customs and resentment, but now, as never before, the time for revenge is approaching for those whom the Bolsheviks sent to France, Bulgaria, Turkey, but who still have, together with their descendants, a decent amount lurking in themselves anger and hatred for all the post-revolutionary regimes of the USSR and Russia. The current government with some indifference contemplates all this, at all these Caspar, Kasyanov, Gozman, and the same Aranovskie, with an eye to the light of civilization of the USA and Europe. You can’t even imagine what will happen to Russia and its people when the “former” people come to power through an election or a coup d'etat — the Poroshenko regime in Ukraine and the Pol Pot regime will be simply lamb, and over a century they have accumulated so much hatred and malice that it will last for thousands of years of crematoriums and concentration camps for Russia, and our “guarantor” will dismiss this judge from the Constitutional Court and put him in a higher position, although much higher .... Yes, guys, I already feel in the air that soon it will strike so that little will not seem to anyone, and it will be a terrible discharge and denouement, and tens of billions of "green" just so no one will spend.
  9. steelmaker Offline
    steelmaker 18 February 2020 12: 58
    0
    • 1
    • 1
    A.Lex (Secret Information)
    I agree 50 to 50. Because the same people, agreeing with my comment, gave me a minus, not a plus!
  10. Radikal Offline
    Radikal 18 February 2020 14: 53
    +2
    • 3
    • 1
    Quote: Arkharov
    After all, someone identified him in such a high authority, probably taking into account his "current", so to speak, patriotism! "

    - And what is the main quality of any judge? Can. professionalism, impartiality, if possible apoliticality and strict adherence to laws? And also the ability to have your own opinion?

    Oh oh oh hold me seven! You tell the marines from ... the US Embassy - they may believe this nonsense. Or gullible aunts, and uncles who sit on all kinds of talk shows as extras-cluckers, substituting their ears under the noodles that they are "twisted" by the presenters, with all kinds of "experts." In general, have fun, respect to you! lol wassat
  11. Oleg Rambover Offline
    Oleg Rambover (Oleg Rambover) 19 February 2020 01: 04
    0
    • 1
    • 1
    What is an "illegally created country"? In my opinion, for a professional lawyer it’s an extremely unprofessional statement. Country of lovers. Rogozin, Mudko, etc. And so in all areas.
  12. 69 Offline
    69 19 February 2020 05: 25
    +2
    • 4
    • 2
    Another client of the synagogue trampled on the memory of the USSR, it does not seem suspicious to anyone that all the negativity about the USSR, Russia and Russians comes precisely from them, their most serious crimes against the people of the USSR and Russia, the Zionists are trying to chat with the banal transfer of arrows from their person to anyone along the way, vparivaya legend of the linden Holocaust, pulling a sheep’s skin on the wolf.